Make Ahead
Meta Given's Pumpkin Pie
Popular on Food52
213 Reviews
Lea S.
December 25, 2020
We love the smooth custard consistency of this pie and the flavor is to die for.
Sandra L.
November 30, 2020
I made this for thanksgiving and would love to leave a couple comments! I thought the recipe had way too much sugar. I tasted the filling before baking and I wasn't really getting any pumpkin flavor, so I added in another cup and 1/2 of the pumpkin puree - this caused my filling to be a little off in consistency so I think you should reduce the original recipe's sugar amount by 1/2 if not more. Second, because of the additional pumpkin I added the pie didn't really set, the consistency was off so I would recommend baking longer if you are going to add more pumpkin. The recipe wasn't very spice heavy so I added the a Pumpkin Pie Spice (no sugar added) from Trader Joe's into the filling and it made it yummier!
Lori
November 30, 2020
This is the 2nd year I've used this recipe for the filling. I agree about the sugar and flavor. I did replace 1/2 the sugar with coconut sugar and the consistency was fine. I also added 1/4 tsp of nutmeg and 1/4 tsp of clove to up the spice factor.
This year I decided to make the pie into bars. Using a 17 x 13 baking sheet, I doubled the crust and filling. Lining the pan with parchment and using an almond & tapioca flour based gluten-free crust... did not need to blind bake prior to adding the filling. About 35-40 minutes in oven.
Next time, I will triple the filling to increase the ratio of custard:crust. And perhaps use all coconut sugar and reduce the amount by 1/4 to lower the glycemic index...
This year I decided to make the pie into bars. Using a 17 x 13 baking sheet, I doubled the crust and filling. Lining the pan with parchment and using an almond & tapioca flour based gluten-free crust... did not need to blind bake prior to adding the filling. About 35-40 minutes in oven.
Next time, I will triple the filling to increase the ratio of custard:crust. And perhaps use all coconut sugar and reduce the amount by 1/4 to lower the glycemic index...
bettinashoe
November 30, 2020
I am surprised that you felt the pie had too much sugar as this pie has the same amount of sugar as Libby's recipe posted on their can and less sugar than most pumpkin pie recipes. I, personally, did not find it overly sweet at all and, after the pumpkin is caramelized, it has a wonderful, rich taste. I made quite a few pies for Thanksgiving customers and I had rave reviews from everyone. I'm sorry you didn't care for it. We all have different tastes and this one has become my "go to" pumpkin pie recipe. As I, and a few others, indicated, we added more spice to the pie as it doesn't call for much. I guess that is why there are thousands of recipes out there, everyone has different tastes
cecilia
November 27, 2020
I made this yesterday and it is a fantastic pie recipe! I was wondering though, could you substitute the the milk to part milk part cognac?
Carole J.
November 27, 2020
Hi,
I’m a first time pie maker and you made me a hero! I have been making your Galettes and enjoy how easy they are to put together - love the rustic look - but this pie was just the bomb! I just love pumpkin and have never tasted such a incredible custard. I used lapadia's simple Himalayan Blackberry Pie crust, also on FOOD52 - and this pie crust was the living end. Thank you! Happy Holidays!
I’m a first time pie maker and you made me a hero! I have been making your Galettes and enjoy how easy they are to put together - love the rustic look - but this pie was just the bomb! I just love pumpkin and have never tasted such a incredible custard. I used lapadia's simple Himalayan Blackberry Pie crust, also on FOOD52 - and this pie crust was the living end. Thank you! Happy Holidays!
Cel W.
November 26, 2020
Made this after watching Amanda's IG video. It was fantastic! I used a premade pie crust and it was so flavorful! I will surely make this again! I even used canned coconut milk for the cream and oat milk for the milk and it turned out perfect with those subs. Great recipe!
Anne G.
November 26, 2020
Just had this tonight for our thanksgiving dessert. This has got to be the best pumpkin pie recipe I have made. So silky and smooth. Absolutely the best.
Melissa
November 26, 2020
Light, silky, delicious pumpkin pie filling. Used Melissa Clark's butter crust -- perfect! I blind-baked the crust for 15 minutes at 450. I will make this again!
Tara M.
November 20, 2020
I love this recipe and have been making it for a few years now. This year I’m planning to make it into smaller tart-sized pies to drop round at my friend’s houses since I can’t have anyone over this year.
Any idea how to adjust baking time?
Any idea how to adjust baking time?
bettinashoe
November 20, 2020
That is a really good question. You seem to have a bit more experience with this pie than I, and I have had to adjust the time to cook quite a bit longer than suggested for the pie to be done to my satisfaction. If you are making individual (I believe it is 4") size tarts, I would start checking the pie for doneness at 20 minutes. I really doubt it would be set before that. If you had to cook your full-size pies longer than the suggested time, that should give you some idea as to how much longer you need to cook a tart (I would half the additional cooking time, as a starter). I know the filling is "almost" cooked after the liquid ingredients are added to the pumpkin due to the temperature of the pumpkin, but I still prefer my pumpkin a bit more set than the 20 minute timeframe, the author suggested, provided. It is an awesome pie filling, however, and this is now my "go to" as it has such a wonderful taste and texture.
