Popular on Food52
12 Comments
Katelinlee
December 21, 2017
I don't think the GMO mention was particularly negative, and there are other reasons to be concerned about GMOs besides the safety of the food item itself, such as increased pesticide use in the form of Roundup.
Reg N.
December 21, 2017
perhaps instead of throwing around the phrase 'genetic manipulation' or 'genetic modification' all blase like its the worst thing ever, use the term 'genetically engineered' which is what you actually mean? it really is sad that people use these terms interchangeably without actually knowing what they mean. its like anti-vaxxers all over again.
and just for the record, i do actually support genetically engineered foods, especially in this day and age with our dwindling resources
cheers
and just for the record, i do actually support genetically engineered foods, especially in this day and age with our dwindling resources
cheers
Calla
December 21, 2017
Thank you! I agree that genetically engineered foods have enormous potential to help solve issues related to land use, nutrition, and food shortages. And I really think that if people took the time to understand what genetic engineering is and how this relates to food they would see the advantage as well. Food52 and similar websites have a platform that they could use to help people understand this issue. If they don't want to do that though, the least they could do is not help spread misperceptions.
Jusika
December 21, 2017
Isn’t cross-breeding also a form of genetic manipulation? Very surprised to see such an egregious error on food52.
Valerio F.
December 21, 2017
Thanks for bringing this up! I looked into what you said, and an LA Times article confirms that there was no genetic modification used. To make it more clear, I've added a link to the LA times article in the text. Hope this helps.
Wes M.
December 21, 2017
So what's being modified in the onion that allows it to be tearless? Is it the genes or.....?
Calla
December 21, 2017
This is getting ridiculous right? I am begging food52 to please educate your writers and editors about genetics. It's 2017 for goodness sake. Genes produce observable traits. If you want to change the traits you have to change the genes. You can do this in a lab with precise gene editing tools or you can do it by cross-breeding . Either way you are modifying the genes, which is FINE. We have modified the genes of literally everything that we eat. Also, there is no evidence to indicate that modifying genes in a laboratory poses any more risk to human health than modifying them by "traditional" farming and breeding techniques.
Jeanne
December 20, 2017
I would love to try the sunions. Please send me info about purchasing.Thank you, Jeanne Fix
ks
December 20, 2017
Agreed, it's really disappointing to see anti-GMO sentiment thrown around thoughtlessly (and, as Calla notes, incorrectly) on here.
Calla
December 20, 2017
Wow these sound amazing! Just for reference though, cross-breeding IS genetic manipulation, its just a less efficient tool than what is used in labs. And as much as I love food52, I am very disappointing that they are helping to feed the fear and frenzy over GMOs instead of helping to educate people about science and agriculture. It's great to have an opinion, but we should all start from a place of knowledge and facts.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.