Magically Transform One Simple Dough into Two Beautiful Breads

November 21, 2017

This season, we're Making Magic, bringing you a series of easy transformations to embellish already-wonderful things, from cakes to mantels to trees. Today, we're baking bread (because you can and you should!). Slide back and forth on the image below to twist your way to some warm, buttery deliciousness.

Magic may not truly exist, at least not in the whole Harry Potter/Hogwarts sense. (Although I've never given up the dream that my owl-delivered school invitation will arrive any day now through my apartment window.) In lieu of broomsticks and wands, baking bread is about as close to magic as you can get. The transformation of a few modest ingredients into a warm loaf never ceases to thrill me, no matter how many hundreds of times I bake.

I understand why yeast bread baking can seem intimidating. Rising! Kneading! Shaping! I’m lucky to have grown up watching my mother bake regularly. She demystified the practice for me, showing me how little technique it requires (and how forgiving it is), instilling in me a lifelong love for the feeling of creating bread from scratch. Now the alchemy of flour, water, salt, and yeast is something I embrace.

The holidays are largely sugar-filled (hello, eggnog), so a savory bread can be a nice party trick to balance out all the sweet treats. My favorite recipe is deceptively simple. Simple, because the ingredients and method are easy. Deceptive, because the result is so sophisticated, most people would swear only a practiced baker could have made it.

Shop the Story

Start with one simple dough recipe, then, depending on how much magic you're looking for, serve either a beautiful braid or star-shaped wonder. You can prep the dough and braid it into a loaf that looks impressive, but doesn’t require much skill. Or you can turn the exact same dough into an herby, cheese-filled star bread (see the dough and two ways to make it by clicking the recipes below). Star breads have a special look, but when you break it down, you’ll see that you can achieve the shape just by stacking rolled-out circles of dough and a filling of your choice, then slicing and twisting it.

I work for a baking company in Vermont, and each month we feature a different recipe as inspiration for bakers. This month, we featured a sweet version of this star bread, and the comments and enthusiasm from home bakers have been heart-warming enough to bring me to tears. Discovering that you (yes, you!) can make something so exceptional-looking (and delicious) with your own hands is the best, and most magical, gift you can give yourself this holiday season.

Join The Conversation

Top Comment:
“This would be more convenient to carry, and can be made the night before! Thank you. And Happy Thanksgiving, Posie! ;o)”
— AntoniaJames

What's your bread game plan this holiday? Will you give one of these special loaves a try? Tell us in the comments!

Food52's Automagic Holiday Menu Maker
View Maker
Food52's Automagic Holiday Menu Maker

Choose your holiday adventure! Our Automagic Menu Maker is here to help.

View Maker

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • MaJa
  • AntoniaJames
  • Posie (Harwood) Brien
    Posie (Harwood) Brien
I like warm homemade bread slathered with fresh raw milk butter, ice cream in all seasons, the smell of garlic in olive oil, and sugar snap peas fresh off the vine.


MaJa November 21, 2017
Any experience with a sweet version? With maybe nutella?
Posie (. November 21, 2017
Definitely! I've tried it with every sort of filling imaginable. The important thing to bear in mind is that liquidy fillings can make it hard to twist the dough -- it's certainly doable but it'll look a bit less "clean". I love using Nutella or jam for the filling. Another great sweet option is cinnamon sugar: just brush each dough layer first with egg wash to help the sugar adhere.
AntoniaJames November 21, 2017
I'm thinking this -- the cheese and herb version -- would be fantastic baked tomorrow night to take with us on our Thanksgiving hike, as a little pick-me-up mid-way, along with a persimmon or apple. I've been looking for a good not-too-salty savory snack for hikes. This would be more convenient to carry, and can be made the night before! Thank you. And Happy Thanksgiving, Posie! ;o)
Posie (. November 21, 2017
Happy Thanksgiving to you! It would be perfect hiking fuel--sounds like the nicest tradition!