Make Ahead

Nigel Slater's Really Good Spaghetti Bolognese

March  4, 2014
5
19 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 10 minutes
  • Cook time 2 hours 30 minutes
  • Serves 4
Author Notes

A bolognese that works around your schedule—and might even be better than Nonna's, thanks to a secret ingredient or four. Adapted slightly from The Kitchen Diaries (Gotham Books, 2006). —Genius Recipes

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • For the bolognese
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 3 ounces cubed pancetta
  • 1 medium onion
  • 2 fat cloves garlic
  • 1 carrot
  • 2 stalks celery
  • 2 large, flat mushrooms such as portobello, about 4 ounces
  • 2 bay leaves
  • 1 pound ground beef or lamb
  • 1 cup crushed tomatoes or passata
  • 1/4 cup red wine
  • 3/4 cup stock
  • 1 nutmeg
  • 3/4 cup half-and-half or cream
  • For serving
  • 8 ounces Spaghetti or tagliatelle
  • 1 handful Grated Parmesan, to taste
Directions
  1. Melt the butter in a large, heavy-based pot -- then stir in the pancetta and let it cook for five minutes or so, without coloring much. Meanwhile peel and finely chop the onion and garlic and stir them into the pancetta. Peel and finely chop the carrot and celery and stir them in, too. Lastly, finely chop the mushrooms and add to the pan, then tuck in the bay leaves and leave to cook for ten minutes over a moderate heat, stirring frequently.
  2. Turn up the heat and tip in the meat, breaking it up well with a fork.
  3. Now leave to cook without stirring for a good three or four minutes, then, as the meat on the bottom is starting to brown, stir again, breaking up the meat where necessary, and leave to color.
  4. Mix in the tomatoes, red wine, stock, a grating of nutmeg and some salt and black pepper, letting it come to the boil. Turn the heat down so that everything barely bubbles. There should be movement, but one that is gentle, not quite a simmer. Partially cover the pan with a lid and leave to putter away for an hour to an hour and a half, stirring from time to time and checking the liquid levels. You don't want it to be dry.
  5. Pour in the half-and-half or cream a bit at a time, stir and continue cooking for twenty minutes. Check the seasoning, then serve with the pasta and grated Parmesan.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • FrugalCat
    FrugalCat
  • Melissa S
    Melissa S
  • Barbara Annemarie
    Barbara Annemarie
  • stefanie
    stefanie
  • Fran McGinty
    Fran McGinty
Genius Recipes

Recipe by: Genius Recipes

103 Reviews

Kay February 22, 2024
I really liked this. I used about a teaspoon of miso paste for sodium and flavor, just one bay leaf, no pancetta. Seems forgiving for a novice cook and I'm looking forward to playing around with it
 
FrugalCat January 17, 2024
Please don't call this one pot - another pot must be utilized to cook the pasta!
 
Jody January 15, 2024
This recipe is FABULOUS. The last time I made it, I used leftover milk from a potato-celeriac puree, so it wouldn't go to waste. That added a lot of flavor. It also freezes beautifully. Five stars, for sure!
 
Victoria C. January 15, 2024
I really love this recipe. I make it with 1/2 pound ground pork so it is more saucy (which is what I was aiming for), and I use Better Than Bouillon Vegetable Base for the stock, which add a lot of umami. I serve. it the English way - over spaghetti, which would make an Italian cry.
 
sabrinafair84 September 17, 2022
I’ve made this many times over the years and always come back to this recipe. I put in more vegetables and mushrooms than the recipe states and it’s always delicious. Great to freeze for a rainy day.
 
Paddy February 15, 2021
I think veal is the better choice for most sauces.
 
brandyk August 21, 2020
Just made this. Delicious!! Only tweak was to use less cream. I used 1/4 cup and felt that achieved a silky result. Loved the flavor the mushrooms bring to the dish.
 
Melissa S. May 12, 2020
This is amazing! It improves in the fridge for leftovers. I make a whole batch of the sauce and cook the pasta as I need it. If the pancetta is really fatty, I skip the butter. The veggies bring a beautiful depth, especially the mushrooms.
 
