Perfect ice cream sandwich cookie?

I promised the four-year old we could make ice cream sandwiches today. I have a normal go-to chocolate chip cookie recipe but I'm looking for one that would go well with the ice cream - a little chewier, softer, larger. Suggestions

  • Posted by: Niknud
  • February 4, 2012


Mr_Vittles February 4, 2012
I like chocolate chip cookies or sugar cookies. Either way I like to bake them 90% of the way through so that do not become too brittle for sandwiching.
mrslarkin February 4, 2012
This makes awesome ice cream sandwiches. We're making them tomorrow!

The chubby chewy would also be good with ice cream:

And Merrill has this one which sounds amazing:
Recommended by Food52