Food52 in 5
This Game-Changing Muffin Mix Is the Key to Better Breakfasts
You'll want to make a triple batch.
Popular on Food52
11 Comments
Launa V.
June 9, 2019
I've a bread recipe that I use a lot (I make communion bread for my church). I weigh the flour and use a measuring cup/spoons for everything else as the other ingredients are not as variable as flour (scoop and scrape? sift/scoop/scrape? etc.) but I need to have the correct amount of flour. I'm now vending at a farmers market each month and shall translate more recipes to scaling.
Kay
April 16, 2019
DIFFERENT Kay!
I appreciate the weights. Years ago I (quasi)experimented with dry ingredients. Here in the Richmond, VA area, it can make a HUGE difference on different days or different times of the year. I think the humidity might have something to do with it, but that's just a guess. Plus, different brands can vary ever so slightly in grinds, I think. I always prefer to have weights for baking, because volumes don't seem to produce results as consistently for me.
I appreciate the weights. Years ago I (quasi)experimented with dry ingredients. Here in the Richmond, VA area, it can make a HUGE difference on different days or different times of the year. I think the humidity might have something to do with it, but that's just a guess. Plus, different brands can vary ever so slightly in grinds, I think. I always prefer to have weights for baking, because volumes don't seem to produce results as consistently for me.
Kay
March 7, 2019
This is a good, adaptable recipe, and I've used it several times. A question, though - why on earth do you think weighing things in grams is easier than measuring? I am an American, not a European (where they are used to weighing, I guess), and to weigh in grams I need to get out the scale, put the ingredient in some kind of container, figure tare weight, then weigh it - adding and subtracting till I get to whatever weight I'm supposed to have. And there will still be containers to wash. Unless there is some kind of magic involved, why is fussing with all that easier than getting a cup of flour?
EmilyC
March 8, 2019
Hi Kay -- My digital scale has a tare button that allows me to reset to zero between every addition, so adding large amounts of multiple flours is really easy. I literally pour the flours straight from the container or bag into one bowl, resetting the scale each time. (For me, this is SO much faster, easier, and accurate.) I included volume measurements, though, because I realize that not everyone owns a scale, or likes to use one. Boils down to personal preference, I suppose! : )
Rosalind P.
March 17, 2019
Feel your pain, Kay. But from the opposite direction. As an American baker of (ahem) many decades, I was firmly in the volume tradition. But a very hit-and-miss baker. And it was always even harder to measure when I got to the bottom of the flour or sugar or cocoa or whatever. I finally stumbled on the weight approach when visiting my daughter in London, and for me -- all thumbs with volume -- it was an epiphany. It really is more accurate, especially given the variation in dry ingredient volumes. So I have a digital scale which is always out; it has a tare feature so can reset to zero for adding ingredients. And I yearn for weight measures in all my baking recipes. If you're an expert and used to volume, then I can see the frustration in getting only weights. But it turned me into a sad but laughable baker to an acceptably competent one.
caroline0ne
April 16, 2019
I WOULDN'T BOTHER WITH ALL THAT TRANSLATING. IT WOULD BE WAY TOO TIME CONSUMING.
Launa V.
June 9, 2019
A cup of flour can vary in quantity because of the air to particle distribution. If you sift/scoop/scrape, the amount of flour would be different than if you scoop/scrape. If you jiggle the measuring cup, you'll have to add more flour to the cup before scraping. The great thing about scaling is the consistency because the weight is the determining factor - not the volume. A scale is still useful if using imperial measures: 16oz still weighs 16oz regardless of how much stuff is in the measuring cup. As a Canadian, I had to forget all I know of the metric system when I moved to the USA. I find the metric system a more accurate means of measurement. If you can count to 100 by 10's, you can use the metric system.
Allison M.
January 8, 2022
It’s easier for me to use a scale instead of having to scoop and sweep, due to the fact that digital scales are equipped either the handy tare button, which makes the whole process a joy. I have even marked up all my baking books with weights, which you can find on packaging or manufacturers’ websites. I live in New Orleans, and the humidity can be anywhere from 25-98% here, so weight is the only way to go for me, and it means that I can save myself having a ton of different measuring cups to wash when I am finished! Tare and keep dumping it all into the mixing bowl!
Jane
March 3, 2019
Has anyone measured more add ins? Maybe something with carrots or dates? I need a week’s worth of variations
EmilyC
March 3, 2019
Hi Jane: I've never done carrot-date muffins, but I suspect about 3/4 to 1 cup of shredded carrots and 1/2 cup of chopped dates would work nicely. In general, when using fresh fruit (blueberries, raspberries, diced pears or peaches), I usually add 1 cup to the batter. With dried fruit, no more than 1/2 to 3/4 cup, and same with nuts. Hope this helps!
Join The Conversation