Melissa S. May 12, 2020
This is amazing! It improves in the fridge for leftovers. I make a whole batch of the sauce and cook the pasta as I need it. If the pancetta is really fatty, I skip the butter. The veggies bring a beautiful depth, especially the mushrooms.
 
Melissa S. May 12, 2020
This is amazing! It improves in the fridge for leftovers. I make a whole batch of the sauce and cook the pasta as I need it. If the pancetta is really fatty, I skip the butter. The veggies bring a beautiful depth, especially the mushrooms.
 
Melissa S. May 12, 2020
This is amazing! It improves in the fridge for leftovers. I make a whole batch of the sauce and cook the pasta as I need it. If the pancetta is really fatty, I skip the butter. The veggies bring a beautiful depth, especially the mushrooms.
 
Don M. February 12, 2020
This recipe is a "go to" comfort food recipe for me. I use passata and diced tomatoes to bulk it up, and serve it with No35 rigatoni.
I've served it to friends who love the aromas and simplicity, then ask for recipe. Versatile, simple and delicious!!
 
Barbara A. October 28, 2019
lovely recipe, split up the work over 2 days and it came out great. flavor improved over a couple of days in the fridge too.
 
halfdani October 19, 2019
Followed the recipe and came out super tasty.
Worth noting that it didn't come out as saucy or tomatoey as I thought it would.
 
Ethel B. May 12, 2020
It wouldn't. That's the difference between Bolognese ragù and ragù from other regions. Bolognese is more meat than tomatoes. And in Piemonte, they have a rage with identical ingredients except for the tomatoes. I couldn't wrap my head around that.
 
stefanie September 30, 2019
Swapped in chopped up rehydrated dried porcini and porcini stock (had some from a colleague that I've been trying to use up for ages) for the mushroom and stock in the recipe. Also added a tablespoon or so of tomato paste with the aromatics. Came out great - umami was through the roof. Will make again.
 
Katie B. October 3, 2018
Tested this recipe last night- good but not wowed. And I am hoping to wow my bookclub with this recipe.
It did not taste layered as described. Maybe more cooking between layers?
Served over rigatoni’s e and sauce got lost. Not thick enough?
Used contadina crushed tomatoes, homemade chicken stock and light cream. Tasted saltier than preferred, not sure why. What does tipping the ground beep into the pan mean?
Want to get this right!
 
Kristen M. October 5, 2018
Hi Katie! I'm so bummed this wasn't a hit on the first try. My first thoughts on how to amp up the flavor: It should keep improving and melding after a day or so in the fridge, so it could be worth making ahead and reheating. Be sure to salt enough to taste to bring out all the flavors, but not enough to drown them out. Let plenty of browning happen on the bottom of the pan in step 3 (but not burning!). And make sure that the vegetables are at least softened and cooked through, no longer raw, before moving onto the next stage (you could let them even brown a little, if you want). I fit still seems too thin, let it keep reducing down and it will concentrate the flavors. I think by "tip in", he just means "add to the pan" in his lyrical way. By the way, if you're looking for less of a ground meat texture and more of a shredded, falling apart one, this recipe is very easy and delicious (some people like to add more tomatoes): https://food52.com/recipes/39733-andy-ward-jenny-rosenstrach-s-pork-shoulder-ragu
 
Fran M. September 8, 2018
My significant other informed me he was no longer eating beef or pork, I used lean ground chicken left out the pork and this dish still shines. It was wonderful. He thought I forgot and used beef.
 
Louise A. June 23, 2018
I love this recipe. I go to it again and again. I have even used it in lasagne and everyone I've made it for love it.
 
Fran M. March 22, 2018
I have been waiting for a request to make this again. It just arrived, I knew it would eventually. I didn’t think it would take this long.
 
riverdwell November 25, 2017
I plan to make this, but without the spaghetti because I'm on the Keto Diet.
 
Loreal November 25, 2017
This is a recipe I return to again and again. I never add the dairy because I'm lactose intolerant, but it's fabulous!
 
