Tips & Techniques
These Genius, 3-Ingredient Cookies Will Be Ready Before the Oven Beeps
From our new podcast network, The Genius Recipe Tapes is lifelong Genius hunter Kristen Miglore’s 10-year-strong column in audio form, featuring all the uncut gems from the weekly column and video series. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts so you don’t miss out.
Listen & SubscribePopular on Food52
51 Comments
Shawna
December 1, 2023
I made these cookies for a cookie swap at work 2 years ago. Shortly after, I quit. Last month, I started working there again, and so far 3 different people who remembered the swap have each independently approached me to ask me if I would make them again. The most recent person started with "You remember those ugly cookies you made that everyone thought would taste bad, but were actually delicious?" (Well, no one said any of that to my face at the time, but yes, I have already received several requests, and they will be made lol).
TLDR: MAKE THESE COOKIES. You won't regret it.
TLDR: MAKE THESE COOKIES. You won't regret it.
Khatri
February 14, 2018
Hi, we dont get sliced almonds where I live and these cookies are literally calling out and begging me to bake them:(.....what is one to do? Any tips on slicing almonds? Or maybe just smash them?
Jeff P.
May 1, 2017
The first sight of this recipe sent me down a rabbit hole looking for an almond slicer. I buy my almonds whole in bulk and would prefer not to buy pre-sliced in a bag, and slicing by hand is no easy feat. Research finally led me to a company in India with a great little gadget that has a flywheel and sits on the counter, not too expensive either. But apparently there are laws against importing appliances from India, dang. Why can't anyone else make something like this?
Sherry W.
March 22, 2017
I first made this recipe about 2 weeks or so ago..........and I've made it 4 times since then! They are so easy to make and that is a good thing since it only makes about 20 cookies. My best friend's husband is familiar with Dorie Greenspan and he thanked me for the recipe (he is a fine food fanatic). They taste like Paris, he told me. To me they taste like almond yumminess. I will try another nut when I get tired of almonds but I'm not there yet. Seems impossible that 3 ingredients could yield so much flavor although I add almond extract so I guess it is 4 ingredients. I may try adding cinnamon one of these times. Maybe now...........
Ann
February 14, 2017
Ok.....What did I do wrong to this easiest of easy cookies? Problems started when I opened the oven after 10 min to rotate the pans. There was a fair amount of watery egg mix that wanted to connect neighboring cookies to one another. Also, the cookies that were once FAIRLY circular were now very misshapen and ugly. Really ugly. I also needed to leave the cookies in at least 7 min longer than required. Despite all this they tasted pretty good, but bore little resemblance to the photo. HELP!!!! I want to make these again to serve to guests.
Julie
February 6, 2017
Thank you once again, Dorie! They look fabulous. Not only GF, but practically paleo as well. I bet these would take well to a variety of tweaks...maybe brown sugar, maybe coconut sugar, maybe granulated maple sugar...hmmmm...with walnuts...or pecans...or mixed nuts...yummmm.
JEANIE K.
February 6, 2017
JEANIEK. "Great little recipe!, If you've got a nut Allergy?, then don't make them!, If you Don't?, then Enjoy"!, Thanks Dorie!....XXXX
Ironstring
July 1, 2023
It is a fact of life, like death and taxes, that not everything is for everyone. This recipe may not be for the nut allergic, but it's a book for the gluten allergic, the lactose intolerant, and a wide array of other people who are under the vast umbrella of difference that living involves.
Packy
February 6, 2017
Bravo! These were so simple to make and they are delicious! They check all of the boxes. Yes I altered the recipe by using 1 less T of sugar and adding a pinch of almond extract....worth it!
Michele
February 5, 2017
A variation of this was in our local paper a few years ago. They were called Passover Cookies and so they are - perfect for Passover. The Passover Cookie recipe also included chopped up dried fruit. Easy and delicious!
nathalie
February 5, 2017
Umm.... this is a crowd pleaser for sure -- but pretty much identical to an Ottolenghi recipe from his first cookbook. I've been using that recipe since 2008...just want to give credit where credit is due
Gourmet T.
February 5, 2017
I made this but changed the recipe a little. Add 1/2 teaspoon of each cinnamon, cardamom and vanilla bean paste for enhanced flavor. Use 1 cup of almonds and 1/4 cup of almond flour to help with cookie structure.
Julie
February 5, 2017
Omg my ex boyfriends mom used to make cookies exactly like these, but with a few alterations. She used just the egg whites and added some orange zest, which added a whole other layer of flavor. DELICIOUS.
Katheryn's K.
February 5, 2017
Yes and just using egg whites makes them virtually fat free. I love the orange idea. I am making these right now and wish I'd read these comments first.
Julie
February 5, 2017
Exactly!!! So they are really a healthy cookie...or at least a healthier alternative :)
JEANIE K.
February 6, 2017
JEANIEK. They may be fat free, But Very "High Carb" level, with 6 Tabs sugar for only 20 Cookies!, that's the level you watch., fats/sugars together = carbohydrates., But 2 won't kill you!
Patricia M.
February 5, 2017
Will the recipe work with walnuts or pecans?
Nora
February 5, 2017
Yes. I found a similar method for cookie-making several years ago and have experimented a lot. Walnuts and pecans work, and a few chocolate chips never hurt anything!
BerryBaby
February 5, 2017
The recipe states 'two teaspoons' of batter for those of you wondering 'how much'. These sound really easy, has anyone tried making them?
Katheryn's K.
February 5, 2017
I just made, I actually used a tablespoon, but used just a little less than a tablespoon, easier for me. I also increased the temperature to 350 from 325 right off the bat, as it is they are taking much longer than 20 mins to get as brown and toasty as the photos. I'd say 30-35 mins in my oven at 350.
Katheryn's K.
February 5, 2017
Actually now after eating a few, I might add a little almond extra next time just because we love marzipan and it just feels as though it will extend the flavour, make it fuller.
Teresa
February 5, 2017
These sound delicious but very sweet. Am wondering if anyone has tried a few flakes of Maldon sea salt sprinkled on top?
Katheryn's K.
February 5, 2017
I don't find them that sweet once baked, they are super good, just make sure you bake long enough so that they are toasty brown.
Katheryn's K.
February 5, 2017
But you know what on second thought, just adding a pinch of salt to the batter would bring out the flavours more so.
Ann A.
February 5, 2017
I wonder if honey would work instead of sugar...anyone have experience with swapping the two?
Nora
February 5, 2017
I do not think honey will work. I've used this method for several years and count on the sweetener (sugar, Splenda, Truvia) to also act as a bit of a thickener so that the dropped cookies hold together.
carol
February 5, 2017
From the photo it appears that you don't much dough on the cookie sheet, maybe a teaspoon?????? Then press down with the fork. How long do you
bake them???? Kinda need to know this kind of stuff (especially being you say this is perfect for the 1st time baker).
bake them???? Kinda need to know this kind of stuff (especially being you say this is perfect for the 1st time baker).
Robbie W.
February 5, 2017
325 about 20 minutes. All your info is in the recipe. Click on the picture of the cookies. I think I will make them today.
Laura
February 5, 2017
(The "recipe-->" button (next to the photo) links you to the full instructions)
Nora
February 5, 2017
I posted elsewhere, I've made cookies by this method for several years. I do not press them down, just do drop cookies. But next time, I'll try the fork for a variation on the theme.
Join The Conversation