Make Ahead
Dan Kluger's Roasted Butternut Squash with Spicy Onions
Popular on Food52
30 Reviews
kate
December 26, 2023
This fantastic, borderline-foolproof recipe made me feel like I whipped up a restaurant-quality dish, even after I sliced the squash too thin and overcooked the hell of it. Even as a bit of a pile of mush, the brightness and spice in the onions and the freshness of the herbs made this a standout. It paired wonderfully with smoked turkey breast and cranberry sauce and I can't wait to try it with other meals. Also perfect for cooking in advance (as noted) or while entertaining, since it's so forgiving.
Cheryl
January 1, 2022
The onions were too sweet to me; I had substituted 1 tsp of agave for honey. I would leave out all sweetener. Subbed pistachios, which I tossed in at the last minute. I liked those. Used vegan feta, but I don't think it added much, even though the vegan feta tasted good.
Carly F.
December 24, 2021
Great combination of flavours. I was a bit concerned that the onions were too acidic but they pair amazingly with the overall dish.
Joyce L.
November 23, 2021
Making it now. Tip: microwave each medium squash about 4-5 minutes! Cuts easy then. Just did it for first tim.
Tish M.
March 29, 2021
This dish was delicious!! I enjoyed every bite. I live alone and halved the recipe and still made three meals of it. (I added more goat cheese and hazel nuts, and pickled onions.) I hsve only made the squash one time, but I must admit I have made the pickled onions 5 or 6 times. Try them on your favorite hamburger sandwich, tossed with your favorite salad, or just as a garnish with your favorite fish. How about on fish tacos? My next taste fest!
Gypsa
November 25, 2020
I love this recipe! This will be my third year in a row preparing it for the holidays and it is a hit every time! It can be time consuming so I always prepare it in increments 1-2 days ahead. I finally found marjoram this year, super excited to add it in.
epicharis
November 24, 2020
This is such an outstanding recipe. I've done it a few times now, adjusting the cooking time/temp (I like my squash a bit more caramelized) and squash (koginut, delicata, honeynut, etc), but it's the combination of spicy onions, herbs and goat cheese that really makes the dish. And everyone comments on how beautiful and colorful it is! In the rare event you have leftovers, you'll enjoy it almost as much straight out of the fridge. I really can't recommend it enough.
Mary H.
December 31, 2019
I found this recipe to be so so. The sauteed onions are spectacular, and what is not to like about goat's cheese, hazelnuts, and the fresh herbs indicated? The problem is, the butternut squash has little flavor, and all of the other ingredients merely serve to counteract that. The salad is colorful, but that's about it. I do not cook squash that often. Is this the most one can expect?
richbusywoman
December 26, 2019
This time of year with smallish, young butternut squash, there's no need to peel 'em before baking.
amg
November 29, 2019
Made this for our Thanksgiving meal and, although a few thought the onions too spicy, that was not the general consensus (me included). I (sadly) couldn't use the nuts due to one family member's allergy to them and decided to substitute a honey chèvre for the regular goat cheese. It does serve many more than 8; especially at a Thanksgiving meal with so many other sides. We had 18 adults! I will definitely make this many more times. Highly recommend!
Erin N.
November 21, 2019
I love this recipe! It is so aesthetically pleasing and the flavors are amazing. I don't usually like nuts in my food, either, but I wouldn't leave them out! A little time consuming to prepare, but so simple. It helps that you can make it in stages, if necessary. I made this last year for Thanksgiving and I'm making it again. It makes a lot, especially if you're serving it as a side. I'll bring the full recipe to three different Thanksgivings. Consider halving if you don't have that many people to feed. Of course, I loved having leftovers and brought with some leftover turkey to work for lunch.
Achefwannabe
October 25, 2019
Saw this on Food52 channel on ROKU. I have an abundance of walnuts. If anyone who has made this, what are your thought on replacing the hazelnuts, possibly with spiced walnuts? Would the spiced walnuts clash with the spicy onions?
Erin N.
November 21, 2019
I would just toast the walnuts, I think you get plenty of spice from the onions.
Peggy
October 11, 2019
Instead of the butternut squash, use a delicata squash cut in half lengthwise and then sliced. As the skin is edible, you don’t have to peel it and the long ridges help it stay put when halving it. Also, the striped skin adds another layer of interest to the roasted slices.
Paula
January 4, 2019
This salad is so amazing that I do not want to share the recipe. I want to be the one who serves this dish to family and friends. I made it yesterday for family (minus the hazelnuts); everyone loved it! The colour, the brightness, the textures, the freshness, the taste... This is a signature recipe! <3
jennygcooks
December 26, 2018
Made this last month and it was amazing! I am totally keeping this recipe.
Kim
November 25, 2018
Easy to make and the spicy onions are an excellent accompaniment and took this salad up a notch. I am not a fan of hazelnuts yet I went back for seconds.
See what other Food52ers are saying.