Anthony B. November 22, 2017
Wow, this was totally delicious--a streamlined bolognese worthy of the name! Do not be put off by the commenters below who are worked up by some detail about authenticity. This is very close to the real thing, with much less trouble! Thank you Nigel!!
 
Fran M. May 31, 2017
The first time I made this I forgot to add the cream. Still delicious.
 
Fran M. May 31, 2017
This dish is Amazing no matter what should or shouldn't be in it.
 
Ethel B. April 27, 2017
I've been reading over some posts. I realized from the remarks about butter, cream, mushrooms, broth, that this is not really authentic Bolognese ragù. Olive oil is used to sauté the carrots, celery and onions. There is no broth, and just a touch of cream at the end. AND NO MUSHROOMS!
 
Christy C. April 26, 2017
I made this and substituted coconut milk for cream, since we can't drink milk. It was lovely, with no coconut taste. Thank you for sharing this recipe!
 
Nicole K. January 2, 2017
Ok perhaps this is a silly question... when making any recipe for bolognese, they don't call for draining fat off of the ground meat used. Are you supposed to drain the fat or leave it for flavor. I always leave the fat. Maybe this helps to prevent the sauce from drying out?
 
Kristen M. January 3, 2017
Not a silly question! It's a matter of preference, and how fatty the meat is—I've never spooned off the fat in this recipe, but if there was a substantial amount, I'd consider skimming a little off.
 
Renee B. November 19, 2016
I made this last night but discovered during prep that our mushrooms were not usable. The result was still delicious. I'll make it again with the mushrooms as we are both fans.
 
Caroline N. September 26, 2016
What kind of stock should I use? Beef?
 
JulieBee September 26, 2016
yes.
 
Rachel April 28, 2016
Thank you! I was able to use my leftover breakfast sausage tube in place of pancetta. Next time I might try to find an opportunity to drain off some of the fat but it wasn't too greasy either way. What it was, was delicious!! Easy too! I wasn't very careful when dicing my veggies I ended up with some rustic chunks. I have no idea how much butter I actually used but more than a cup of cream seemed like overkill when I reached that step so I just added in a dash or two to smooth things out. I put half in the freezer for another night. Can't wait to make this again!!
 
Ethel B. April 25, 2016
Aaaand, this is where I shine. This is my Forte after having lived in Bologna for 7 yrs. Yes, there are secret ingredients. For one, now get this, about 1/4 lb. chicken livers. Aaaaand a mixture of meats, 2:1, beef:pork.
 
Florence L. August 22, 2016
Germans always use beef:pork 1:1. I get deer legs and liver, so I mince deer meat and thanks to your comment, will be sneaking in some liver as well!
 
Margaret January 18, 2016
3/4 cup heavy cream is waaaay too much for my taste. With that much cream, there's no way it can look like the photo. The Bolonese is great with just 1/4 cup.
 
4376ab November 5, 2016
You're right, that much heavy cream is a bit much, but 3/4 cup of half and half is perfect.
 
Joe C. September 20, 2015
From just reading it, this looks like an awesome sauce recipe.
 
DrGaellon September 6, 2015
Couldn't find pancetta, substituted steak-cut bacon. Had three portobello caps in the package, so used all three. Added a tablespoon or so of tomato paste before adding the meat. Used about an extra half-cup of tomatoes (half a 28-ounce can). AMAZING.
 
Smaug September 9, 2015
It's your dinner to do with as you would, but smoked meats are all but unknown in Italy and add a jarring note to essentially Italian recipes.
 
Alexis M. November 21, 2015
Lol, wrong. Never heard of speck, I take it?
 
Alexis M. November 21, 2015
OR prosciutto affumicato
 
Smaug December 31, 2015
Sure, I've heard of speck- that's where the "all but" comes in. Speck is used to a limited degree in parts of the north, probably a Swiss influence, and has no place in a Bolognese sauce.
 
