Popular on Food52
15 Comments
Suzy S.
December 11, 2021
Please note that dried currants are NOT a third kind of grape. They are…currants, an actual fruit used in both fresh and dried forms. Currant (not grape!) jelly, anyone?
Thanks to British baking shows, most American bakers know this, but sultanas is the UK term for golden raisins. I am not all that fond of Xmas pudding and prefer my great aunt’s Scottish sultana cake. Of course, I had to alter that, too, as I have an inability to tolerate citron or glacéed fruits. I use dried cherries with the sultanas instead.
Thanks to British baking shows, most American bakers know this, but sultanas is the UK term for golden raisins. I am not all that fond of Xmas pudding and prefer my great aunt’s Scottish sultana cake. Of course, I had to alter that, too, as I have an inability to tolerate citron or glacéed fruits. I use dried cherries with the sultanas instead.
Lori L.
December 11, 2021
Hi Suzi, That's fascinating. I'm from Canada and here sultanas are different from golden raisins. In our grocery stores there are three types of raisins 1. Thompson (the dark raisins that we all ate as children in the brand-name little boxes) 2. Sultanas which are slightly lighter and have a great taste 3. Golden which are yellow-coloured and used by bakers in oatmeal cookies or bran muffins. Are you in the U.S.? So interesting to learn what things are called in different countries. I lived in SC for three years, but never noticed what type of raisins were available. I do remember the butcher laughing at me requesting suet for plum pudding!
Suzy S.
December 11, 2021
Well, this will teach me to rely on family lore and habit, rather than research! When I went looking for answers to your questions, I found that dried “currants” are indeed a grape and not made from fresh currants — my deep apologies to the author!
It appears that the naming conventions for raisins do differ between the US snd commonwealth nations, as the article below makes clear. I would love to try Turkish sultanas sometime.
https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/raisins-sultanas-currants#what-they-are
It appears that the naming conventions for raisins do differ between the US snd commonwealth nations, as the article below makes clear. I would love to try Turkish sultanas sometime.
https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/raisins-sultanas-currants#what-they-are
David H.
December 6, 2020
Is British Christmas Pudding different than what we call “fruit cake” on this side of the pond? I hate fruit cake and this steamed pudding doesn’t look too appetizing to me neither. I would rather make cinnamon buns or an apple pie.
Lori L.
December 6, 2020
David, Christmas Pudding has a similar flavour from the dried fruits and alcohol, but has a moist cake binding the fruit. American fruitcake, in my experience, is hard and solid. But if you don't like the fruitcake components, you wouldn't like this. The British alternatives for steamed puddings (really traditional for Christmas) are steamed cranberry pudding or even steamed carrot pudding. Wouldn't be Christmas for us without it. We usually add a chocolate cake, typically a buche de noel, for the kids.
Stevie T.
December 6, 2020
Well, fruit cake and Christmas pudding are very different, but think of them as cousins, as there's considerable cross-over in the ingredients. I would think that the chances are that if you dislike one, you'll dislike the other. My advice would be to buy a small one rather than going through the palaver of making one in advance. I used to buy mine from Marks and Spencer, but they don't have a brick-and-mortar location in North America anymore, and I was able to buy mine from a church that made them as part of their Christmas fundraising. Anyway, I do encourage you to try it just once - you might quite like it!
BTW, what some posters have called brandy butter you will see in some cookbooks as "hard sauce" - either because of the amount of booze or the consistency of the sauce, I don't know - and to my mind is absolutely necessary.
BTW, what some posters have called brandy butter you will see in some cookbooks as "hard sauce" - either because of the amount of booze or the consistency of the sauce, I don't know - and to my mind is absolutely necessary.
Randi
December 6, 2020
I made one every Christmas for years. The kids loved the dramatic flambé but unfortunately didn’t really like to eat it. I served it with brandy butter. Yum!
Lori L.
