Popular on Food52
4 Comments
Leah Z.
October 24, 2014
Sugar pumpkins are what I use to make fesh pumpkin purée. I substitute fresh for canned in every recipe. For pies I usually place the fresh purée in cheesecloth and let it drain through a strainer to get much of the moisture out. L. Or add it ice cream with appropriate spices for a pumpkin shake.
AntoniaJames
October 23, 2014
Do you have any thoughts on what variety of pumpkin to use? We've found that in most instances, the standard pumpkins widely available this time of year for carving lack flavor and moisture, making them unsuitable for cooking. But then, I see that for this recipe, you suggest using canned pumpkin -- quite unexpected, I must say, given the topic of the article. What types of pumpkins do you recommend for cooking? Do some roast better than others? And can butternut squash be substituted in each instance? Thank you. ;o)
ktr
October 23, 2014
I've always been taught to use sugar pumpkins for baking with. They are a smaller pumpkin with small yellowish dots on them usually (at least the ones I've seen have them).
ktr
October 23, 2014
Oh, and I haven't tried it but I would think that squash or sweet potato would be a fine substitute for pumpkin. It might taste a little different but should still be good.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.