What is a good toasty to make?
What is a "toasty?"
are you talking open face grilled cheese sandwiches? Then My vote is for Pimento spread and bacon.
or cream cheese with brasiola and olives
Ham and cheese is a favorite at home, especially when topped with a fried egg. To make things more interesting, I sometimes spread a thin layer of vegemite and/or sriracha on the bread before topping it with cheese.