Make Ahead
Martha Stewart's Slab Pie
Popular on Food52
40 Reviews
Beautybaby
August 9, 2023
In the 1980's, it took me a long time to save up $35 to pay for Stewart's flagship cookbook, "Entertaining". It was the priciest cookbook ever but it was lavish and I was excited. I wrote out 2 recipes to take with me for a destination
Christmas with friends: Chestnut Puree and Honey Curry Dip. Both, were so bad, that I had to toss them. Seriously. I wondered: Had I copied the recipes incorrectly? I hadn't. To this day, I feel Stewart owes me for the cost of that cookbook AND the ingredients that were a total waste, not to mention the effort to peel those pounds of chestnuts!!!! It wasn't until the late '90's that I happened to watch E True Hollywood on Martha Stewart. A New York Times food writer who had reviewed the cookbook when it came out was interviewed on the show and said how strange it was that although the book was beautiful, ALL of the recipes that she tested for her review didn't work and she ended up giving the book a terrible review. All those years later, I was finally vindicated and ever since that Christmas, decades ago, l've never, and will never, use a Martha Stewart recipe.
Food52, I love you. I’m subscribed to your emails, I’ve made so many of your delicious recipes, and I follow you on Instagram. But a Martha Stewart recipe listed under your “Genius” umbrella??? That’s where I draw the line.
Windischgirl
August 9, 2023
I made this several years ago and it was delicious, but I have to agree with you, BB. I’ve tried my share of Martha baking recipes that were absolute duds: texture too crumbly, dough too dry, flavor combination didn’t work, etc. I appreciate Martha’s design sense; her recipes? Not so much.
bridget
April 15, 2024
I can imagine how disappointing this was! There truly was magic about those beautiful books back in the 1980s, and I loved to ponder as I looked at them. I only used a few recipes—this is often the case—but they were good. I have used Martha's pate brisee from the Pies and Tarts book for years with no trouble—it's terrific. I also love her recipe for Spanikopita from Entertaining.
Tavo
October 15, 2021
This is the crust recipe I use from her site for Cherry slab pie:
3 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
2 1/2 teaspoons coarse salt
1 1/2 teaspoons sugar
1 1/2 cups chilled (3 sticks) unsalted butter, cut in pieces
6 to 12 tablespoons ice water
3 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
2 1/2 teaspoons coarse salt
1 1/2 teaspoons sugar
1 1/2 cups chilled (3 sticks) unsalted butter, cut in pieces
6 to 12 tablespoons ice water
d W.
July 9, 2017
Martha does not measure flour the correct way...she digs it our instead of putting the flour in the cup. I was taught the Cornell way over 60 years ago. If one were t weigh the flour the Cornell way would be closer to spot on. Please give the dry ingredients in weight measurements since many people have not had good luck with Ms. Martha recipes if they measure the Cornell way. There can be a difference in delicate recipes.
Andree
July 9, 2017
not to worry, she won't. Even though everybody else finally is, she won't because she never reads these comments or her blogs. Her minions do the postings (and they are often so inaccurate). I know, I'm being peevish today. But it's all true.
Kojak
August 3, 2022
I, too, get upset when recipes do not include weights.
There is a site I use that converts volume to weight that I find excellent. You enter 2⅓ cups of flour or sugar, or butter, or whatever, and it will tell you what the weight is in ounces or grams, or a multitude of measurements.
http://convert-to.com/conversion-of-ingredients-from-cooking-recipes
There is a site I use that converts volume to weight that I find excellent. You enter 2⅓ cups of flour or sugar, or butter, or whatever, and it will tell you what the weight is in ounces or grams, or a multitude of measurements.
http://convert-to.com/conversion-of-ingredients-from-cooking-recipes
Andree
August 3, 2022
Well, there is a new problem with that. A cup of King Arthur flour weighs less than a cup elsewhere. I learned that after a tragic bread making day with a new recipe. I consulted both the author (who blamed KAF weights) and KAF (who stood by their weights). I also found problems with the conversions. So everybody needs to use the weights they tested or we have to follow our instincts. But these are only recipes. Expensive recipes at times, though, so I am careful what recipes I try for the first time.
Donna
July 3, 2017
I'm really loving the slab pies !! T have 4 apple trees in my yard and it's so much easier to make an apple or peach ( I have one peach tree ) , or rhubarb, have some of that also !! It all goes together!! I was always guilty of packing way too much filling in my pies so the slab works perfectly for me !! Did it on my own first without a recipe, then found this on Food 52 a few years later!! Thanks for so many wonderful ideas over the years!! Love your site !! Love your ability to create a recipe index on this site also !!!
placidplaid
August 11, 2015
The crust had waaaaayyyy too much salt. I think a teaspoon would have done the job.
EmilyC
July 8, 2015
I made a sweet cherry-berry version (4 cups of blackberries, 2 cups of blueberries, 2 cups of Bing cherries) and it was wonderful! I used 1/3 cup of cornstarch and it was the right amount -- the filling was set enough to slice but there was still plenty of juice.
Laura M.
