I'm going shopping. What's your favorite cookie sheet?

786e3e14 8b3a 4880 8d90 5b54b1d69e67  dsc04267
  • 918 views
  • 6 Comments

6 Comments

Blissful B. January 9, 2011
And the winner is.....the Nordic Ware Cookie Sheet with Silpat. Thanks everyone!
 
POTATO January 9, 2011
After reading an article in Cooks Illustrated magazine comparing various cookie sheets, I purchased their top pick - The Vollrath Co Cookie Sheet. Cooks Illustrated actually called it "The Holy Grail of cookie sheets". I can't say enough great things about, I don't have any complaints, in fact I think they are wonderful.
 
testkitchenette January 9, 2011
I use what Mrs. Larkin uses also. I have bought them before at Costco but also find them easily at restaurant supply stores.
 
drbabs January 9, 2011
I think mrslarkin is the master and you should listen to her. I don't have any of the sheets she recommends, but my very favorite cookie sheet is made by Calphalon. I also recently tried a non-stick sheet by Circulon that is inexpensive and works well. (But it has a weird circular pattern on it.) And I have double-thickness insulated cookie sheets by Wilton that I'm iffy about. I pretty much only use them to make meringues.
 
chrissyb January 9, 2011
I have a Nordic Ware cookie sheet that I love but I have always used a silpat or mat on top of the sheet to protect it.
 
mrslarkin January 9, 2011
For most cookies, I usually use heavy-duty sheet pans, like this one: http://www.amazon.com/Nordic-Ware-Bakers-Half-Sheet/dp/B000G0KJG4/ref=sr_1_1?s=home-garden&ie=UTF8&qid=1294595662&sr=1-1

But I also use these cheaper ones too for some recipes: http://www.amazon.com/Good-Cook-Non-Stick-Cookie-Sheet/dp/B0026RHI3M/ref=sr_1_2?s=home-garden&ie=UTF8&qid=1294595702&sr=1-2
 
Recommended by Food52