Father's Day
The Easiest Strawberry Shortcakes
Popular on Food52
17 Reviews
barbaspal
November 2, 2021
This isn't a review, but a comment: traditional and knowledgeable culinary experts like Alice Medrich UNDERSTAND that a GREAT recipe isn't the most complicated, it is one that gives the most bang for the buck! Greater nuance can always be achieved through more ingredients, but the most treasured recipes are ones that give a lot for less complication, not more. My 2 cents!
Loretta
June 5, 2021
I tried this last week when we had lots of strawberries. Since it was only my husband and me, I halved the recipe and made two biscuits that seemed a normal size to me. This let me know that I would double the original recipe if I actually wanted 8 biscuits. The flavor was delicious and the recipe is super simple and quick. I'm on my way to get some more strawberries for a little dessert party tonight!
Dorothy K.
May 29, 2021
We had some beautiful ripe strawberries, so I made the recipe last night with my three grandkids. Easy and good — but I made just four shortcakes and they were the perfect (and normal) size. The recipe calls for eight biscuits — from just 1 cup of flour!
Mar
February 13, 2020
I am an easy going cook, but a real New England’s when it comes to shortcake.
So a peeve - you can’t make strawberry shortcake with regular cake. That is simply strawberry cake. To be strawberry shortcake, you have to make it “short”.
Short means cutting in the fat, aka shortbread and shortcake. It’s a different and very special thing. :)
So a peeve - you can’t make strawberry shortcake with regular cake. That is simply strawberry cake. To be strawberry shortcake, you have to make it “short”.
Short means cutting in the fat, aka shortbread and shortcake. It’s a different and very special thing. :)
barbaspal
November 2, 2021
It is at least arguable that a cream biscuit is a lot more of a 'shortcake' than white or angel food cake! After all, the flour is cut into the cream here ;-)
Julie D.
June 9, 2018
Followed the directions exactly and was richly rewarded. These things went so fast I should have doubled the recipe!
Joy
July 16, 2014
Superb, easy to make, best of all shortcake recipes I have tried. Puréed some berries on top...not a pretty biscuit but fantastic. So simple!
lfkershner
July 14, 2014
Not a fan of this recipe - the shortcakes for some reason came out flavorless and hard
I took care not to over bake
They were also much smaller like cookies
I took care not to over bake
They were also much smaller like cookies
creamtea
July 14, 2014
I made these during the week--simple and good! I used blueberries. Next time I will make fewer but slightly larger biscuits, 4 or 6, from the same recipe.
nolu
July 13, 2014
Made this recipe tonight, so easy. Everyone loved it, and my husband had seconds. Thanks for posting this! I'll be making it again.
yaspas
July 13, 2014
I tried this recipe today and my shortcakes came out really flat! They still taste delicious but look more like cookies than cakes. I tried to fold the batter very carefully but perhaps I overdid it. Any suggestions for ensuring a fluffier texture?
Cherie777gll
July 13, 2014
Strawberry shortcake reminds me of my family at our cottage enjoying the summer. After playing all day in the lake this would be our supper. Shortcakes made from scratch smothered in fresh picked berries.
je S.
July 10, 2014
I have heard about strawberry shortcakes my whole life (48 years) and decided to make it tonight because the recipe looks so simple and I am an avid follower of Alice Medrich's recipes. Besides, with Oregon's fleeting strawberry season coming to an end, I wanted one last hurrah. My family thought it was GREAT! The not-overly sweet nature of the shortcakes really let the strawberry flavors shine through. Since it was my first attempt of trying out the recipe, I followed it exactly as written, and through my experience with Alice Medrich's recipes, her techniques and flavors are very reliable. Next time, I probably will make the cakes a bit bigger and will add some orange or lemon zest to add another dimension, as suggested by other bakers. Thank you Ms. Medrich and food52!
Emily H.
July 7, 2014
I've been making shortcake like this for years, but I also add a little fresh grated orange peel -- something about the strawberry/orange combo really elevates it. Also, no need to puree berries; just prepare them with sugar and refrigerate and it naturally creates its own syrup which is sufficient. Oh, and it's just not the same without vanilla ice cream.
cheryllk
July 7, 2014
It's easy to mash part of the berries with a potato masher, rather than make a puree (and dirty the food processor). Mash them with a little sugar to taste and a wee bit of fresh lemon juice, and let them set at room temp to juice up a bit while you're making your biscuits. Another key to the perfect shortcake: spoon a little of the mashed berries onto your plate or bowl and then put the bottom half of your split biscuit on top of that. Softens the biscuit bottom and makes everything perfectly yummy. (We take our strawberry shortcakes very seriously in our family.)
See what other Food52ers are saying.