Make Ahead

Pantramvai (Milanese Italian Raisin Bread)

January  4, 2017
5 Ratings
Photo by Emiko
  • Makes 1 loaf
Author Notes

This raisin bread is unlike any other. In fact, it's half flour, half raisins. I first read about this Milanese bread (sometimes called the "panettone of the poor") in Carol Field's wonderful baking book, The Italian Baker. Pane Tramvai, or Tramway bread, as it's known, is what that Field calls “outrageously delicious.” It's also outrageously easy to make and is ideal for a beginner baker or for anyone who doesn't have any fancy kitchen equipment—a pair of hands is all you need.

The bread is soft and pillowy. The sweetness of the fruit is balanced with the slight bitterness of the dark brown crust. It keeps very well. If you can manage to wait as long as a week (highly unlikely), you'll find out it's still just as soft and delicious as when it came fresh out of the oven.

Many traditional Italian recipes for this include a step with a sponge (a pre-ferment) or call for sourdough starter. This recipe, which calls for active dried yeast instead, is much simpler and is based on Carol Field's recipe (major differences are that hers includes a teaspoon of malt and calls for doubling the recipe to make 2 loaves) from The Italian Baker, an excellent and well-researched baking book. This makes 1 loaf, roughly 12-inches long.

Note: I've added this note because some people mentioned that they found the dough to be quite wet. I have reduced the liquid but yes, it is a wet and rather sticky dough, though it also depends largely on how the flour absorbs the liquid (the flour I used for the photographs is an Italian flour, type 1, stone-ground and organic and it absorbed twice the amount of liquid here without being too soft or sticky). You can add more flour if you want a 'kneadable' dough, but you can also work with a soft, wet dough too. Don't worry too much about it in the beginning before the first rise. After the rise, the dough will be smooth and although still sticky and tacky (Carol Field describes it this way too), you can dust generously with flour and work it by folding it gently a few times and it actually becomes very easy to handle. Use your hands to flatten the dough, dust well underneath and on top, and dust between additions of raisins. It will work out quite fine. If you find it's too wet to sit up and flattens, you can try baking this in a loaf tin too, but it's quite all right for this to be long and flat, more like a ciabatta shape. That's one of the beautiful things about this very easy and delicious bread! Enjoy! —Emiko

What You'll Need
  • 1 1/2 cups (250 grams) raisins
  • 2 teaspoons (6 grams) active dried yeast
  • 1/2 tablespoon sugar
  • 1/2 tablespoon softened butter
  • 2 cups (250 grams) flour (I used stone-ground, unbleached all purpose flour), plus extra for dusting
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  1. Place the raisins in a bowl with enough warm water to cover; let sit for 1 1/2 hours. Drain raisins thoroughly, reserving the liquid.
  2. Warm about 3/4 cups of the liquid until tepid (stick a finger in it, it shouldn't feel cool or warm), pour into a bowl and stir the yeast and sugar into it. Let stand in a warmish spot in the kitchen for about 10 minutes or until the mixture begins to look creamy (even foamy if it's warm enough). Add the softened butter and about half of the flour. Stir to combine, then add the rest of the flour and the salt. Mix the dough by hand until soft, silky and elastic, a few minutes (note, depending on the dough you may find that it is quite sticky, dusting with flour can help you mix the dough at this stage but don't worry too much about the stickiness at this point, mix with a spoon if you prefer not to get hands sticky). You can also do this with a machine, but it's so easy and comes together so quickly I find doing it by hand to be the simplest and most satisfying.
  3. Place the dough in a large, olive oil-greased bowl covered with plastic wrap or a tea towel and let rise at room temperature until doubled in size, 1-2 hours, depending on how warm your kitchen environment is. In the meantime, pat the raisins dry and dust with a couple of tablespoons of flour.
  4. The dough should now be soft and puffed (and if previously sticky, now less so, though still expect a bit of tackiness in areas where not dusted with flour). Place the dough on a floured surface, flatten it gently and shape into a rectangular shape. Sprinkle about a third of the raisins over the dough and roll it up, tucking in the sides—it's best to roll it along the length so you have a long roll as you want to end up with a long loaf. Dust the surface again with flour, flatten the dough again and sprinkle over another third of the raisins. Roll up, tucking in the sides so raisins don't fall out. If it becomes too tight to work with, Carol Field suggests letting the dough rest for about 10-15 minutes (under a tea towel so it doesn't dry out), before adding the final third of the raisins. If your dough is very soft and still manageable, you won't need to wait.
  5. To form the dough, with the last addition of raisins, roll up the dough into a long, plump loaf, tucking the ends in well underneath the loaf. Lift the loaf onto a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Cover with a tea towel and let rise an hour.
  6. When ready to bake, heat oven to 450ºF (230ºC). Place the bread on a bottom shelf and after 5 minutes, turn the heat down to 400ºF (200ºC) and continue baking 30-40 minutes longer or until a dark brown crust forms. Cool completely on a rack. This is easier to cut when it is a day or more old. Stored wrapped in parchment paper, or in plastic, it keeps very, very well, at least a week but I've never been able to resist keeping a slice of this bread uneaten longer than that.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Bruce Damen
    Bruce Damen
  • Courtney C
    Courtney C
  • Two Trays Kitchen
    Two Trays Kitchen
  • Nora
  • Josée Khamlong
    Josée Khamlong

