Serves a Crowd
Italian Rice Pie
Popular on Food52
23 Reviews
Nalexis4321
March 31, 2021
I’m very glad I read through the comments before making this. Took the advice to use 2 cups of water and 1/2 cup Arborio rice. I let it bake for 40 mins- not an hour. It came out really good. The only thing is I remember my Nani’s rice pie bring a more cream color & not so yellow/eggy on top...either way it was good & I’ll make it again this week for Easter Sunday.
Dbp100
November 13, 2020
Frankly terrible. Way too much milk for the arborio. Ratio wrong. Cooking for 1 hour results in brown / burnt and dry heavy pie. VERY disappointing considering I have had a very good results with other recipes. This was sadly a waste of time, money and effort
cpc
April 10, 2015
I followed recommendations to reduce the amount of liquid (I used nonfat milk) to rice ratio. I couldn't find a 10.5 inch pie pan so I ended up rolling out the crust and using a biscuit cutter to cut small circles which I put into muffin tins to make small tartlets. The crust recipe was easy and perfect for the inept pie crust maker that I am. I filled the crusts to the top, baked them for twenty minutes and they turned out beautifully. There is a huge amount of filling left over so I will probably just make another batch of crust. The recipe seemed like a lot of steps at first but was actually very easy. The tartlets would be perfect for a pot luck or party. As the description said, they're only lightly sweet so adjust the sugar according to your tastes. These would be great for breakfast.
RBV1750
April 5, 2015
I followed the directions exactly....I then baked the pie at 375 for an hour. The result, was a burnt pie and extremely burnt crust. Also the rice and milk ratio appeared to be incorrect for the fact that after cooking the rice for 20 minutes, it never absorbed the liquid and was extremely watery. Sadly I had to dispose of the pie due to it's burnt appearance. I would love some feedback from the person who posted this recipe.
kumalavula
March 15, 2015
easy to make and really good with some tomato vanilla jam drizzled over it.
i like to make this once the cold weather and rain lets up here in seattle. it helps me welcome spring.
i like to make this once the cold weather and rain lets up here in seattle. it helps me welcome spring.
Lorenza
March 14, 2013
Do you suppose that MyGardenersTable (below) used the wrong variety of rice? I plan to prepare the recipe as written, with arborio and Whole Milk. Grazie, Mille Grazie
Pizzapie
June 5, 2012
The flavor was good, but really dense.. I don't if it was over cooked what. I cooked 1 hour and it was golden brown on top unlike the picture. We ended up putting raspberrys and heavy whipping cream on top..
Nadia H.
June 26, 2011
I just made this cake in a 10-inch pan. It is still warm but I can already tell from sampling the extra filling, which I put in a ramequin, that it tastes very good. However I had a problem with the amount of liquid to cook the rice. 4 cups for 1/2 cup arborio rice seemed very high (usually I use 1 cup arborio to 3 cups liquid), I could not imagine the rice would absorb all of it, as the recipe says, but I went along with it. After 20 minutes the rice was cooked but I had two cups of water left over. I drained it, and it was fine. If I make it again I will cook the rice in 2 cups water.
Ilalia
April 25, 2011
I just walked in on my husband eating another slice of this pie....I can't stop smiling! Let me explain. My husband loves custard anything, but I have always avoided trying to make it for him feeling I could never come close to satisfying his experienced custard pallet. Over come with a longing for a new Easter tradition to ease the shock of adjusting to being just the two of us again as empty nesters and missing our parents who have passed away, I bought all the ingredients for this recipe and planned to made it in secret ( for fear I would fail at it and make us more lonesome for family). My husband just asked me if I would make this for him every week. The directions were easy to follow and the ingredients were easy to find. I will be making this on saturday for sunday morings.
Hilarybee
June 4, 2010
Just joined and this is one of my first saved recipes! I'm of Italian descent myself, and my great grandmother used to make a rice custard, though not a pie. I hope this taste just as good =) I'm making it for a picnic tomorrow.
Koshamrock
April 4, 2010
This does sound like a tasty recipe, but I wonder if there is a weight-watching version? I plan to try some substitutes to see if I can still make a tasty dish.
pTsaldari
March 26, 2010
I am prepared to break with tradition for our Greek Easter and feature this at our Easter table. It looks, sounds and reads like a winner. Just voted for it as well.
Susan we luv ya pie!
Penelopi
http://ptsaldari.posterous.com
Susan we luv ya pie!
Penelopi
http://ptsaldari.posterous.com
Food B.
March 27, 2010
Wow! I'm honored. Greek Easter customs are as cherished as Italian ones. Thanks a bunch, Penelopi!
hyphenhermann
March 21, 2010
could i use a 9.5" deep dish for this recipe, or do you recommend a 10.5" tart pan? i can't seem to find a 10.5" pie dish. thanks!
See what other Food52ers are saying.