Tara M.
November 23, 2020
Thanks! I experimented with it a bit over the weekend and found that in my oven, 15 minutes did the trick. However, it was also necessary to blind bake the crust beforehand as without doing that they came out a little too soft to stand on their own without the tin. I might experiment with using a proper tart crust for the next batch.
bettinashoe
November 23, 2020
Thanks for the info. I was thinking about some individual pies for this year since it is a small gathering. Each person could have a choice of desserts and not a lot of pie leftovers. I blind bake my crusts also. My first attempt was not blind baked and the bottom crust was soft and not at all what I was hoping for. After a blind bake, the crust under the pumpkin was still flaky and tasted great. Did you use Erin McDowell's crust recipe? I am so hooked on that.
bettinashoe
November 11, 2020
Although this recipe was posted quite a few years ago, I just discovered it. I am a professional baker and I hate pie, not all pie, just fruit-filled pie! Really, it's not the pie I detest as much as crust. I have never cared for its taste and avoid eating custard/cream pies with pastry crusts because of this. While getting ready to do holiday pies a few days ago, I wanted to up my pie crust in hopes that when I sample my pie (I always do just to make sure it is perfect), I would not gag on the crust. I came across Erin McDowell's all butter pie crust, found it interesting and made it. Then, I happened (accidentally) upon this pumpkin pie recipe and thought it looked intriguing. I had never heard of caramelizing my pumpkin, but it sounded like something I would have done, had I thought of it. I made the sample pie yesterday and tasted it today. Oh my, this is the very best pie I have ever tasted. I even like, no I love, the crust. It is flakey, even on the bottom, and so rich tasting. The pumpkin filling is smooth as silk and cooks up beautifully to a deeper color than traditional pumpkin pie. On first inspection, you may think it is underdone, but it is not. Once chilled, it sets up wonderfully. I will probably add a wee bit more spice (maybe clove and/or fresh nutmeg) as the spices do not have a discernable taste, however, some may want that as it is strong on pumpkin. The types and amounts of spice called for are probably acceptable to most people, even me, but in commercially sold pies I think it needs to be stepped up just a bit. It is an excellent filling recipe which goes wonderfully with Erin's all-butter pie crust. I did not blind bake the crust and thought I would regret that, but the bottom crust is golden and flakey and tastes perfect. I am so happy to have found both of these recipes. Enjoying the taste of what you are baking makes it so much more rewarding.
Little P.
November 14, 2020
HI. Did you use a metal or glass pie plate? I baked my pie for about 40 minutes. The filling was set but bottom was underdone. :(
bettinashoe
November 14, 2020
I used a cheap, aluminum pie plate. I did cook the subsequent pies a bit longer than the time stated. On the original pie, I was a bit worried about the crust not getting done, but it was fine. In the pies I made after the original one, I took the extra step of parbaking the crust to ensure it was completely cooked and the parbaked crust was even better than the original. I also put foil around the crust edge the last 10 minutes or so of the cooking time (after the filling was added) and I turned the oven down to 350 during that additional cooking time. As I indicated I would do, I added about a 1/4 tsp of clove and the same amount of freshly grated nutmeg. It made the pie taste perfect. I thought my second pie was overcooked because it had a few cracks in the filling so I kept it to see how it worked with the parbaked crust, extra spices and longer cooking time. It was excellent as the crust was super flaky and remained that way. I was a bit turned off by the softness of the original pie, although I know it was fully cooked, it just looked a little underdone. It set up better in the fridge, but I still prefer my pumpkin fully set, not soft. Did you use Erin's all butter crust? It is a fantastic recipe and I received a ton of compliments specifically on the pie crust. In fact, everyone who has ordered pie (so far) has been really impressed. You probably know this, but in case you do not, the pie tins need to be cooked on a baking sheet which gives it more even heat on the bottom. I hope this helps.
Little P.
November 14, 2020
Hi, thanks so much for your detailed response. I might try in a metal pie plate next time and par-bake. I was excited about the recipe as it stated you probably wouldn't need to par-bake but oh well. I did try that pie crust and I didn't love it but that might be my own fault. For whatever reason, I just dumped the entire 1/4 cold water into the dough rather than drizzle it in and I think it could have used less water.
I too added more spice, 1/4 t nutmeg and 1/8 t clove, and more salt than she suggested in the filling. This is a keeper, but next time I will just make sure to par bake. Thanks again and I hope you have a lovely holiday.
I too added more spice, 1/4 t nutmeg and 1/8 t clove, and more salt than she suggested in the filling. This is a keeper, but next time I will just make sure to par bake. Thanks again and I hope you have a lovely holiday.
