This Savory Twist on Apple Pie Turns It into a Main Dish

In the spring of 2015, I packed up my rolling pin and traveled from my rural home in Washington State, to the Big Apple to do all the baking for the Art of the Pie photo shoot. Each evening, photographer Andrew Scrivani would ask me for the backstory of each of the pies he would be shooting the next day—he wanted each image to capture the feeling of the story.

One of my favorite recipes, a Sausage and Apple Pie, is evocative of apple harvest time. I told him about community cider pressings and potlucks, crisp air, and the scent of the first woodstove fire of the season.

Photo by Andrew Scrivani

Over the eight days we shot the book, it was not unusual for me to have five or more pies in process at any given time. Whether blind baking a crust, whipping egg whites for a meringue, making custard filling, or rolling out dough, I was doing my best to keep track of it all. I had placed a saucepan on the stove to reduce some apple cider for my Sausage and Apple Pie but lost track of it while weaving a lattice top for a berry pie. When I turned my head to check on the cider, I saw that it had nearly caramelized—not quite what I wanted. I removed the saucepan from the heat, and when it was cool enough, took a taste. There was no burned flavor so I decided to forge ahead in order to keep to the very packed baking schedule.

Shop the Story

When it was time for a lunch break, the Sausage and Apple Pie was placed on a big table already covered with ones from the previous day’s shoot. I was still in the kitchen finishing up and overheard someone call for a bottle of wine and glasses. Good sign, I thought. I pulled up a chair to the table, hoping that the pie hadn’t been a complete disaster, and saw only one slice left…and some very happy faces. I took a bite and smiled, too. That extra time the cider had spent reducing on the stovetop had resulted in a pie with great depth of flavor. I immediately amended my original recipe to include this fortuitously happy outcome.

Photo by Julia Gartland

Use a favorite pork sausage, a mix of tart and sweet apples, and a flavorful apple cider or juice. The liquid will intensify in flavor, much like boiled cider, when reduced. I like to pair this filling with a cheddar cheese crust either with or without a bottom crust. Don’t worry if there is extra moisture released in the bake from your fresh juicy apples. That bottom crust will soak up the delicious flavor.

The Magical Mini Guide to Cozy Weekends
View Guide
The Magical Mini Guide to Cozy Weekends

Whether you're in the mood for some soup-simmering, leaf-peeping, or nothing at all, your dream weekend awaits...

View Guide

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Becky Koenig
    Becky Koenig
  • Evergreengirl
  • Thomas Draths
    Thomas Draths
  • Kelly Wingard
    Kelly Wingard
  • Kate McDermott-Art of the Pie
    Kate McDermott-Art of the Pie
Kate McDermott is the author of ART OF THE PIE: A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO HOMEMADE CRUSTS, FILLINGS, AND LIFE (The Countryman Press/W.W. Norton 2016). She lives in Port Angeles, WA where she is at work on her next book KATE'S CAN-DO COOKBOOK, EASY AS PIE RECIPES FOR EVERYDAY COOKING to be published Fall 2018. Follow Kate at www.artofthepie.com


Becky K. September 27, 2019
Wondering if this is best served warm or at least room temp? Thinking about making it the day before and wondering if serving it cold should just be weird.
Evergreengirl October 1, 2017
Kate, have you made this gluten free? I'd love to make this for my family, but have no idea how to make a cheese-based gf pastry. We have the last of our local pork from Sequim and a mix of some delightful Booth Canyon apples to use up!
Thomas D. September 17, 2017
I'm making this tonight. Is it worth trying to pub it up and serve with a gravy and/or peas?
Kate M. September 17, 2017
I'm not sure that the peas and gravy would go well inside of the pie, Thomas.
Thomas D. September 17, 2017
Oh! I just meant alongside, like a pub-style pie. Just popped it out of the oven and looks excellent. Thanks for the recipe!
Kate M. September 25, 2017
My pleasure Thomas. Kate
Kelly W. September 16, 2017
This looks delicious and I look forward to trying. Do you consider it a dinner/lunch main course?
Kate M. September 17, 2017
I usually serve it for supper or lunch as a main course, Kelly. I hope you will enjoy it.