Smaug January 1, 2016
Prosciutto Affumicato (smoked ham) I have of course heard of, though never in Italian; then again, in the modern world you're likely to find anything anywhere. Poking around a bit, I did find it on one long list of Italian dishes, though no one seems to have any more information on who makes it, where, or how it's used(there is a smoked Dalmatian version, Prsut)- apparently someone in Italy did once smoke a ham; still, has no place in a Bolognese sauce.
 
Jeff A. April 15, 2020
Idiot
 
jstucky August 6, 2015
One of the best things I have ever made! So many of my favorite flavors to cook come together-- pancetta, butter, garlic, onions, mushrooms, red wine, cream. Like others mentioned, I also reduced the amount of butter and half and half and it still absolutely delicious!
 
Pablo D. May 22, 2015
Just one thing. What does 'leave the putter away' mean? Apologies for my ignorance, but I honestly only have a guess that it means something like only to stir it once in a while.
 
Kristen M. May 22, 2015
Thanks for noting that typo. It should actually be "leave to putter away" -- I just updated the recipe. Slater means that it should be left to simmer gently, and I think the rest of that step describes the way it should do that pretty well. Hope that helps!
 
Pablo D. May 23, 2015
Ha! Thanks for the clarification! I figured it was something like that. Great recipe though and it is good enough for me to want to fully understand each of the steps completely, which I now do. And my typing abilities are atrocious, so no worries there. Keep up the excellent work! :-)
 
Melissa May 21, 2015
A good bolognese- will it replace Ina's? Nah but it's just as good
 
Marina B. March 1, 2015
Perhaps it was the beef stock but my attempt was horrible.
 
Georgetown-DC February 15, 2015
With the temps in the teens this was the perfect dish to make for tonight's dinner. It's currently bubbling on the stove and it's oh so yummy. I used lamb and initially thought it was a big gamey but I've had it on the stove for about 3 hours now and the flavors have gone sublime! As for the half-and-half, I will add in small increments because the sauce is outstanding as is and do not want to overwhelm it. For dessert I'm serving Julia Child's free-form rustic Apple Tart with apricot jam,Grand Marnier and currents in the mixture with a side of Dulce de leche ice cream. If I'm going to break the bank in terms of carbs and calories, I might as well do it all! My neighbors are going to love me!!!!
 
Jonathan M. February 13, 2015
This recipe is loaded up with so much fat that it could be made of cardboard and it would still be "good". Consider: 4T butter + rendered fat from 3oz pancetta + rendered fat from 1LB ground beef + 3/4C heavy cream. This style of cooking, which uses fat to replace flavor, is the problem with much American restaurant cooking. This recipe is actually quite bland, because no specific amount of salt is included in the prep. If I make it again, I will trade nearly all the animal fat for olive oil, and add 2 tsp salt at step 4.
 
Smaug September 9, 2015
The food industry LIVES on fat, salt and sugar. One big reason to avoid bringing commercial perversions into your home- professional chefs have an entirely different agenda from home chefs.
 
Fran M. January 25, 2015
I made this last night and it was unbelievable, I loved it and will be making it again. That being said, I couldn't bring myself to eat all the fat so after cooking the meat I strained all the fat out. It was still fantastic. I did use the 1\2 & 1\2. When I make it next time I will only add 1 Tbsp. butter.
 
Smamfy January 23, 2015
Not Vegetarian as it's collection lists it to be?
Bummer!
 
Sam January 9, 2015
This was pretty darn good! I ended up using half the amount of cream, although I will likely leave it out all together next time since it was a little bit too rich for my taste, and it was so wonderful prior to adding the dairy anyway.
 
FavourFlavour January 8, 2015
Superb! I love the way this lets you chop the items in order and toss them in as you go - a great way to prepare. Followed recipe exactly as written. I let it simmer for 1.5 hours - served with fettuccine. So SO good, thank you!
 
procrastibaker August 3, 2014
I loved this! We made it last night, and it was hearty and delicious (perfect for summer in the Bay Area). I doubled the recipe and used half beef and half pork for the meat, which added some more depth to the flavor, and also threw in two teaspoons or so of crushed red pepper. Wonderful recipe, will definitely be making again.
 
