Paula Deen
So I know this is not a food question per say, but it is a question about the responsibility of public food figures. I'm wondering what this food community thinks about the Paula Deen/ type two diabetes controversy. As much as I am dedicated to a healthy lifestyle and all for healthy food for children, especially in schools, I'm not sure it's a chef's responsibility to promote healthy eating. And if the problem is the way she cooks, I'm not certain her personal health should be part of the equation. Thoughts?
Recommended by Food52
33 Comments
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/opinion/sunday/bruni-paula-deens-revelation.html?_r=1&hp
Personally, I find her to be entertaining. Very warming. But I don't like how she's handling this situation. It seems she's taking full advantage when she could use this diagnosis to really help others.
http://www.foodpolitics.com/
His questions are very simple and remain unanswered:
* Is your weight up, down or the same since you were diagnosed, and since you started daily Victoza injections? (Which costs $500 per month.)
* What about daily blood-glucose readings and A1C (a several-months’ average of blood sugar) since diagnosis and since you started using Victoza? At least, have they gone up or down on a percentage basis?
* Before using a ridiculously expensive medication whose long-term efficacy has yet to be established, did you try other cheaper, highly effective drugs — like metformin, which helped lower my own daily blood sugar from 350 to a healthy 90-110, and costs less than $20 a month?
And as he points out, eating fatty foods doesn't cause the disease, and it can turn this realitively benign condition into a lethal disease.
Read more: http://www.nypost.com/p/news/national/good_lard_paula_just_spit_it_out_yQklfIAF44InxfRsZA48fK#ixzz1k1n6Rt00
i think her life story is inspiring too but that doesn't mean that because you've had a hard life you just do whatever and eat whatever you want, promoting it on a cooking shows, in restaurants around the country, and in products, without consequences to your health at some point. i mean, she did cover this up for a few years so she must have known the fall-out would be bad.
she's not in control of what people eat just like anthony bordain isn't in control of whether or not people smoke or drink. he also doesn't have his own line of cigarettes or liquor that he's pumping to the public like deen's products and restaurants and now medication. do a public service announcement for free about diabetes, but don't try to make MORE money off of something you've done to yourself. fyi, bourdain has been off cigs for at least 3-4 years with the birth of his daughter...the alcohol, well he likes to drink. i'm pretty sure we won't see bordain pushing AA in the future like deen is pushing/promoting her insulin.
What's sad is that there are a whole lot of obese people out there that are going to think all their health issues are ok as long as they just take the "paula deen insulin." sad, but probably true.
As for Bourdain piling on, at least he quit smoking some time ago.
Even Anthony Bourdain a great critic of Paula Dean...loves Fat and smokes, 'drugs', Alcohol, etc. He's no pardon of health food..it's bascially the same thing that Dean does---Enjoy food eat with friends.
It's kinda sad to see him going public on a 'quest' to degrade her..while he eats bone marrow fat, praises pork fat, and drinks a lot of alcohol. Seriously, what's the diffrence here, except one wears a suit, and has orgasms over a fatty pork product, and the other is a woman with gentic differences for a disease..(well she's capitalizing on that tho). A. Bourdain is far much a whore for high fat stuff as in "oh Bone Marrow" Or
"Oh fatty pork meat". He even did a show about the 'porn' of high fat stuff and did the same thing as a 'joke'..except never too insult his sources.
She's a Food Network person...So I give it that for what's it's worth, that's her gig.
What's strange is that Alton Brown didn't get half the kicking about when he adopted an extrime "healthy" diet.
He looked sick. This is not an image of a healthy person.
The Today Show, which gave me pause.
I also was a bit turned off by the way she
Kept trying to get a plug in for her son's show.
All in it for the money?
I seriously question the study mentioned by meganvt01. Regardless of the specifics of Deen's case, food is an important piece of the picture.
While I never eat the food she promotes, I do have respect for her story. A single mom with agoraphobia trying to provide for her family in the only way she knew how - cooking her food. She made lunch baskets and eventually it all snowballed into a celebrity career. She's a celebrity because of her sparkling personality and winning life story - not because she is promoting a heart healthy lifestyle. I don't expect every chef/cook who makes it big promoting their story and the food they learned as a child to suddenly change course when they become a public icon. Caveat emptor - we all know fried butter isn't good for you. But really - Anthony Bordain who smokes a pack of cigs and gets wasted on every show really shouldn't critize another TV personality's health choices.
Voted the Best Reply!
At some point Paula Deen went from being a Southern culinary historian and turned into a cooking circus sideshow. She’s created the kitchen equivalent of the Amazing Mr. Lifto. She peddles increasingly-gnarly combinations of ingredients that may create facsimiles of classic Southern dishes, but really end up like something out of a culinary funhouse mirror – all distorted and more than a little scary.
Fundamentally, what she peddles food-wise and product-wise amounts to a really unhealthy lifestyle. She could have used her platform as a “food celebrity” to bring awareness to the ways in which people with Type 2 diabetes can and should make changes in their lifestyles, how they can do so in reasonable ways, how they can use at least some of the hallmarks of Southern cooking as I understand them (use your garden, make things from scratch, try canning) to make changes that can have a positive impact on their health.
Instead she’s using her image – and now even her health – to make a quick buck. That’s fine when it comes to selling people a cheap-o mattress for way more than it’s worth, but when it comes to people’s health…? To be fair…it remains to be seen how this all plays out, and maybe I’m just being cynical, but I find it hard to believe that the woman who came up with Ham-Banana Casserole is going to change her tune any time soon.
Bourdain's statement "Thinking of getting into the leg-breaking business, so I can profitably sell crutches later."