Why You Shouldn't Judge A Wine Bottle By Its Price

December 20, 2017

If wine is so fun to drink, then why is picking a bottle so stressful? In his latest book, The New Wine Rules: A Genuinely Helpful Guide to Everything You Need to Know, author and critic Jon Bonné breaks down how to buy, store, and enjoy wine in simple, friendly language. Here, he explains why a bottle’s price rarely reflects its quality.

Wine is almost never priced for the exact value of what’s in the bottle. A lot of opaque economics—from the cost of vineyard land to a region’s reputation—get in the way. And, of course, fair value is in the eye of the drinker.

There are wines that overdeliver (from places like Australia, Chile, the unknown properties of Bordeaux) and wines whose prices have outpaced whatever they can offer (California “cult” wines, some top Burgundies, and so on). Obviously, we all want to be on the first half of that equation, but there are times when spending dearly makes sense.

A few things to keep in mind:

It’s hard to find wines under $15 that are distinctive and made with care; it’s even harder under $10, a category in which most wines are made by big corporations. But it’s easy under $20. Few places in the world can justify a wine over $100. They’re only worth buying if you do your homework first (and that doesn’t mean just checking wine scores).

Shop the Story

The best values often come from places that have fallen out of fashion. Friends may question you, but once the bottle’s open, your smart taste will be evident.

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Linda Nevin
    Linda Nevin
  • Jon Bonné
    Jon Bonné
Jon Bonné

Written by: Jon Bonné


Linda N. December 22, 2017
Do you have any specific suggestions?
Jon B. December 22, 2017
best suggestion is to find a good local wine shop and lay out what you're looking for. a combo of Rule 3 ("A good wine store employee is your best friend") and Rule 40 ("Hunting for *just that wine* is probably a waste of your time.")