Popular on Food52
11 Comments
penelope
February 17, 2017
Not to pile on, but carne asada and rajas are much more Mexican than Salvadoran.
Also, I think you mean the "sight" of frozen food, not the "site".
Also, I think you mean the "sight" of frozen food, not the "site".
Greenstuff
February 17, 2017
Just to take some pressure off the interesting discussion about regional and historical colonial Indian food, I must say that I was startled by a Dulce de Leche recipe for Manchester by the Sea!
Riddley G.
February 17, 2017
Hi Greenstuff! That choice isn't about the dulce de leche, more so the icebox cake itself!
Greenstuff
February 17, 2017
Of course, and I say it with well-intentioned humor. But as someone who's eaten my share of meals in Manchester by the Sea, startling none the less! I figured they were embracing multiculturism up there. Not a bad thing.
Stephanie S.
February 17, 2017
What? No squid ink pasta for Arrival? I think i'll be doing some Samba & Tapas for La La Land and mini shredded carrot rolls for Elle (sans broken toothpicks!).
Riddley G.
February 17, 2017
Unfortunately we don't have a photographed recipe for squid ink on our site! I love your thinking though.
Susan
February 17, 2017
This is not in any way meant to shame or embarrass anyone, I understand this a light-hearted article. Food52 has been making a great effort to include diverse voices and cuisines, and which is great! However, it seems like after yesterday's great article about the complexity of Indian food, and the flattening of identities that often happens in food writing, some of these are tone-deaf.
It might be a difficult process, but we all need to do better, I look forward to an inclusive and diverse Food52.
It might be a difficult process, but we all need to do better, I look forward to an inclusive and diverse Food52.
Riddley G.
February 17, 2017
Hi Susan,
Thank you for your note. This, for one, is not meant to be tone-deaf—I'm sorry you felt that way. Yes, the process towards diversity is difficult and will happen over a long-term period, in a meaningful way. As I was writing this, I found myself wishing the actual dish shared in that pivotal diner scene in Moonlight was on our site (because of your comment, I am linking to the dish in the scene, pollo de la plancha). For Lion, I searched for a jalebi recipe to use, however all we had was an Iraqi zengoula recipe. Although this dish is similar, I didn't feel comfortable using it and merging and assuming similarities between two very different cultures. I wish we had both of those recipes. Because, you're right: My colleague Mayukh's article was wonderful. And we do need more that: more article coverage, more recipes, and, in general, to be better—and for it not to be hard to do so. We will continue to push ourselves to be better in our coverage, writing, and recipes. And I hope you stick with us through the process. Thank you, again.
Thank you for your note. This, for one, is not meant to be tone-deaf—I'm sorry you felt that way. Yes, the process towards diversity is difficult and will happen over a long-term period, in a meaningful way. As I was writing this, I found myself wishing the actual dish shared in that pivotal diner scene in Moonlight was on our site (because of your comment, I am linking to the dish in the scene, pollo de la plancha). For Lion, I searched for a jalebi recipe to use, however all we had was an Iraqi zengoula recipe. Although this dish is similar, I didn't feel comfortable using it and merging and assuming similarities between two very different cultures. I wish we had both of those recipes. Because, you're right: My colleague Mayukh's article was wonderful. And we do need more that: more article coverage, more recipes, and, in general, to be better—and for it not to be hard to do so. We will continue to push ourselves to be better in our coverage, writing, and recipes. And I hope you stick with us through the process. Thank you, again.
Panfusine
February 17, 2017
Dev Patels character (the younger version) would not have heard of Chicken TIkka Masala (which traces its origins from the Punjab), I'd suggest one of Rinku Bhattacharya's recipes instead!
Riddley G.
February 17, 2017
Thank you for alerting me to this! Although I lived in India for a good portion of my life, I still need help at times placing dishes and their origins properly. I've swapped out the recipe for one from Rinku Bhattacharya, as you suggested! Thank you, again.
Panfusine
February 17, 2017
Rice and vegetables would be an apt choice, Saroo Brierly was adopted from an orphanage in Calcutta, and this particular dish would very likely have been one that was served up at the institution.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.