What is the trick to growing Basil?
Every year I have a beautiful patio garden with pots of tomatoes and peas that grow like crazy. For some reason, I'm not successful at growing Basil. I've tried sun, part sun, shade, excellent soil (same that I use for all the other pots with great success) and it still turns black and shrivels up. What should I be doing?
Recommended by Food52
64 Comments
In my opinion, all of this discussion about fertilizers, worm casings, whatever are meaningless.
Soil has its own unique characteristics, but it does not clearly reflect weather patterns, humidity, temperature (degree days), sun exposure, etc.
If you can find a community garden in your neighborhood, it is worth walking through that area and talking to the gardeners. That will probably be more valuable than any sort of soil analysis report you get from a university lab.
But that's just me...
The last time I did a soil sample, it was free. It's also extremely educational. Soil and climate are both interesting. Neither should be taken as gospel.
Good luck with your move. I figured you'd be wise enough to consult other sources. Mostly wanted to point it out for other readers who might not have thought about such avenues for information.
Microclimate is a big deal, but a lot of people online don't seem to recognize that. Hopefully they will stumble upon this discussion and take some notes.
Anyhow, best wishes for your move.
Someone signs up, asks a question, then NEVER EVER POSTS AGAIN. This is essentially a drive-by. Maybe someone gives an answer, but in 99% of these situations, the original poster provides ZERO feedback. That feedback is critical in helping others in the same situation understand whether the proposed solution worked. It legitimizes the community's purpose.
But no, radio silence is the typical response. It's mostly just TAKE, TAKE, TAKE.
Admittedly, this reprehensible "non-behavior" is not unique to Food52, but is pretty typical of any online Q&A forum.
Appalling.
Yes, yet another good reason to consult your local nursery, master gardeners or neighbors.
Cultivars can vary substantially. Usually certain ones grow better in any given place than others (temperature, precipitation, soil composition, length of growing season, amount of sunlight, etc.).
That said, much of it is determined by one's specific situation. Basil grows great at the nearby community garden, yet I am unable to grow it at my place because my little condo unit is shaded by large trees. Some other units at my complex have better sun exposure, some others are probably even more in the shade. That's just the way it is.
In most basil-friendly growing regions, you should stagger your sowings by two weeks to provide consistent supply of basil leaves. Don't plant everything at once.
Source: Sunset Western Garden Book
Here in NorCal, basil grows well in all but the foggiest coastal areas.
Voted the Best Reply!
There are no real tricks to basil. I can't guess how you get it to turn black and shrivel up- freezing it or spraying it with paint thinner would work, but I'll assume you're not doing that. It is an annual and has a very specific life cycle- it won't grow at all well until the soil warms up- after it's developed 2 sets of leaves it will grow quite quickly in warm weather. After a while it will go into it's flowering cycle- branches will elongate and leaves will get smaller, and then flowers will develop; the flavor is pretty much ruined at this point; I usually grow 3 or 4 crops in a year (I have a long growing season). Flowering can be delayed to some extent by using high nitrogen fertilizer- fish emulsion is probably best for home growers(caveat- the combination of fish and basil smells seems irresistable to some types of flies). Limiting sun exposure, can also delay blooming, but will also reduce the productivity and quality of the herb. It's soil needs are simple. Any good potting soil should work fine- it would take something really egregious to kill the plant- though something with manure included would be best, and of course it needs good drainage. My best guess as to what is happening to your plants is poor drainage, which can kill the plant quickly; the problems you're having just shouldn't occur under anything like normal conditions.
1. A mixture of organic potting mix and mushroom compost. I'm sure this isn't the prerequisite for basil to grow well but our basil went absolutely crazy with it.
2. We had a tomato plant growing with the basil and because they are companion plants, they helped each other grow.
3. If you are starting with seeds, thin the seedlings out because overcrowded plants don't grow as well.
I hope that helps! :)