using salted butter v. non-salted
i'd like to hear from anyone who feels using salted butter yields or doesn't yield a different baking result than just adding salt to the recipe. i'm specifically looking at a french walnut tart that uses salted butter in the dough and in the filling. Tx
Recommended by Food52
13 Comments
I agree with ustabahippie -- using salted butter in baking results in better distribution of the salt. When I use unsalted butter, I can usually detect the individual grains of added salt on my tongue as little sharp spots, like the salt on a saltine cracker. That's not always a bad thing -- for example, it's what I would want in a digestive biscuit. But usually it's not preferred. That said, it's not going to ruin what you're baking either way as long as you adjust the added salt to account for what is or isn't in the butter.
Besides, how can we have a cluster of opinions without different points on the graph?
I don't know if the amount of salt in their salted butter is the same now that it was then, or if all salted butters are comparable in their salt content.
I've recently thought about making 2 batches of chocolate chip cookies (using the recipe for Toll House cookies on the side of the bag), one with salted butter and one without, to see if there is a noticeable difference. More importantly, I'd like to see if the salted batch tastes more like the ones we made as kids - with salted butter. ;o)
Interesting in itself and what Burkhardt says.
Also makes me think of a possible conference of the people who have staffed various Good help lines. Sort of like Comic-Con for foodies.
But once you go beyond the original region or country, salt and water percentage in butter can vary and, with it, cooking and baking results.
So, either do a test batch with salted butter and if the results are good, make notes (what brand of butter, percent salt) and repeat.
If results not to taste, use unsalted butter and measured salt.