American
Flakiest Pastry With Apple Purée & Vanilla Custard
Popular on Food52
17 Reviews
Smaug
May 10, 2023
This was just OK. I just made the pastry; I wanted to make hand pies, and this filling seemed like it would be too soft- pastry cream can work well with strongly flavored fruits, such as berries, but with apple I really can't see it; at any rate, I used some leftover apple rugelach filling. The pastry is sort of a hybrid; the amount of butter is more typical of a pie crust than a puff pastry. For a puff pastry, the butter is kneaded and mixed with a bit of flour, to try for a texture as much like the dough as possible; this skips that, but cutting the butter into pieces is an added step. Puff pastry takes a lot of time, largely because it is given refrigerator rests after each set of folds to keep the temperature (which of course profoundly effects the texture) and to relax the gluten formed by the fold and roll process, but it's really not a lot of work time. This simply skips that; worked OK in my cold kitchen and with the small number of folds (puff pastry is typically folded in 9s rather than 3s). By the last set of folds, springback was getting to be a little bit of a problem, though not serious. The end result is relatively few, thicker layers, and I don't think it was particularly successful;
yeasted pasties, such as Danish, work well with less folds. This did indeed come out with a crisp outer layer, but it's a bit thick and on the tough side, and the thicker butter layer bled a lot at all the cut edges (a lot in a turnover); they ended up more or less frying in their own butter. As to the baking instructions, they might work for a pie, but just too hot for turnovers; I usually cook them at 360 in a convection oven- I have a couple of pieces of dough leftover; I'll experiment with that. All in all, this is fast- at the cost of rushing things, but I can make a flaky pie crust faster and it makes for a better turnover.
yeasted pasties, such as Danish, work well with less folds. This did indeed come out with a crisp outer layer, but it's a bit thick and on the tough side, and the thicker butter layer bled a lot at all the cut edges (a lot in a turnover); they ended up more or less frying in their own butter. As to the baking instructions, they might work for a pie, but just too hot for turnovers; I usually cook them at 360 in a convection oven- I have a couple of pieces of dough leftover; I'll experiment with that. All in all, this is fast- at the cost of rushing things, but I can make a flaky pie crust faster and it makes for a better turnover.
Smaug
May 8, 2023
I'll have to try this, but just reading the recipe the pastry doesn't seem like any less work than standard puff pastry (which really isn't all that bad). It skips the rests between folds, so faster, but it could be trouble in a warm kitchen.
Bruce Y.
March 16, 2021
You should say “fold like a letter”, not “fold like an envelope.” You don’t fold envelopes, especially into thirds.
rutlamb1
March 8, 2021
Had some issues with this. The dough was extremely dry but I didn't want to mess with the recipe so I moved forward with it that way and wow, was it tough. I definitely overworked it in my quest to get it to the correct size. No rise at all, no flaky layers and the custard was grainy and separated during/after the bake - is that normal? I will say that the filling was delicious and I will definitely try again.
Smaug
May 8, 2023
This all seems to be rather rushed- a longer rest at refrigerator temperature might allow the dough to hydrate better- I don't generally measure water in pastry recipes, but this seems like plenty.
Nina A.
March 2, 2021
I wonder if I can use a TBS of my sourdough starter in these...What do you think?
Marbesner
February 28, 2021
Love this recipe! Flaky and delicious. I used almond milk for the custard and it came out delicious too.
Mark A.
February 21, 2021
Special and pretty straightforward, especially with the help of the video, which diverges a bit from this recipe (it's especially worth watching when it comes to slicing the butter for adding to the dough—what a great tip!). As a bread baker, I struggled to resist the urge to knead the dough, and yet my dough ball was initially less cohesive than Mandy's example in the video. I have a few things to work on, but it's definitely worth the effort to perfect. Next time I'll cook both apples and custard a little longer so they're firmer and less runny, reducing the chance that the filled pastry leaks (even though I sealed it well). The bottom of the pastry was a bit tough or overbaked so it might need a shorter time in my oven. But the overall effect was a delight—not too sweet, nicely French (a terrific balance of apples, butter, and vanilla custard), and definitely shatteringly flaky! This is a keeper recipe because it's such an easy and rather humble puff pastry with a dramatic effect.
Doreen W.
February 20, 2021
Flaky & delicious indeed! Watching her video really helped with this recipe. For the dough, I first made it with the cup measurements and it was too dry. I couldn’t combine it where it was a cohesive dough. So I started over and made it based on the gram measurements and it was significantly better. After rolling the dough to 10x15, I sliced the dough into smaller pieces to make personalize size pastry. It still came out flaky and delicious! I’m not an avid baker, this took me 3 hours to make since I took breaks to rewatch her video, so I agree the dough recipe is pretty foulproof :) after making it once, I think I can prob make this way faster next time. I recommend even for novice cooks!
Doreen W.
February 18, 2021
Will it still be flaky and dough portion will be ok if I cut up the dough into small squares? rather fold the entire dough sheet over the filling, I cover the filling with a small square sheet of the dough? Seeing if I can use the same recipe portion but make it into smaller personal size pastry bites.
Melissa M.
February 26, 2021
Although I haven't tried it, I imagine that will work similar to other rough puff pastry I've made. The only thing to look for is exposing the butter on the cut edges - too much exposure could lead to the butter leaking when it hits the oven. Good luck!
See what other Food52ers are saying.