December 3, 2020
Nancy, My Canadian grandmother also served a caramel sauce, almost identical to yours, with her plum pudding. I married an Englishman, whose family insist on brandy butter (for Americans that's equal parts butter, icing sugar and a generous amount of brandy whipped, then chilled and put on a portion of pudding with a knife, like you would add butter to a roll.) I make a traditional pudding almost identical to the royal recipe, but without beer and I add some lemon and orange zest. For Americans, the nearest equivalent to British mixed spice is pumpkin spice, but I generally use cinnamon and allspice. And you MUST make this ahead--that's why it refers to making it on stir up Sunday, before advent. Like fruitcake, it ripens. Just refrigerate after steaming. On the day of serving, just microwave about 5 minutes. And if you don't have a traditional stoneware pudding bowl or a mold, just use a corning mixing bowl. So happy, Nancy, to hear that someone else shares our tradition of caramel sauce with plum pudding!
Nancy H.
December 4, 2020
Lori, I'm Canadian and my mother's pudding and sauce recipe was actually published as part of a compilation cookbook here in the mid-seventies - not necessarily a likely connection, but it's fun to ponder such random possibilities all the same! Adding citrus zest (instead of mixed peel?) sounds like a great addition by the way - definitely thinking that it might be pud instead of the torte this year even though the size of our table will be greatly reduced. We are more fortunate than many this year and I'm working on being grateful in advance for better times ahead - stay well and safe!
Nancy H.
December 3, 2020
My mother was English (she LOVED the Queen :)) and always made a pud for Christmas. It had many of the same ingredients as this one, but she also added 1 cup each of grated carrot and potato (she said this "lightened" it up), as well as dates and 2 kinds of nut pieces (pecans and filberts, usually). No breadcrumbs, slightly less suet and a lot less alcohol..... however, the crowning glory was the Caramel Rum Sauce which was the only thing that persuaded my Dad to eat it (small amount of pudding/large pool of sauce). Her recipe combined 1 cup brown sugar, 1/2 cup maple syrup, 1/4 cup water, 1 cup heavy cream, 2 oz of rum (or 4) and a dash of lemon juice. Stir this together over med. heat until well blended, then simmer for an hour or so - keeps for ages in the fridge. It's not a thick sauce, but the whole point for me is the big puddle :)) I've tweaked it over the years and add 1/2 tsp. of salt and quite a bit more lemon - taste for the sweet spot to bring it into balance.
All of the ingredients that the Royal family pudding leaves out are the ones that I would leave out of my Mum's (except for the veg) so will give this one a try as I'm not personally fond of glace cherries or steamed nuts. For what it's worth, I've been making something called Cranberry Torte from a vegetarian cookbook by Celia Brooks Brown for years as an accompaniment to our rum sauce. I just found it here in a slightly different presentation for anyone who might be interested - essentially just fresh cranberries glued together with a bit of batter which works very well with gluten-free flour. VERY popular at the Christmas table in my house!
https://boroughmarket.org.uk/recipes/cranberry-crisp-with-toffee-bourbon-sauce
All of the ingredients that the Royal family pudding leaves out are the ones that I would leave out of my Mum's (except for the veg) so will give this one a try as I'm not personally fond of glace cherries or steamed nuts. For what it's worth, I've been making something called Cranberry Torte from a vegetarian cookbook by Celia Brooks Brown for years as an accompaniment to our rum sauce. I just found it here in a slightly different presentation for anyone who might be interested - essentially just fresh cranberries glued together with a bit of batter which works very well with gluten-free flour. VERY popular at the Christmas table in my house!
https://boroughmarket.org.uk/recipes/cranberry-crisp-with-toffee-bourbon-sauce
AntoniaJames
December 3, 2020
Nancy, your mum's pud and (gasp!) that caramel rum sauce sound divine! I can see using that sauce for all kinds of treats. Thank you so much for all of these great tips. ;o)
Nancy H.
December 4, 2020
Thank you Antonia - just realized that I should have said 1/4 tsp. of salt instead. I don't really measure these things, but that's a safer start!
mela
December 6, 2020
Nancy, am interested in your cranberry crisp but can't seem to get the link to work. Could you repost?
Nancy H.
December 7, 2020
Hi Mela, If you highlight the above address and copy, then paste it into your browser, it should bring you to a place where you can click on the link itself. Failing that, just search Borough Market, then the recipe itself from their homepage. Good luck!
Join The Conversation