Editors' Picks — Peach Pie or Tart

September  1, 2011

Just Peachy Pie  Peach and Goat Cheese Tart with Rosemary Cornmeal Crust

Any Food52 member is welcome to help us test our Editors' Pick candidates, so go call dibs on the recipe you'd like to test in the comments section below! We'd love to see some new testers in the mix. Don't forget to email us your notes (about 100 words) to [email protected] by next Tuesday at 5pm.

We'll collect your comments, decide the official list of Editors' Picks and publish your evaluation in the headnote if the recipe is selected as an Editors' Pick (with credit, of course!). And even if the recipe you test isn't chosen as an Editors' Pick, please feel free to leave your testing notes in the recipe's comments section. Constructive criticism is always encouraged!


See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • ChefJune
  • hardlikearmour
  • ashleychasesdinner
  • MmmmFood!
  • cinnamongirl
Food52 (we cook 52 weeks a year, get it?) is a food and home brand, here to help you eat thoughtfully and live joyfully.


ChefJune September 2, 2011
hmmm I missed this yesterday, but that's probably okay because I've already planned to make Amanda's tart this weekend, and I don't think my hips could take two tarts....
hardlikearmour September 1, 2011
Looks like Simple Ginger Peach Tart is still up for grabs!
ashleychasesdinner September 1, 2011
I will take Simple Ginger Peach Tart if that's okay?
Sagegreen September 2, 2011
Thanks, hla for noting this and to a_s_p for volunteering to test!
ashleychasesdinner September 1, 2011
I think everything is taken! I appreciate the nomination, and congratulations to everyone else too!!
MmmmFood! September 1, 2011
I'll give the Peaches 'n Honey Cream Tart a whirl.
cinnamongirl September 1, 2011
I'll take the peach & goat cheese tart w' the rosemary cornmeal crust, please!
cookinginvictoria September 1, 2011
If it's still available, I will happily take Petaluma Peach Tart!
coloterp September 1, 2011
I'll take the peach frangipane galette. It's peach season in Colorado which means I'm in absolute heaven!!
Food52 September 1, 2011
Just a few still up for dibs: Peach and Goat Cheese Tart with Rosemary Cornmeal Crust, Peach Frangipane Galette, Peaches 'n Honey Cream Tart, and Poached Peach and Blueberry Tart.
Sagegreen September 1, 2011
Thanks for the ep nomination for my simple ginger peach tart, which I think still is also up for dibs? I won't be able to test this week between post Irene and pre semester! Congrats to all the nominees.
Sagegreen September 1, 2011
Petaluma peach tart, as well as peach and rosemary crumble tart tartin may also be unclaimed?
Emily H. September 1, 2011
These all sound delicious, congrats to the editors picks. I'm swimming in peaches to can, so no baking this week. ;)
Burnt O. September 1, 2011
Cardamom Peach Pie Filling please!
Helen's A. September 1, 2011
Congratulations to the Candidates, these all look fantastic. I'm on vacation and canning up a storm, so I won't be able to do any testing... have fun everyone!
nogaga September 1, 2011
peach and rosemary crumble tarte tatin, please!
hardlikearmour September 1, 2011
White Peach and Lemon Thyme Galette, please!
vvvanessa September 1, 2011
be gentle, please : )
hardlikearmour September 1, 2011
I'm sure you have nothing to worry about!
vvvanessa September 2, 2011
thanks, hardlikearmour! i know you already know your way around a galette!
sticksnscones September 1, 2011
Vanilla Bean Cardamom Peach Pie pleeze!
AntoniaJames September 1, 2011
I'll happily test the Mini Rustic Peach Tart, please! And thank you, too. ;o)
Dabblings September 1, 2011
Yeah! I can't wait to hear what you think!
AntoniaJames September 1, 2011
And I can't wait to make and taste this! A tart for two people? Perfect!! (Alas, my sons are now both off at college now.) ;o)
wssmom September 1, 2011
Now that power is restored, may I test Farmer's Market Peach Crumb pie?I
Food52 September 1, 2011
Sorry Dr Babs got there first. Do choose another recipe to celebrate the restoration of your electric!
wssmom September 1, 2011
LOL slow power! Just Peachy Pie?
Food G. September 1, 2011
I'll take the peach - Basil - Goat Cheese Gallette! Whoot!
drbabs September 1, 2011
Farmer's Market Peach Crumb Pie please!
ashleychasesdinner September 1, 2011
Oh Yeah drbabs!! Can't wait to hear what you think:)