Transcendancing July 18, 2014
Loved this, worth the time and effort most definitely. The sauce without the cream tastes incredible, and with the cream is a different kind of incredible. I'm very impressed by the flavour of the sauce - it reminds me of Bolognaise sauce but... also feels markedly different. I will definitely make this again for a dinner party of some sort. I used beef mince and home made beef stock. My stock is unsalted and I also found that I didn't need to salt the sauce at all - the celery I think does the job of salt very well in this recipe. I also like that it seems to be a fairly forgiving recipe in terms of amounts - I roughly measured the liquids, erring on a little more rather than less and ended up with the perfect ratio.
 
IMOm June 21, 2014
Absolutely delicious! Quadrupled recipe first time I made it for a big party & people were scraping down the bowl. Paws asked to make it for another party tomorrow! That makes u feel good!
 
dhyka D. June 10, 2014
I made this recipe just now, subs the cream with milk. and used combination of olive oil and butter. Amazing flavour, better than the one in the Italian restaurant. :p
 
jampot May 17, 2014
This was so yummy! I know we'll make it again and again. Made it to spec!
 
Janet May 15, 2014
accidentally forgot about the cream and just chowed down, thinking it was delicious, only to realize half way into my bowl of pasta that i left out the cream. oh well! just letting people know it's still good without the dairy!
 
ktchnninja May 11, 2014
soooo good! thanks for the recipe. followed exactly but found I needed about double the tomato/stock/wine mix over the course of 1 hour and 15 minutes. I did use the full 3/4 cup of half-and-half but would prefer it at about 3/8 cup to 1/2 cup. It was a little creamy/rich for my liking. However, the flavors were incredibly deep and rich. I also loved the texture from the carrots and celery. Great recipe!
 
tastysweet April 17, 2014
I noticed that all of the comments are separated from the main recipe page to the full recipe page. Any way they can be all in one place? Does this make sense?
 
gasgirl April 11, 2014
I only commented about the serving dish..asking who made them. I had not made the recipe....But..now..I made this sauce and loved it! So good and the mushrooms are the secret! Make it..you will not regret it!
 
m.juliusbrown April 11, 2014
Just made it. I really enjoyed it. Thank you.
 
JulieBee April 7, 2014
WOW! Made this yesterday and it was so easy, relatively quick and fabulous. The wine, garlic and portobello give this extra deep flavor and the cream tenderizes the meat to perfection. I added 1/4 cup cream and let that simmer with sauce until the end, then I added the rest for extra goodness. Superb, really, and all in just 4 hours.
 
gasgirl April 3, 2014
have a silly question...who makes the serving dish? thanks! great recipe!!
 
Kristen M. April 3, 2014
The plate is from Mud Australia -- we love their stuff.
 
gasgirl April 3, 2014
Thanks Kristen...I appreciate your responding...I love the bowl and will look on their site. Thought it was Heath! Thanks again!
 
gasgirl April 3, 2014
Ok...another question on the bowl...is this the nest bowl....do you know the size..is this a single serve bowl or the serving bowl/large? I do appreciate your help! I love their pieces and color selection!
 
Kristen M. April 4, 2014
I think it actually might be the salad plate!
 
gasgirl April 5, 2014
Thanks again Kristen...Wow...did not think this is a salad plate...although..the salad plate is flared ..and almost 8 inches in diameter..I think I will order...I like the mist..or the blue..what do you think? I feel like you are my personal shopper! LOL ....seriously..very appreciative!! love ceramics and pottery...especially Italian..but now mqy be into Australian!! Have a good weekend!
 
Lisa M. March 31, 2014
the cream kills the recipe
 
tastysweet March 29, 2014
I have used bucatoni for my bolognese. I like the heartyness of this pasta for this kind of sauce. If doubled, do we just double every ingredient?
 
Stella March 29, 2014
I would double most ingredients,yes! Made this with ground Turkey the second time(lamb the first). Really good with Turkey!!! I freeze it for another week. Works with many types of pasta but, I like Linguine.
 
Brooke March 21, 2014
"1 nutmeg" is the measurement here? ...teaspoon? pinch? a teaspoon seems like a lot, but anyone have any thoughts?
 
