How to CookMarinade

Why We're Marinating Just About Everything in Mayo

6 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

Mayonnaise is a savior in a spread, a miracle in a jar, a genie in a bottle. Besides decking out our sandwiches and dressing up our grain bowls, it makes the fluffiest pancakes, the fudgiest chocolate cake. It can even remove watermarks from tables, stickers from jars, mistakes from the past.

I Tried It: Extra Fluffy Pancakes, Thanks to This Japanese Secret Ingredient

I Tried It: Extra Fluffy Pancakes, Thanks to This Japanes... by Valerio Farris

Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake

Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake by Posie (Harwood) Brien

With a little of this and that, it can also become your new go-to marinade. We love this for the same reason we love mayo on the outside of a grilled cheese—it stalls burning, bronzes evenly, and adds rich flavor. This idea hails from longtime contributor EmilyC, who developed the recipe with a grilled bread salad in mind. Her version includes: mayo, olive oil, lemon juice (and zest!), garlic, salt, Aleppo pepper, smoked paprika, and cumin seeds. Mix and done.

This throw-together sauce becomes the happiest place for summer squash and broccoli rabe, which marinate for half an hour, then get charred on the grill. In the recipe headnote, Emily writes: “The mayonnaise marinade for the vegetables creates a wonderful blistery crust....The marinade soaks into the squash and clings to the leaves and florets of the broccoli rabe, resulting in a delicious smoky char that perfectly complements the natural sweet-bitter flavors.”

Grilled Bread Salad With Broccoli Rabe & Summer Squash
Grilled Bread Salad With Broccoli Rabe & Summer Squash

Our favorite part: The recipe can be riffed on—all to taste, it’s just a marinade—and the application can, too. Here are some ways to play around:

Swap out the garlic

Call in another sassy allium. Try minced shallot, chive, scallion, or even our old friend, onion. Or, take another direction entirely and substitute fresh, grated ginger or turmeric. Psst, any of these can be included in addition to the garlic.

Replace the spices

Swap out the smoked paprika for sweet or hot. Replace the cumin seeds with crushed caraway or fennel seeds. Add in some cayenne or hot ground mustard for kick. Or, try a blend, like chili powder and za’atar.

Keep it saucy

Bump up the flavor—and/or the color!—by adding another condiment to the mix. Think dijon, tahini, or miso (a big dollop, in each case). Harissa or hot sauce (dash by dash, depending on your spice preference). Even a splash of soy sauce, fish sauce, or pickle brine. (That’s actually another trick we learned from EmilyC.)

One-Pan Roasted Chicken Thighs with Potatoes and Tarragon
One-Pan Roasted Chicken Thighs with Potatoes and Tarragon

Get started!

The mayo-based marinade possibilities are infinite, but here are a few of our favorites. Adjust as you see fit!

  • Boneless, skinless chicken thighs. Make the marinade with lime juice and zest, instead of lemon. Swap out all the spices for chili powder. Tuck it all into flour tortillas. Bonus points: Marinate poblanos and red onions, then grill those for the tacos, too.
  • Tomato halves. Swap out the marinade's cumin seeds for fennel seeds and add crushed red pepper flakes. Grill until the tomatoes slouch. Serve on buttered, open-faced bread.
  • Tofu slabs. Swap out all the spices in the original marinade for togarashi. Add grated ginger and a splash of soy sauce, to taste. Serve on steamed rice or peanutty noodles.

What’s your go-to marinade? Tell us about it in the comments!

Tags: Sauce, Grill/Barbecue