14 Reviews

leahshunt July 30, 2021
I've made this recipe many times exactly as written. It turns out great. I'm making it again today. The bread is naturally sweet from all the raisins but not dessert like. We love it.
Bruce D. November 9, 2019
I am going to try this recipe and knead in the raisins right from the start to make a loaf, rather than later. Tell you how it turns out. I want a more traditional raisin loaf. Like the raisin ratio❤
Courtney C. January 27, 2018
I’ve been missing Italy like crazy, so I’ve been going through a lot of your recipes this week. They are fantastic. This was perfect. So good and easy to make. Will definitely play around with it.
Two T. February 4, 2017
I loved this! I made a half-recipe. Just blogged about it.
Nora January 30, 2017
I am one of those people--don't like raisins. I do love chocolate chips, so I wonder if you tried that, mslarkin, and how it turned out. Did you make any other modifications? Has anyone tried other dried fruit--cranberries, cherries, chopped apricot perhaps?
Josée K. January 18, 2017
What a wonderful recipe! Easy to make and very delicious. I love to slice it, toast it and spread butter on top. And the bread does stay soft for a week. Thank you for the recipe!
Martin B. January 18, 2017
Hi Emiko, Thanks for this recipe. Just wanted to point out that, by accident, you have now omitted water entirely from the ingredients. I know you mention the amount in the instructions but some people might still find this confusing.
mstv January 13, 2017
Based on my experience trying this recipe as posted - if using American AP flour, I would start with 3/4 cup of the raisin liquid and add more as needed. One and half cups of liquid made a soupy mixture for me as well.
Emiko January 13, 2017
Thanks for the feedback!
mstv January 13, 2017
Thanks for posting this recipe - I really enjoyed trying this bread. I'd never heard of it before and it is delicious! Day three and it is just as good as day two (which is good because I made two loaves).
Jessica January 11, 2017
I think maybe the flour quantity in this recipe is incorrect because it makes a soupy mixture otherwise. I added extra flour until it made a nice dough and ended up with a beautiful and delicious loaf of bread. I will absolutely be making this again. Thanks so much for the recipe!
Emiko January 12, 2017
Hi Jessica! Mrslarkin made this recipe a week ago (before I posted this!) straight from Carol Field's book and noted that she also had a very wet dough. I even added more water to mine (this recipe) and it was as you see above -- soft but still easily kneadable, but I really quite like a soft/wet dough. I may do another experiment this week and adjust the recipe to help as others have asked about this too. Mrslarkin said she had to add 2 more cups of flour to the Carol Field recipe (note that this one above is slightly different) and notes here in this thread what kind she used:
mrslarkin January 13, 2017
Hi Emiko! I did not use the carol field recipe. I made this exact recipe. It was on the food52 site on January 4. I used King Arthur Flour unbleached all purpose flour. I did have to add an additional 2 cups of flour as dough was very very wet. Emiko's stone ground flour, as does any whole wheat flour, absorbs a lot more liquid. Next time I make this bread I will use less water. I also substituted chocolate chips for the raisins. It's a great bread!
Emiko January 13, 2017
Got it, thanks! Was confused because of the timing of the article coming out!