Dissolve it in hot water first
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
hardlikearmour is a trusted home cook.
It doesn't sound very salvageable. If you're going to try, I'd dissolve the gelatin, and mix it through the salad.
Could the entire salad stand to be warmed up? I'm thinking bloom the plain gelatin in cold water while you heat the salad. Once the gelatin in the salad melts, stir in the plain gelatin until it dissolves.
Might even work if the reason it didn't set properly was due to fresh pineapple…
Pack your bags!
Cozy Fall Weekend Trips
Turmeric Sugar Cookies
What's New in the Neighborhood
Buttery Sheet Pan Pot Pie
The Hits Keep Coming