Can a Restaurant Cookbook Be *Great* If It's Not Home Cook–Friendly?

October 17, 2017

A great restaurant cookbook, in my eyes, meets the following criteria: Its subject is a restaurant with a good story behind it, told in a manner that evokes the energy of dining there. It is a gorgeous object. And it contains solidly built recipes that are functional for those up to the challenge.

Chicago chef Paul Kahan’s new cookbook, Cheers to the Publican, checks almost all of these boxes.

I’ve been waiting for this cookbook for a long time. Back when I started covering cookbooks about a decade ago, it was rare for restaurants outside of New York or maybe San Francisco to get book deals, and Paul Kahan was always my go-to suggestion for a chef who might produce a great Midwestern restaurant book.

Shop the Story

Kahan has no shortage of restaurants and bars to write about: his One Off Hospitality Group is responsible for Chicago favorites including Blackbird, Big Star, and The Violet Hour. But it’s the Publican that gets the cookbook treatment. Of course, the Publican is one of those magical restaurants that is simultaneously casual and celebratory, American and worldly, comfortable and electric. I’ve enjoyed my experiences at the Publican tremendously; the food is always killer.

Executive Chef/Publican co-author Cosmo Goss writes that the food at the Publican tastes like “you put too much sweetness, too much salt, and too much acid together and then tried to shove them all through a small hole.” It is a menu that takes inspiration from Belgium and France, with a good dose of flavors not typically found in those traditions. Think frites and sausages and mussels and charcuterie, all of it balanced with sumac or fish sauce or ramps or palm sugar or mirin.

The book—perhaps properly called a tome at over 300 pages—winds its way through the restaurant’s menu, from vegetables to seafood to meat to charcuterie to bread. It’s conversational: picture Kahan and Goss sitting outside the restaurant, walking you through every dish. There are stories galore, nods to chefs that inspire them (Suzanne Goin, Chris Bianco, Alice Waters), and much love bestowed to vendors and producers. There are insights into menu development, product sourcing, and cooking philosophy.

The fact that the Publican bills itself as a beer hall may lead you to think its recipes would be somewhat accessible, and indeed, a quick flip through the book reveals plenty of temptations for the home cook. The vegetable chapter in particular holds a great deal of potential, although it skews heavily towards spring produce. But I have to be honest with you: I had a really hard time finding recipes to test from this book.

There were recipes out of scale with a home kitchen. (Unless you’re the type to “ask your butcher for a 20- to 25-pound piece of 'pork middle,’” have them debone it for porchetta, and keep the bones for pork stock.) There were ingredients that proved impossible to find. (If anyone finds a U.S. source for peach olives, AKA immature peaches that have been cured like olives, please let me know.) And there were days-long projects that maybe I will get around to some day, but were not viable options at the moment.

Not all cookbooks—particularly restaurant cookbooks—need to be home cook–friendly. I can hear you right now: “What good is a cookbook if I’m not going to cook from it?” But I believe there’s a place for difficult recipes, be they cheffy, complex, esoteric, labor-intensive, full of hard-to-find ingredients, or all of the above. Cookbooks should cater to a wide range of abilities: just like there need to be books for folks who don’t know how to boil water, there need to be books that elaborate on the far reaches of cuisine. And as long as the procedures are thorough and detailed, home cooks can learn from such recipes, even if they don’t actually prepare them.

That is, of course, assuming they work.

Disappointingly, of the five recipes I did try, three of them were pretty flawed. An otherwise delicious cauliflower caponata mentions twice in the headnote how important anchovies are to the dish, but the tiny, salty fish are nowhere to be found in the recipe. The pork country ribs were perhaps the most delicious of all the recipes I tried—and certainly the most home cook-friendly—but they call for you to reserve one third of the marinade...and then never tell you what to do with it.

And then there were the pork pies. Very delicious, very porky, and very British, the pork pies are a slow-baked minced pie, heady with sage and something I had to order online called Vulcan’s Fire-Salt. But unfortunately, the hot water dough recipe just wouldn’t come together: there’s no universe in which just over a half cup of flour combines with 1 ¼ cups liquid (plus an egg!) to create a dough. Heck, this Food52 recipe for a similar hot water dough calls for 3 cups flour to 1 ⅓ cups liquid. I soldiered on, I added more flour, I ate tasty pork pies. But pastry recipes trade on their accuracy, and this one just wasn’t accurate.

