Baking Club

The Best Pie Weight Substitute Is Already in Your Pantry (Nope, Not Beans)

April 13, 2020

A couple years ago in our Baking Club, Leslie Rogers shared a delicious looking batch of lemon bars with a brown butter shortbread base. But what really caught our eye wasn't the creamy lemon filling or the generous dusting of powdered sugar—it was her off-hand comment that she used sugar as a pie weight for the toasty shortbread crust. No surprise that this ingenious idea comes from Stella Parks, whose book BraveTart was a smash hit in the Club.

Sugar pie weights before & after 2nd round of blind baking. Toasty!

A post shared by Stella Parks (@bravetart) on

Parks' details her entire blind baking process over on Serious Eats, where she explains her reasoning for swapping in sugar in place of other types of pie weights:

My kitchen and budget are too tight to accommodate a bag of ceramic pie weights or marbles, and I'd rather save rice and beans for dinner. It's not that weights aren't essential, only that my go-to choice is far less traditional: plain white sugar. For one thing, it's something that any baker has in abundance, and, at seven ounces per cup, it's wonderfully heavy. As a pie weight, sugar completely eliminates the risk of slumping, shrinking, or puffing, and obviates the need for docking. The result? A laissez-faire method that gives me a crust deep and flat enough to hold every last drop of filling.

As you can see in Parks' Instagram photo above, the sugar gets faintly caramelized after a serving a round of pie duty. She suggests cooling the sugar to room temperature after use and transferring it to an airtight container. The sugar can be used as you would regular granulated sugar, but it can also be reserved for a few more rounds of work as a pie weight, until it turns pale tan. At that point, you've made roasted sugar!

Shop the Story

It's sugar with a toasty flavor, and it can be used just like regular granulated sugar in any recipe that would benefit from a little more complexity and a little less sweetness. Of course, if you don't have imminent plans for blind baking any crusts, you can also just skip ahead to roasting sugar all by itself.

Recipes to Use That Roasted Sugar

Once you’ve accumulated roasted sugar from your scrappy pie weights (go you!), put it toward your favorite baked goods and desserts. (Psst: Try stirring a spoonful into coffee or tea, too, for a roastier cup.) You can do a 1:1 swap wherever a recipe calls for granulated sugar, or do a custom mix of roasted and granulated. You’re in charge.

Salted Egg Yolk Pound Cake

Salt-cured egg yolks add a glowy golden hue and subtle savoriness to this moist, fudgy pound cake. The only thing to make it even better? Roasted sugar, of course. And we wouldn’t turn away some sour cream, sweetened with roasted sugar, to plop on top either.

Our Best Banana Cream Pie

Using your pie weights to make even more pie is sort of meta, but let’s roll with it. Our Best Banana Cream Pie is already full of malty, caramely flavors, so the roasted sugar will fit right in. Swap in for the granulated sugar in both the vanilla pastry cream and Nilla wafer crust.

Genius Raspberry Granola Bars

These granola bars are a hit among kids and adults alike. Picture: a gooey, jammy center, surrounded by the nuttiest granola in town. And yes, you can swap out the raspberry jam and pecans for your favorite kind or whatever is around.

Beyond-Sugar Pie Weights

Dried Beans

If you have dried beans in your pantry, these can come in handy as pie weights, too. The type doesn’t matter, so use chickpeas, black beans, pinto beans, even lentils. After using them a couple times, retire them as pie weights and turn them into dinner. (This Instant Pot method is a great place to start.)

Raw Rice

Like beans, rice is a cost-effective pantry staple that works wonders as pie weights. Also like beans, any variety is happy to help out there—short-grain, long-grain, whatever’s not for dinner tonight. Once you’ve used your rice pie weights a couple times, turn them into a toasty pilaf.

Loose Change

Unlike sugar, beans, and rice, this option obviously isn’t edible. But you might still have it around if you search through your wallet and under those couch cushions. Make sure you line the pie dish super well with foil, since you don’t want the coins to come in contact with your crust and impart a metallic taste.

Another Pie Pan

If you own two pie pans, you already have a perfectly shaped pie weight. As with other methods, just cover the dough-lined pie pan with parchment or foil, then place the second, empty pie pan on top. Just like sugar, this will weigh down the crust and prevent it from puffing.

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • jpriddy
  • Jennifer Spencer
    Jennifer Spencer
  • TampaCook
  • Cindy Foreman
    Cindy Foreman
  • Lauren B
    Lauren B
I like esoteric facts about vegetables. Author of the IACP Award-nominated cookbook, Cooking with Scraps.


jpriddy June 2, 2022
Like many others, I have learned to include a bit of freshly squeezed lemon juice for a more tender piecrust. The recommendation: "Make sure you line the pie dish super well with foil, since you don’t want the coins to come in contact with your crust and impart a metallic taste" strikes me as a bit odd. I use parchment when I blind bake because I do not want aluminum coming into contact with any food.
Jennifer S. August 30, 2021
I have a jar full of ball bearings that I use for pie weights. They are very heavy and they get hot in the oven, imparting more heat to the pastry, unlike the ceramic pie weights.
TampaCook November 26, 2020
I tried the sugar method as the article suggested....huge crack across the bottom of the pie when I uncovered it. Not a fan of this method at this point!
Cindy F. July 21, 2020
Don't like these articles that have instagram camera pics. I can't ever open them. Just post the real picture....
Lauren B. April 29, 2020
I will try the sugar weight! It’s exactly the solution to the dilemma of what to use. Now why didn’t I think of that? LOL I won’t tell you what I had been using instead, this sounds infinitely superior. A really great suggestion. Thank you very much!
Barbara N. April 27, 2020
I have a jar full of pennies. I’ve used them as pie weights for years. Let them cool off and then back in the jar.
Smaug April 13, 2020
I've been using the same $1 worth of beans for at least 15 years now, I find the expense bearable and they do exactly what I need done. I don't get the sugar at all; you're hovering dangerously near the liquefaction point, it's far more likely to be spilled when taking it out, or to leak into the crust- can't see any real upside at all
MJprovence April 18, 2019
After making many jars of apricot confiture, there were 100’s of pits. Washed them, dried them in the sun. They have been my perfect pie weights for years.
Bradd S. May 6, 2018
This works so well I love the roasted sugar; used it to make cake frosting yesterday. I always keep a supply on hand after reading about it in Bravetart. Stella Parks has so many inspiring ideas for amateur bakers
Lindsay-Jean H. May 6, 2018
She really does!
Nadia April 21, 2018
I love the idea, but I live in Brazil and our sugar is from cane sugar. Could I use this technique?
Lindsay-Jean H. April 21, 2018
Refined white sugar is the only kind that will work for roasting, unfortunately. You can check out Stella's post on it for more info, here:
Heather Z. April 16, 2019
Claudia T. May 14, 2020
I imagine anything else will caramelize too quickly, melting down into the crust?
HalfPint April 19, 2018
I love the synergy of this :)

Lindsay-Jean H. April 21, 2018
Me too! :)
Dani R. April 19, 2018
Can't wait to try this!!
Lindsay-Jean H. April 21, 2018
Yay! Please report back once you do!