Make Ahead
Roasted Garlic Soup with Olive Croutons
Popular on Food52
Continue After Advertisement
15 Reviews
etrickey
February 11, 2025
First time ever making this soup, for a soup swap and boy was I nerrrrvous! I had the miso as suggested on hand, bacon just in case and shuffling through comments to see if anything else might make it flavorful. I had to double the recipe for the swap. However.... salting the onions, using that thick pot, patience and pepper were the secret. I let mine meld for more than 40 minutes and was tasting as I went and it did get better and better. This is not to be a complex soup, that's the beauty of it, the texture, the olive oil, cracked pepper.. letting it rest was vital. Do not skimp on quality olive oil, the other ingredients are inexpensive, go for the good stuff! I did make homemade croutons to accompany it just in case the participants needed some crunch. Did keep some green stems in the soup, as I read a review it increases flavor. Fresh Ground pepper, game changer.
etrickey
February 11, 2025
whoops! Wrong review for this particular soup.. this is for the Genius Cauliflower Soup.. :)
krikri
November 4, 2017
I also ended up with a small but tasty amount. Maybe it would be helpful to have a ballpark total quantity of liquids: water in with the roasting garlic + 3/4 cup water called for in the recipe + liquid from the can of tomatoes = ??
Maybe erring on the side of less-is-better gives a very flavourful result.
Maybe erring on the side of less-is-better gives a very flavourful result.
Van A.
December 22, 2013
I agree about the yield I doubled it and there was enough for 3 of us. I was also confused about the egg but now that is clear based on comments below. My wife and daughter thought it was absolutely delicious and so did I. I guess thats why we were disappointed in the yield. :)
Eleanor A.
January 3, 2013
Do you add the egg directly to the soup or eat it on the side?
PDXpam
January 3, 2013
I placed a poached egg on top of the croutons. Wonderful when the soft yolk runs into the soup.
PDXpam
January 2, 2013
I made this tonight as a special treat for my cold. Absolutely divine! For the liquid, I used the garlic poaching water supplemented by chicken broth. Worked really well. My only complaint if the yield. I doubled the recipe and got only two bowlfuls. We wanted more! Next time I'll at least quadruple it.
james R.
January 2, 2013
i'm confused too about the tomatoes. do you actually use the tomatoes or is it just the juice in the can that you use.
linzarella
January 2, 2013
It's just the juice. When I cooked this soup, I had just used a can of tomatoes for another recipe, and was looking for something to do with the leftover tomato juice. But it's a very flexible recipe, and in subsequent versions I've made it with both tomatoes and their juice, or used broth instead of the tomato juice.
fiveandspice
January 2, 2013
I've made this with chicken broth instead of tomato juice because I didn't have any tomatoes around, and it was quite delicious using the broth instead.
Simonelisa
January 2, 2013
I assumed you meant the water from roasting the garlic. You mentioned that adding the water would yield more roasted garlic pulp. I'm confused on that part now. I'm anxious to try this but thought I'd ask before I do!
linzarella
January 2, 2013
No, I actually meant the water left over from a can of tomatoes. But, as I mentioned in the headnote, any flavorful liquid would work, and I bet the water left over from roasting the garlic would taste great. However, there probably wouldn't be enough of it, so you'd have to add more of some other liquid.
fiveandspice
November 26, 2012
Hi! I want to make this tonight for my husband who has a nasty cold. I'm trying to figure something out though. You call for tomato liquid in the instructions but it isn't listed in the ingredients. Are you supposed to use it, and if so, how much, and where does it come from? Thanks!
linzarella
November 26, 2012
Woops, guess I forgot to list that. I used the liquid left over from a 14.5 oz can of tomatoes. Hope your husband enjoys the soup and it helps him feel better!
See what other Food52ers are saying.