Popular on Food52
22 Comments
bluet
September 10, 2013
I had no problems following the basic directions, just keep an eye on it and check for doneness starting at about 15 minutes. Both the oil and garlic were delicious with everything from croutons to salad dressing to sautes.
Dahlia V.
August 28, 2013
I went and tried this recipe. Great tasting. One thing is important to know: heating the olive oil until it boils is dangerous. It is so hot that when I dropped the garlic cloves into the boiling oil, they exploded and spattered boiling oil all over. I removed the oil from the heat immediately and let the oil and garlic "coast". The smaller cloves were burned bitter. A better way to cook it is to start heating the oil on medium heat and when the steam from the garlic starts bubbling the oil, reduce the heat to low simmer. Cook until tender and garlic is buttery - like roasted garlic. The garlic will not burn or become bitter.
Phyllis G.
August 28, 2013
so sorry there's so much confusion with this. let me try and clarify. i agree. you should never drop the garlic into boiling oil. i always cover the cloves with room temp oil and place it on the back of the stove before bringing it up to the boil. another option is to do it low and slow in the oven. you can even put a lid on it. but i don't like that water from the lid drips down into the oil. but that's by far the safest. let me know if you try it again!
saltyone
August 27, 2013
call me stupid but I still don't know what the initial heat on the olive oil with the garlic should be to reach the boil without running the risk of burning, etc? should it be a very low light a mid-level flame or high?
Phyllis G.
August 28, 2013
just crank the heat high, don't walk away from it, and turn down to a simmer right when it comes to a boil.
saltyone
August 27, 2013
I'm a bit confused, how high should the initial heat be for the garlic?
Phyllis G.
August 27, 2013
Bring to a boil and immediately reduce to the lowest simmer to prevent splattering. Simmer until cloves are cooked through (they’re done when a paring knife slides right in) -- it should take 10 to 20 minutes, depending on the size of the cloves. Take pot off the heat and cool. Alternatively, bring to the boil and take right off the heat. This will take longer but you will have the same results.
bernice C.
August 26, 2013
Would the dish be the same if the garlic heads were roasted instead of simmering them in oil? Particularly if you're not planning to use the oil from the confit? thanks
Phyllis G.
August 26, 2013
would totally work to roast the garlic. but it does take longer. and you won't get the garlic oil. and the flavor and texture is a bit different. but it's equally as wonderful.
Dahlia V.
August 25, 2013
Do I understand correctly that the olive oil covering the garlic cloves is heated until the olive oil boils? That temperature is between 405 and 572 degrees F, depending upon the grade of the oil. I fear the garlic will be cooked bitter. Or do you just heat the oil until the garlic begins to vent steam into the hot oil?
Phyllis G.
August 26, 2013
i never check the temp. just bring to the boil. turn to a simmer. you can even turn it off when it comes to the boil and let it coast (it will just take a bit longer). i've had beautiful results every single time. try it and let me know!
Marna
August 25, 2013
OMG, OMG, OMG-----brilliant use for the 2 million cherry tomatoes in my garden. Using the 2 lids to slice the little beggars is such a simple solution for slicing little round rolling things, including olives and grapes!! We're going to do this tonight on personal size grilled flatbreads.
Naz D.
August 21, 2013
Delicious and beautiful to look at. School has already started for us - I have a couple of hours to myself. This is what I want and this is what I shall cook. Without interference from the six and under crowd. Get Lucky has been playing non-stop on KCRW. Thanks Phyllis!
Phyllis G.
August 21, 2013
you're welcome! back in school already? how wonderful. enjoy the peace and quiet. i love KCRW.
Dawn R.
August 21, 2013
I'm wondering which olive oil to use for the confit -- my workhouse one, mid-range or high-end? My gut instinct is mid-range, since it's being heated, but I hate when you try to skimp and end up with subpar results.
Phyllis G.
August 21, 2013
yes. probably mid-range is best. and avoid any olive oil that's really bold (bitter or herbaceous) because it will overpower the lovely garlic flavor.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.