Sarah H.
November 26, 2020
I just wanted to chime in and say you are right on all accounts. I am not a professional, but I’m a pie lover, and very proficient pie baker, and I just discovered this recipe this year as well, and I too made this on Erin’s all buttah crust, which has been my go-to crust recipe for a few years now and it really is an excellent combination. And that you are absolutely right that the pie may appear undercooked, but 30 minutes at 400 degrees really is all that necessary. Oh and I added a small amount 1/4 of a teaspoon cloves, nutmeg, and turmeric for the more “traditional” pumpkin pie flavor, but I might try it without next time just of curiosity.
Mike E.
October 10, 2020
Of all the pumpkin pie recipes I've tried over the years that never bowled me over, this one is a real game-changer. Carmelizing the pumpkin is genius. Not only does it intensify the pumpkin essence, but by cooking out all that excess moisture, you get an incredibly silky smooth filling with zero residual cracks. Since they were out of heavy cream at the market, I subbed out light whipping cream and it's still plenty rich and creamy. I added a 1/4 teaspoon of cloves and a light dusting of freshly-grated nutmeg to warm up the spices a bit more. As for the crust, I decided to swap out a conventional pastry pie shell for a simple crushed gingersnap crust from the following Food52 recipe: https://food52.com/recipes/24768-pumpkin-pie-with-gingersnap-crust-and-cinnamon-whipped-cream. Absolute raves all around.
Asha S.
November 30, 2019
I made this pie for Thanksgiving using an all butter crust. Added 2 tablespoons of Grand Marnier in the filling. It was divine, very light and silky. Definitely a keeper!!
JenniferJ
November 28, 2019
Love this! I might add slightly more of the warm spices next time. What sets this apart for me is the wonderful soft custard achieved with the high temp and short time in the oven. I notice a lot of commenters baking it a lot longer. I encourage trying it exactly as written--just use an oven thermometer to make sure your oven is hot enough. I don't know that I noticed a huge taste difference due to cooking the pumpkin but the hot filling, cold crust, hot oven, short time--great result in terms of silky custard texture.
judy
November 13, 2019
Never thought about caramelizing the pumpkin. Now, only 1-3/4 c pumpkin--what do I do with the rest in the can? about 3 Tbsp? Also, I have never had much luck with pie crust. going so far one year as to trying about 8 different pie pans--very expensive experiment. Last year a game changer--bake the crust ON TOP of the pie. Amazing. No soggy crusts. I now do this exclusively, forgetting the bottoms altogether. Decades of raw pie-dough or soggy dough. No more. I finally gave up the quest for cooked crust in a pie--even pumpkin.
Alex
November 14, 2019
I used the whole can, which is 1&3/4 cups according to the nutrition label. I wouldn't sweat a few tablespoons of puree, if your label is different.
Deedledum
November 14, 2019
Did you try blind-baking first instead? I do it almost always because I don't like soggy crusts either.
tosacem
November 21, 2019
Either my brain isn't working this morning or??? I don't understand what you mean by--bake the crust ON TOP of the pie?
Alex
November 21, 2019
Filling goes in the pan first. If using any crust, it tops the filling. I'd delete it altogether for a custard pie. I make crustless quiche all the time because I'm not a big fan of pie crust.
Lori
November 13, 2019
This looks interesting and sounds like it tastes amazing. Question: the written recipe calls for 1 3/4 c pumpkin, however the video lists 3/4 c. Which is it?
JenniferJ
November 27, 2019
That's pretty much the same thing as a normal can is 15 oz. I used the whole can b/c I didn't want a dab of pumpkin left. It was no problem to use the whole 15 oz can.
JenniferJ
November 27, 2019
(Sorry--thought you meant 3/4 of a can versus 1 3/4 cups. It's the 1 3/4 cups--or almost the whole can. Use the whole can.)
Smaug
November 12, 2019
Interesting- this is very similar to the Maida Heatter recipe I use for my very occasional pumpkin pie (she covered pretty much everything)- precooking the puree is new to me. For the record, her baking method is preheat to 450, pour warm filing into frozen shell, bake 10 min. at 450, turn down to 350 and continue baking 30-40 min.
Austin B.
November 22, 2018
The Pie was amazing, the whole table agreed it was the best they'd ever had. The referenced pie dough was awful, though. Way too liquidy. Ended up tossing it and throwing together the All Buttah Pie Dough.
Serena D.
October 2, 2018
Love the cooking method
I have never read a recipe that cooked down or caramelized the pumpkin!
Consistency spot on
Next time I will use less sugar
-I used glass pie plates and did not blind bake the crusts. They were perfect.
I have never read a recipe that cooked down or caramelized the pumpkin!
Consistency spot on
Next time I will use less sugar
-I used glass pie plates and did not blind bake the crusts. They were perfect.
See what other Food52ers are saying.