A 5-Ingredient Lemon Pasta with Just One Caveat

July 26, 2018

Today, cooking instructor Jennifer Clair gives us a super-simple recipe for lemon pasta, but in order for it to be sublime as opposed to just satisfying, it needs real Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese. In the following article, she explains why this is so important.

Let’s begin with some clarifying vocabulary: “Parmesan” is a style of cheese (like “cheddar” and “mozzarella”) and “Parmigiano-Reggiano” is the world’s best variety of this cheese, only produced in Italy, exclusively in Bologna, Modena, Parma, and Reggio Emilia. Its moniker is “the king of cheese,” and that is no hyperbole.

Almost everything in Italy is finished with a fresh grating of Parmesan, except spicy foods and seafood dishes (try asking for cheese to top one of these dishes in Italy; it is more than likely that they will flat-out refuse you). It’s sweet/salty/nutty flavor is an undeniable flavor enhancer to so many savory dishes.

Put your best Parm forward. Photo by Ty Mecham

But there is a big difference between Parmesans produced domestically (and in some non-Italian countries, like Australia and Argentina) are those from parts Italy’s famed Emilia-Romagna region. To understand the variables, I have highlighted the categories in which Parmigiano-Reggiano excels over its Parmesan peers:

Time: Most Parmigiano-Reggiano is aged for 2 years or more (domestic versions are likely 6 months to a year). This prolonged aging process not only helps develop the cheese’s tell-tale nutty and salty flavors, it also helps create beautiful, crystalline clusters within the cheese (a transformation of milk proteins), which adds crunch and character. For Parmigianos aged for 3 years (called “stravecchios”), it is better to nibble it in craggily chunks as part of an appetizer or antipasto platter, so you get the full benefit of its textural superiority.

Purity: Two words: “wood pulp.” Last year, that is what food scientists found mixed into tubs of pre-grated domestic Parmesan cheeses sold in the supermarket. I guess trees are cheaper than cheese, but when you buy a block of Parmigiano-Reggiano, there is no room for such flimflammery. Just 100% pure salty goodness. Leave those green foiled-wrapped canisters on the non-refrigerated shelves.

Oversight: Like with so many of the EU’s prized foodstuffs—champagne, aged balsamic vinegar, San Marzano tomatoes, prosciutto di Parma—there are specific consortiums in place to regulate their production so they are consistent in their superior quality. Parmigiano-Reggiano is one of these “protected designation of origin” foods (often labeled DOP), meaning it can only be called “Parmigiano-Reggiano” if its production follows the rigorous standards set forth by the consortium that oversees it. This includes strict rules for the location of the dairy farms and the diet of the cows that provide the milk; the weight, size, and color of the cheese wheels; the aging length; and its final texture and aroma. That is why every wedge of Parmigiano-Reggiano you buy is consistently delicious.

The Rind: This is how you, the consumer, will tell that the cheese you are buying is true Parmigiano-Reggiano: Every giant wheel of cheese is stamped with the words “Parmigiano Reggiano” over every inch of the rind, so no matter how small a piece of cheese you are buying, you will see some of the letters of the name. Without it, it is not the real deal. Also, save the rind! Because the rind is naturally formed during the aging process, it is completely edible. That doesn’t mean it has a great texture (it’s hard and a bit waxy), but it is packed with flavor. Slip it into your next vegetable soup, pot of white beans or chickpeas, or a simmering tomato sauce, to lend a saltiness richness. It won’t melt, so just fish out and discard before serving. Blocks of Parmigiano-Reggiano have a very long shelf life (usually a year after its cut, due to its low moisture content). It should be stored in the refrigerator in a container that allows it to breathe (like a plastic tub or glass container), and placed in plain sight, since you’ll want to grab it to season your dinner as often as you can.

We originally published this delicious and oh-so-simple pasta recipe in April 2018, but we're giving it another go. Why? Because it's summer and what better dish to eat than a sharp, tangy cheesy pasta dish that's as bright and vibrant as the late July sun. Share your favorite summer dishes in the comments below.

Join the Conversation

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Nikkitha Bakshani
    Nikkitha Bakshani
  • isw
  • HalfPint
  • Stephanie B.
    Stephanie B.
I am wild about food. And about my new cookbook -- Six Basic Cooking Techniques: Culinary Essentials for the Home Cook -- based on the most popular class at my cooking school in New York City. If you crave food knowledge, take a peek inside the book on the website above.


Nikkitha B. April 24, 2018
Adding to my rotation ASAP.
isw April 20, 2018
Re: Parm rind in sauce:
"so just fish out and discard before serving"
Are you out of your mind? That's a "Chef's treat" if I've ever come across one. Yum!
HalfPint April 19, 2018
I knew someone who would balk at paying $10 for a small wedge of parm reg. Even though I pointed out the incredible flavor, the long shelf life that did not come from preservatives (that small wedge could have lasted 3 months), she believed that the stuff in the green can was just as good. Now I can add that it's salted wood pulp. Penny-wise, pound foolish. There's no fixing that.
Stephanie B. April 19, 2018
I commend the restraint of anyone who can make a small wedge of good parm last 3 months. Is it possible to go through parm too fast? I'm asking for a friend.
HalfPint April 20, 2018
Obviously us parm reg lovers will consume in about a week but this was someone with insane ideas on dieting and nutrition (the ones that would make you roll your eyes and bite your lip).

No, you can't go through parm too fast ;)