Popular on Food52
claireinaustin June 10, 2021
I've made this several times and it's a winner recipe for sure! We love it. I will only say that I found the coarse kosher sea salt made it to salty, so I switched to a regular sea salt and used a slightly lighter hand. And it all worked beautifully. This will be my default roasted chicken recipe from now on. Thanks for sharing a great recipe!
claireinaustin July 17, 2021
Sharing an additional comment, in case it is helpful: When the chicken reaches the second part of the cooking time, where the lid comes off the pan, I use tongs to flip the pieces over into the pan sauce, then flip them right side up again, so they are throughly coated, especially on top. Then back in the oven for the final 15 minutes. I've found this helps with browning and crisping.
Ann D. June 6, 2021
Absolutely, positively one of the best chicken dishes I have ever made. It works like a charm every time. I’ve only made it with thighs — will try a whole bird soon!
SKK February 4, 2021
This recipe is spectacular! Made it exactly as recipe stated. Unbelievably tender and the open sauce is amazing. This is a long time keeper.
Alpa P. January 12, 2021
The teens made it tonight for their dinner and followed the directions (except accidentally discarded the skin instead of just lifting and rubbing. Oh well. They said that it was a really good base but needed a bit more flavor. They did at Penzey's Ruth Anne's Muskegee Avenue Seasoning and Paprika on top of the chicken for a bit more depth. They loved the moisture and ease of cooking. So while our family may add some more ingredients, we learned a quick and easy way to cook, with minimal cleanup.
Craig K. January 19, 2021
Penzey's makes a liar of me every order. "Never use spice mixes! Who knows what's in there?" Then they send us a little envelope of French Vinaigrette mix or whatever, and we're like "How did we live without this?"
Maria S. June 17, 2020
I'm making this now.. Why salt twice? If you are rubbing the chicken with salt why put salt on again right before putting in the oven?
Jen V. June 26, 2019
I've make this several times and I like it more each time. It cooks while I play outside, with a little supervised broil at the end. It's so versatile -- I've used whole chicken, thighs, breasts, and a combo thereof. The pan sauce is perfect with the chicken, but last night I tossed it with some leftover penne to make an easy side, and today I'm eating leftover penne tossed w leftover roasted Brussels sprouts and tomatoes and some shredded chicken for a dynamite pasta. It is a real weeknight winner that tastes very sophisticated!
James B. June 18, 2019
Made this dish yesterday and all worked as described; favors were amazing and the chicken was very moist and crispy. The only negative was that using Thighs and olive oil produces a huge amount of very fatty oily liquid. Might reduce the oil or an oil wine mixture.
Katherine O. June 15, 2019
Really a challenge to get 8 chicken thighs in a 6" skillet.
Craig K. December 29, 2020
Huh. If only the recipe said something like "Choose a large pot with enough room that the chicken won't be too packed in—it should have a bit of room to breathe around each piece."
Heidi K. March 12, 2019
This was so easy. I even sent it to my 25 year old son and he is making it too. Needed to open the top and broil to get the skin really crisp
Annabel February 24, 2019
So I'm a little late to this party, and wow! this is now my go-to roast chicken recipe.
DC's P. February 21, 2019
Wow this is a great recipe. My only modification was that I didn't include rosemary - but the sage and thyme combo made for a very smooth and luscious sauce. I used a Le Creuset dutch oven that has high sides, which meant that the skin didn't brown very much but got me more sauce than with a less deep pot. Looking forward to trying this with a whole chicken. Thanks for a terrific recipe.
Jen V. February 6, 2019
Stop what you’re doing and make this. So simple and so delicious. The SAUCE, guys!
tin December 22, 2018
can this work with duck?
Kristen M. December 23, 2018
I've never tried it, but I'd be concerned that the fat wouldn't have a chance to render and crisp up. It might be better to stick with a recipe designed for duck, but if you decide to try it, please let us know how it goes!
Craig K. December 29, 2020
I've got a cold oven technique for duck that's pretty excellent. You only do this with legs and wings--season with salt and pepper, both sides, arrange them in a roasting pan that's just large enough to comfortably hold them, skin side up, put in the oven, set to 350 F, and come back in two hours. You get something that's almost like confit--incredible flavor--and crisp, almost parchment-like skin.
GordonW December 17, 2018
When you do you start the clock on timing? From the point the oven has reached 450? Thanks!
willbfrank November 13, 2018
This has become our favorite chicken dish...all seasons. Have made it with a butterflied whole chicken, thighs and also with cut up chicken. It just works great! And the dipping sauce it makes is scrumpcious! Grab a bagguet and dig in.
Stephanie W. November 12, 2018
Had to put my two cents in. This was delicious! I used 3 chicken breasts and followed the recipe exactly except for shorter cooking time. Loved the pan drippings, I added a splash of wine when I removed the lid. Also had to turn the broiler on to crisp up the chicken. I served with a potato and arugula salad with a mustard vinaigrette. I felt like I was eating in a French bistro! This recipe is a keeper!
kritt November 11, 2018
So looking forward to trying this! I just returned from the store with a 7 1/2 pound whole chicken (yikes!)...any thoughts on the timing for this size bird?!
Kristen M. November 14, 2018
So sorry for the delay—I saw someone answered your question over on the Hotline, too, so hopefully that was helpful. The most important thing is keeping an eye on the internal temperature and adding water if the good stuff in the bottom looks like it might burn. How did it go?
Michele G. October 24, 2018
This was absolutely delicious. I used a whole chicken. I put the lemons inside the cavity after squeezing them over the chicken. I ended up with less juice than I expected so I deglazed the bottom of the pot with white wine on the stovetop. Just perfect...my new favorite!
See what other Food52ers are saying.