Baking Club

The Iconic Breakfast Dish With More Than 25 Different Names

June 14, 2018

It's a simple dish: it needs just four ingredients (bread, butter, salt, and an egg) and couldn't be easier to make—cut out a circle from the middle of a piece of bread and cook an egg in the empty space. But the name for this iconic breakfast food is anything but simple.

We realized that when Nancy Romaine DeWitt posted a photo of her breakfast, called eggs in the nest in Itamar Srulovich and‎ Sarit Packer's cookbook Golden, our Baking Club's book of the month. A few different names popped up in the comments, and when we polled Club members, "egg in a hole" and "toad in a hole" were the runaway favorites (the former has a slight edge in popularity over the latter). They were far from the only options though, we ended up with more than 25 names for the same dish:

Photo by James Ransom

Eggs in... something

  • Egg in a hole
  • Egg in a hat
  • Egg in a nest
  • Egg in a basket
  • Egg in a window
  • Egg in the eye
  • Egg in a frame
  • Egg in a pocket
  • Egg in bread

Mona Martin Davies says, "My husband calls it egg in a hat. His dad toasted the cut-out circle and put it on top, so it did look like a hat."


More eggs

  • Picture frame eggs
  • Bullseye eggs
  • Betty Grable eggs
  • Bob Smith egg
  • Buzzy egg
  • Egg surprise
  • Peek-a-boo egg
  • Rocky Mountain eggs
  • Pop-eyes
  • Egg in a blanket

Kayla Mize shares: "For some reason, my family called it a buzzy egg when I was growing up. I can't seem to find a reference to that online, so I have to assume this is a weird made-up thing."


Gimme the toast

  • Egyptian toast
  • Sunshine toast
  • Holy toast
  • An egg toastie

Heather McKimmey calls it holy toast, explaining, "it went from a hole for an egg toast to holy toast somehow."


Animals, eyes, and everything else

  • Toad in a hole
  • Birds in a nest/bird's nest
  • Chicken eye
  • Egyptian eyes
  • Moon over Miami
  • Boy Scout sandwich

Erica Stokes Lowther says: "We call it toad in the hole, though I know that the English dish toad in the hole isn't the same at all. And my husband is English. Go figure."


Whew. It's probably time for dessert by now

Did we miss one? Fill us in below.

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Zzz
    Zzz
  • food52
    food52
  • Matthew Dayton
    Matthew Dayton
  • sms
    sms
  • Valerie
    Valerie
I like esoteric facts about vegetables. Author of the IACP Award-nominated cookbook, Cooking with Scraps.

32 Comments

Zzz March 14, 2020
More than 80 years ago, when my husband made this dish for my stepsons, after he cut the hole in the bread, he held it up and winked through it before cooking. Hence, the name "wink sandwich" in our family. I believe that it was his father more than 25 years before that who made wink sandwiches for his toddler only son, making it a family tradition of not quite 110 years. I was astounded when discovering with the advent of the world-wide web that our wink sandwiches had siblings if not twins around the world.
 
food52 January 25, 2020
Am I the only one brought up to call this delicious breakfast dish a “spit in the ocean”? 😂
 
Matthew D. January 22, 2020
We call it a “Pirate Sandwich” in our household.
 
sms January 22, 2020
Hole in One
 
Valerie January 22, 2020
My dad called them "Spit in the Eye" eggs. I am not sure the origins of that name, but I love all the name variations of this childhood favorite!
 
beejay45 December 18, 2019
I learned this on a very early stay at summer camp -- I was maybe six or seven. They called it "One-eyed Susan." :))) Seems like a camping kind of thing -- no need for a toaster, toast and eggs all in one pan, so we've stuck with that name both camping and at home in the kitchen.
 
MrsMehitabel July 29, 2019
I don't remember having these as a child, but I believe my sister calls them ace-in-the-hole!
 
Jeanine April 26, 2019
Hobo egg
 
Rebecca S. December 24, 2018
An egg cooked in a holed-out piece of bread is a split-in-the-eye!
 
Beaulaker December 22, 2018
we call it Cyclops
 
FrugalCat July 11, 2018
Grew up calling it Egyptian Eye. My dad loved those and always wanted me to make him one.
 
Tasha June 22, 2018
To the best of my knowledge, “Shit on a Shingle” is creamed chipped beef on toast
 
K M. June 21, 2018
Gaslight Eggs! I saw that in a movie. In my home, we always called them Eggs-In-A-Frame, however.
 
P M. June 20, 2018
You know what? MY DAD also called them "shit in a shingle"
maybe it was a WWII thing?
 
Charlotte June 5, 2019
I think that usually referred to creamed chipped beef on a waffle. Their recipe for that was not too popular apparently.
 
Cindy F. June 19, 2018
Humpty dumpty eggs.
 
Laurette June 18, 2018
Always called a “gold mine” in our home.
 
Camihenry June 15, 2018
We call it egg in the middle.
 
Sherri M. June 15, 2018
My mom called it Egg a la Hollywood--can't imagine why!! My mother-in-law called it a Miss Francis Egg, after a 1960s children's TV host...
 
Jordann June 14, 2018
Poor man's omelette is what my mom always called them
 
nancy E. June 14, 2018
"Toad in a hole" is sausages cooked in yorkshire pudding batter.
 
Author Comment
Lindsay-Jean H. June 15, 2018
The name is used for both dishes!