Kristen M. March 21, 2014
Check out step 4 -- you're just adding "a grating", but it should ideally be freshly grated from a whole nutmeg.
 
Patricia S. December 9, 2014
I'm just curious how much of the whole nutmeg do I use? Approximately how many "grates"? I don't want it to over power. Thank you.
 
Stella March 19, 2014
Didn't like Lamb so, will make it again with ground Turkey!
 
riverdwell March 17, 2014
Lamb? Oh please; don't suggest Americans use lamb in any shape or form. We'll take the corned beef for St. Patrick's Day anytime, too.
 
nicole W. March 17, 2014
What are the nutritional values of this recipe? calories, carbs, fat?
 
James E. March 17, 2014
stupid question. What kind of stock? beef?
 
Kristen M. March 17, 2014
Not stupid at all -- we used chicken because we had it on hand, but beef would be great too.
 
jlyn March 16, 2014
Have made this twice following the recipe to the letter. Delicious!
 
Nikki H. March 11, 2014
I followed this exact recipe except a paleo version. Used full fat coconut milk and almond flour fettuccine noodles. Delicious!
 
maryvelasquez March 9, 2014
Followed the recipe to the letter. Spectacular! Will definitely make again.
 
Mary K. March 9, 2014
can this recipe be frozen?
 
Kristen M. March 10, 2014
Yes, absolutely.
 
CarlaCooks March 7, 2014
I made this last night and it was great! It tasted so rich and meaty even though it's chock full of vegetables. I substituted a few things: I used 4 slices of bacon instead of the pancetta; I used finely cubed celery root instead of celery (I can't wait for spring, I'm getting awfully tired of getting celery root in my CSA box, but this was a nice way to use some of it); I used one can of tomatoes instead of the one cup of crush tomatoes.
 
CarlaCooks March 7, 2014
One more change: I added one thick leek, quartered and finely sliced, since it was withering away in my fridge. I added it to the pot when I added the onions and garlic.
 
Kerryloves2travel March 6, 2014
Super with green lasagna noodles. Try Delverde instant lasagna (no bake) egg or spinach.
Had in years ago in Italy & recently in Italian restaurant. Great to have a quicker version that is yummy. Salud!
 
Barbara O. March 6, 2014
We will be making it for dinner....I want to add that I love food 52, it is
inspiring.
 
Kerstin March 6, 2014
I made this last night for today's lunch. So easy and quick, and it tastes divine. Can't wait for lunchtime :)
 
Renata March 6, 2014
My boyfriend agreed on going to the gym if I make him this pasta! Thanks!
 
[email protected] March 5, 2014
Allergic to both milk & mushrooms. Worth it to sub olive oil for butter and leave out mushrooms and 1/2 and 1/2?
 
Cathy G. March 5, 2014
maybe sub soymilk.
 
JohnL March 5, 2014
From the description, the mushrooms seem to be a key ingredient. Can you think of something with similar texture that you can eat that you might substitute so you don't leave a hole in the texture profile of the dish? If you like moussaka, that dish has the beef/lamb option and always includes eggplant which gives that dish a nice satiny plush texture that you might be able to use to advantage in this Bolognese recipe without the portobellos. If I were trying it that way, I would buy the long slender eggplants that don't have as many seeds, peel and dice them for sure and cook them down a bit before adding to the recipe. You might just come up with something great! Nutmeg is wonderful with eggplant, too.
 
HalfPint March 7, 2014
If you are allergic to milk and mushrooms, it would best to make another meat sauce without either. I found this dairy free bolognese without the mushrooms. Haven't tried it, but it sounds and looks good. She used coconut milk and swears that you won't even taste it in the final sauce:
http://dairylandmashup.lanari.net/2012/05/28/homemade-df-bolognese-sauce/
 
Ziggy March 24, 2014
Yes yes yes! I didn't have mushrooms so I tried this with aubergine and it was delicious and silky, although if you aren't allergic to mushrooms I'm sure that their earthy base notes would be very welcome here as well. Excellent tip JohnL!