American
Double-Chocolate French Macarons
Popular on Food52
21 Reviews
Stacia
June 2, 2024
These are amazing. My first time making and I learned a lot. Not perfect, but perfectly delicious. Don't be afraid to dump grainy almond flour (I dumped), don't overmix the batter (should fall in a thick ribbon) and let the piped batter rest until the skin is firm - if there's a lick of humidity it will take longer (I wasn't patient and mine cracked and didn't grow feet).
Next time I know what to look for!
Next time I know what to look for!
TM59
December 10, 2023
Is the batter supposed to be grainy?? I pulsed the almond flour in my food processor first. Then I shifted it to the 150 g that it called for. But it still came out grainy.
Holly
July 25, 2023
These just didn’t turn out. The batter was too thick and they ended up almost like brownies with a shell too.
Kyala04
April 12, 2023
A lot of reviews are saying it was too thick and I had a similar issue but the second time I made it, it was too thin. I think it's because of the almond flour I used, the first time it was a high-quality almond flour while the second time I used walmart brand. I noticed the second time there were a lot more bits of almond leftover in the sifter after sifting it twice while the first time I had barely anything there. So if you're making this for the first time and using high or low quality almond flour consider adding more or less depending on home much almond is left in the pan I added a tablespoon to the one that was too thin and it seemed to help but I'm still experimenting. I will update in the future if I find the right brand of flour or how much to do.
Sharpe4
March 29, 2023
This was my first time making macarons. I followed the recipe exactly with exception of adding 1/2 teaspoon cream of tartar in the egg whites. They turned out phenomenal!! Smooth tops. No cracks. Great feet. Delicious !!
FleurRousseau
February 20, 2023
I must warn everyone.
THIS RECIPE CALLS FOR TOO MUCH SALT.
I have been making macarons for 6 years and I have never seen a recipe with this much salt. When I tasted the macarons, they tasted way too salty. It could be because i used regular table salt instead of sea salt. I would do 1/8th teaspoon instead if you don’t have sea salt and you only have table salt.
THIS RECIPE CALLS FOR TOO MUCH SALT.
I have been making macarons for 6 years and I have never seen a recipe with this much salt. When I tasted the macarons, they tasted way too salty. It could be because i used regular table salt instead of sea salt. I would do 1/8th teaspoon instead if you don’t have sea salt and you only have table salt.
merlimed
November 12, 2022
Really bummed to go through all the work of making macarons to realize the recipe is wrong. Yes I measured everything on a scale and followed the recipe closely. As other comments said, the batter is way too thick. They ended up cracking and not having feet. Other parts of the recipe are also off ( beat on medium high for 5-7 minutes?!)
Murphyb
October 18, 2022
Is the amount of sugar for the vanilla macarons correct? I made the vanilla version and they were extremely sweet. But, as always, I loved your video. Your joy in baking is contagious!
Nitta555
January 28, 2022
I read all previous comments and felt like I had a 50% chance of it working out. I'm glad I tried it! Originally I felt like the batter was on the thick side but this was my first time making Macrons so I wasn't sure how it was supposed to look. I continued and baked them and they came out perfect! It's highly recommended to use a scale and measure exactly to the recipe. I'm so glad I decided to try this recipe.
Nitta555
January 28, 2022
I read all previous comments and felt like I had a 50% chance of it working out. I'm glad I tried it! Originally I felt like the batter was on the thick side but this was my first time making Macrons so I wasn't sure how it was supposed to look. I continued and baked them and they came out perfect! It's highly recommended to use a scale and measure exactly to the recipe. I'm so glad I decided to try this recipe.
Eddie
January 16, 2022
I made the vanilla variation and used the chocolate ganache filling. It was my first time making macarons and I don’t think I could ask for a better result. Everyone I shared the macarons with were impressed by the appearance and flavor, which is not the norm for my baking experiments. I used this recipe in conjunction with the related Bake It Up A Notch episode and I highly recommend watching it. Erin made me feel like I could do it, and I did! I measured all the ingredients by weight, and I wound up needing the whites of 5 eggs, so I recommend weighing them.
loosylou
December 3, 2021
This worked super for me. They were really fancy tasting. Love the bittersweet filling with the very sweet shell.
Kaiyasilly
November 29, 2021
The batter is way too thick! I’m surprised this is still up! I’m so disappointed 😢this recipe might need a touch up on the ingredient amounts because it’s like unbelievably thick.
Kaiyasilly
November 30, 2021
I think it needs another egg white or two. They looked almost alright but biting into them they were so dense. These are like brownies with a shell.
preba
October 18, 2021
I tried making macarons two times using this recipe, both times the batter was way too thick (even though I had previously measured all ingredients on a digital scale). I had to add an eggwhite or two to save the batter. Other than that issue, the macarons are lovely.
Nlc5175
October 18, 2021
Use a scale. Egg white volumes vary, as do egg sizes. You can’t get perfect proportions unless you use weights.
preba
October 18, 2021
I used a scale even for egg whites, I had exactly 140g but for me it didn’t work out as well.
Nlc5175
September 20, 2021
This is hands down the best macaron recipe ever. I use black cocoa, fill with salted caramel and ground pecans or hazelnut paste with mocha French buttercream. Thank you Erin! Your video and this recipe made me brave enough to make these. My coworkers are eating my experiments in flavoring. Macarons make everyone happy!
Tena
August 17, 2021
Don’t whip the meringue for 5-7 minutes at high speed. That long put it way passed the hard peak stage. I saved it with adding another egg white. Whipping at high speed only needs about 2-3 minutes.
ryanne334
June 7, 2021
Super tasty! Made vanilla and lemon versions of this recipe too, came out really well. Erin’s video 1000% helps.
See what other Food52ers are saying.