Make Ahead
Chicken Pot Pie
Popular on Food52
8 Reviews
MarmonkHayes
October 21, 2015
Our family loves this recipe, and I make it often when it's cold out. It's so easy and fast. I add fennel and omit carrots - we're not fans of cooked carrots...
Molly W.
March 29, 2015
I have two baking right now with 22 mins to go. After only 10 mins, the crusts were deep golden brown. I whipped them out of the oven and covered them with tinfoil and back in the oven for the remaining 20 mins. I'm using puff pastry sheets just on top, not inside. I''ll cover them with foil FIRST next time, then uncover the last 15 mins or so. They smell heavenly! We have a nice cold glass of sancerre awaiting their release from the oven!
Passenger
October 15, 2012
I gravitated towards this recipe because it was casserole sized, not pie sized. Unfortunately, that was not the case... it barely made any gravy for the amount of chicken it calls for. As it is, I only used 3 chicken breasts 'cause otherwise, it would've been way overkill, even though I doubled the celery and nearly that of the onion. I also had issue with the amount of flour for the amount of stock and milk used... after 10 minutes of boiling and it not thickening, I had to add more flour to get it somewhat gravy-like.
There was a good amount for a deep-dish pie plate. The flavors are all there, just the proportions are a bit off... at least for my kitchen!
There was a good amount for a deep-dish pie plate. The flavors are all there, just the proportions are a bit off... at least for my kitchen!
campagnes
November 5, 2012
Thanks for the suggestions, Passenger! Now I'm in the mood to make this again.. haha.. good cold-weather fare, that's for sure.
Jodie
April 21, 2018
Make sure to use a quarter cup of flour. 3 tablespoons is not enough. Use only 3 chicken breasts. 4 will be too much.
Sagegreen
December 3, 2010
Just noticed this looking for supper ideas! Wish I had one here right now.
See what other Food52ers are saying.