Could it be a typo? Sure. Can I forgive a typo? Of course. But in combination with the other errors I encountered, it sure gives me pause when approaching the book’s recipes. Let’s just say I don’t plan on buying 20-25 pounds of pork middle for porchetta any time soon.

Publican lovers, don’t despair. There is a lot for you in Cheers to the Publican. The kitchen curtain is pulled back, through history and vendor tributes and kitchen philosophy. The recipes aren’t inoperable, they’re just a touch sloppy. If you’re the type to cook out of restaurant cookbooks, you’ll likely be able to make them work, and if not, well, the charm of Kahan and the Publican are what you’re here for anyhow.

It’s a book that checks most of the restaurant book boxes. It has verve and heart, it’s beautiful, at times it is wise. It’s good. It’s just not great.

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Olivia Bloom
    Olivia Bloom
  • Pernille Perry
    Pernille Perry
  • Stephanie B.
    Stephanie B.
  • Souhaite
  • Susan Adler Sobol
    Susan Adler Sobol
Paula Forbes has reviewed cookbooks for nearly a decade for sites like Epicurious, Eater, Eat Me Daily, and now Food52. She's currently working on a cookbook about the foods and restaurants of Austin, Texas.


Olivia B. October 18, 2017
Agree that there is something to gain from laughably difficult restaurant cookbooks! My cookbook club chose Yottam's Nopi as a chance to really push our cooking skills, and cook from a cookbook we probably wouldn't have touched otherwise. Although everyone griped about how long it took to prepare their dish, we all walked away learning something new. My favorite fun tip acquired: mix up crushed nuts—pistachios and pine nuts in this case—and melted browned butter and pour into a small baking pan (so your mixture comes up to about 1/4 inch) and let set until solid. Cut into rectangles the size of your fish fillets (halibut in this case), place on top, and then broil. Perfect, amazingly delicious crust!
Olivia B. October 18, 2017
Also, just noticed the recipe is on the site!
Pernille P. October 18, 2017
Having had the pleasure of dining at the Publican and truly enjoying it I am sad to hear the book is not of the same standard. Hopefully a 2nd edition will take care of some of the errors but until then I think I will stop at browing it at the bookstore rather than bringing it home.
Stephanie B. October 18, 2017
"...Publican co-author Cosmo Goss writes that the food at the Publican tastes like 'you put too much sweetness, too much salt, and too much acid together and then tried to shove them all through a small hole.'" I hope it's not how the co-author meant it, but this sounds like they don't even like the restaurant their book is based on! To me that just doesn't read as a compliment.

And I do think a cook book has to be home cook friendly, though of course as a home cook I'm biased. Who else is the target audience? Of course they can target different levels of skill, but 25lbs of pork? That has nothing to do with skill, it's just not feasible for the average home. If a chef wants to write a book about their restaurant, process, journey, food philosophy (things a home cook can learn from but not actually prepare recipes), I think that could be a really interesting read. But then write that book, not a cook book where the content is mostly recipes that most readers won't be able to make. Again, this is just personal opinion based in nothing but my own preference.
Souhaite October 18, 2017
Peach olives! I've been looking for these for almost two decades, since the bartender at a wine bar in DC told me those amazing things I'd been munching on were "fetal peaches"
Susan A. October 18, 2017
I am so disappointed to read this. Avec is my favorite Chicago restaurant. My son worked for One Off Hospitality for a number of years. I was going to buy him this book for Christmas.
BeyondBrynMawr October 25, 2017
I think it's disappointing, too (Blackbird used to be my favorite restaurant in Chicago, and then it switched to Nico Osteria ... and now it's Boka, which isn't a One Off Hospitality restaurant, but I still love The Publican). But given that your son worked for One Off Hospitality, he might still really enjoy the cookbook since, as the author of this review puts it, "There are stories galore, nods to chefs that inspire them (Suzanne Goin, Chris Bianco, Alice Waters), and much love bestowed to vendors and producers. There are insights into menu development, product sourcing, and cooking philosophy."