May 2, 2015
I don't have a food processor and so I incorporated the butter and water by hand. After letting the dough sit for an hour when I tried to roll it out it fell apart. I was unable to get it to lift off my board and stay in one piece no matter what I did. Help!
adobeblue
August 9, 2023
watch some basic videos on pie crust making. The technology is the same for round or square pies. It sounds like you did not have enough water in the dough; also you should have put it in the refrigerator once the dough came together and rolled it out when it was cool.
Windischgirl
July 9, 2014
I made a peach slab pie for a friend's graduation party recently and used a half-sheet pan with success. I tend to like the crust a bit thinner so I certainly had more than enough dough. I did find that the ratios for Martha's pate brisee make a very soft and sticky dough, which is difficult to work with; less water (not more than 2/3 c) should make for a flakier crust. I also used about 4+ lbs of peaches and made a lattice top. The pie was such a hit that the hosts requested that I make it for an upcoming party that I'm hosting. That pie is currently raw, in the freezer, and I'm hoping to bake it day of the party. Will let you know how it goes!
Susan N.
October 19, 2014
So...how did it go. I would like to make ahead and freeze for a party in a week.
Windischgirl
October 19, 2014
Pro: flavors were good, and it was a time saver--baked up nice and brown.
Con: I made a lattice top, with strips about 3/4 inches wide, and the edges of the crust broke in my freezer. So presentation was not as attractive. If you make a full top crust, you might be ok.
Are you making an apple version?
Con: I made a lattice top, with strips about 3/4 inches wide, and the edges of the crust broke in my freezer. So presentation was not as attractive. If you make a full top crust, you might be ok.
Are you making an apple version?
Susan N.
October 19, 2014
Yes. I was thinking of doing punch outs of leaves to allow some steam out. Can't wait to try it. Thanks for the info.
Malia Z.
June 15, 2017
Do you use ripe peaches or slightly under ripe? I've never made peach anything before.
Windischgirl
June 15, 2017
Use ripe peaches...even a little overrripe is fine. You want the flavors to be at their peak.
maya
May 24, 2014
may want to understand the capacity of your food processor if you're trying to make the pate brisse all at once… mine was a travesty because not everything blended together because it was too full…but I didn't realize it was overcapacity until it was too late. I know…my fault, it's a 9 cup processor. So I had to try again, in 2 batches.
Andree
October 26, 2013
We've been making these for generations in New England. Men love them because they can grab a slab and take it out when logging or farming.
Ceege
September 5, 2013
I am making this slab pie for a church function. Since I need to make it the day before, can this be partially made and then baked the morning I need it? I would like to make the crusts, roll out the bottom one and place in pan (covered w/saran wrap). Then perhaps get the peaches ready with a tad of lemon juice to keep them from getting dark. Then place both the peaches and bottom crust in fridge. I will mix up the sugar/cornstarch mixture and set aside. Then next morning roll out the top crust and put it all together and bake. I had thought to put the whole pie together and refrigerate, but was afraid the crust would be too soggy to bake correctly the next day. Does anyone have any thoughts on this method or perhaps have a better idea.
Yvonne T.
July 8, 2013
Egg wash gives a shinier finish, good if you add sugar sprinkle on top as sticks better. Yolk gives more golden colour, whites more clear. Can beat whole egg then brush on. Milk or cream helps baking to brown (eg. scones, biscuits).
flowers4amy
July 4, 2013
I used 7 cups of mulberries instead of mixed berries and it was delicious! Does anyone know what the difference is between brushing the top crust with cream or egg? I used cream but an egg certainly would've been less expensive.
bricksoj
July 3, 2013
i made this last night just because it seemed like a good tuesday night activity, and it turned out FABULOUS. increased the fruit to 8c (3 pint packages of blueberries just didn't seem enough when i added them to the crust) and cut the sugar on the fruit to 3/4 of a cup, which was more than enough. the ratio of fruit to crust made it super easy to serve and far less messy than traditional pie.
TaffyIsVictory
July 2, 2013
Are there any recommendations on how to prepare/freeze this ahead of time?
Kristen M.
July 2, 2013
You could make and freeze the dough in advance (just give it a day to thaw in the fridge before you want to use it). Or you could make the whole pie and freeze it -- then just put it straight in the oven. It will take a bit longer to bake, but it should work fine!
Stephanie M.
July 1, 2013
Has anyone tried to bake this in a half sheet size?
Kristen M.
July 2, 2013
I haven't, but I think there might actually be enough dough in this recipe to work with (you just won't have as much leeway to trim it down). You'd want to bump up the filling proportionally though. Let us know if you try it!
Midge
July 5, 2013
In my rush to make this for a party yesterday, I unwittingly used a half sheet pan. I probably used about 7 cups of blueberries. It wasn't nearly as pretty as Kristen's but it seemed to be a big hit. Just had a piece cold from the fridge for second breakfast. Yum!
Gail V.
June 30, 2013
I have the same question as ATG117 - I'm making this now with nectarines, and wondered about the cornstarch.
See what other Food52ers are saying.