Popular on Food52
13 Comments
Dee
July 7, 2020
The salt is too much! Will try to fix my batch but pretty disappointed right now.
S
July 7, 2020
I had a similar issue. I believe that the recipe writer is in Australia where flake salt (less salty) is more commonly used. I’m in the USA and attempted the recipe with kosher salt but it was too much. I haven’t reattempted yet but if you scroll down the recipe author gave some recommendations for when using non flake salt.
Dee
July 9, 2020
Hi S, thank you for the reply. I actually was able to half way salvage them. I drained the liquid off of them, cut it with half water, and added it back. They were still crazy salty, but more edible, lol.
BK
June 17, 2019
Just tried this recipe--it was awful. The salt ratio is WAYYYY too high--inedible.
It really doesn't take THAT much salt to make a safe brine.
It really doesn't take THAT much salt to make a safe brine.
S
May 19, 2019
I thought this sounded so easy especially with the easy ratio but I should have heeded the comments. This was the saltiest pickle I’ve ever tasted- completely inedible. We tried to salvage it by removing half the brine, replacing it with water and adding lemon zest and fresh lemon juice. It improved it a bit but the saltiness comes in STRONG regardless. There is something majorly wrong with this ratio.
Samantha R.
May 19, 2019
S, so sorry to hear this!!!
I might need to add the same amount of water to vinegar to the brine, as I didn’t take into account people using different types of salt. I always use sea salt flakes being in Australia, which are less intense. Usually I do 4 Tbs vinegar, 2 tbs caster sugar or honey and 1 tbs sea salt flakes. But if you’re using fine kosher salt I’d go for 1/2- 1tsp
I might need to add the same amount of water to vinegar to the brine, as I didn’t take into account people using different types of salt. I always use sea salt flakes being in Australia, which are less intense. Usually I do 4 Tbs vinegar, 2 tbs caster sugar or honey and 1 tbs sea salt flakes. But if you’re using fine kosher salt I’d go for 1/2- 1tsp
Minnie
January 31, 2019
WOW. These were inedible! I used white vinegar, sugar, and salt in the ratio you recommend and they were so salty and acidic, they went straight into the garbage, even after just 30 minutes of pickling. Is there supposed to be water included to dilute the brine? If so, how much?
Robert C.
June 18, 2018
WOW I must have missed something. I made these "quickles". They are SO salty they were inedible
They had good crunch but it was too late to rinse the saltiness. I used the 4-2-1 ratio--What did I do wrong??
I like the premise of quick pickles.
Help
They had good crunch but it was too late to rinse the saltiness. I used the 4-2-1 ratio--What did I do wrong??
I like the premise of quick pickles.
Help
702551
June 8, 2018
The undisputed world champions of the quick pickle are the Japanese who have developed the greatest appreciation for extended aged and quick preserved vegetables.
Their quick pickle recipes include salt, vinegar, soy sauce, mirin, sugar, sake, citrus (especially yuzu), kombu, but only a few of each in various proportions based on the cook's preference for a given dish. Sometimes the preserving liquid is cooked, other times it is raw.
One important step that the Japanese often use is "aku nuki" to remove bitterness. Basically, you salt the item, press it under a weight for 10-20 minutes and throw away the resulting liquid (which has extracted much of the bitterness).
I do this all the time with my favorite asazuke ("shallow pickle") made with sliced cucumbers and salt. I usually stick with a classic Japanese style and also use a piece of kombu and some citrus peel.
A related preparation is ohitashi, an item that is briefly steeped in a broth (typically a dashi based one). The classic here is with blanched spinach leaves, but many other items can be prepared this way.
If one is serious about these types of dishes, it is highly recommended to read a cookbook on classical Japanese cuisine. The Tsuji cookbook refers to five basic vinegar sauces and eleven vinegar dressings.
The range of items that can be enjoyed with a quick pickle/brine/sauce/broth is enormous, ranging from lowly turnips and radishes to fancy ingredients like kanisu ("vinegared crab" -- cooked of course), yet another classic.
Of course the simplicity of this technique will reveal the shortcomings of inferior ingredients.
Their quick pickle recipes include salt, vinegar, soy sauce, mirin, sugar, sake, citrus (especially yuzu), kombu, but only a few of each in various proportions based on the cook's preference for a given dish. Sometimes the preserving liquid is cooked, other times it is raw.
One important step that the Japanese often use is "aku nuki" to remove bitterness. Basically, you salt the item, press it under a weight for 10-20 minutes and throw away the resulting liquid (which has extracted much of the bitterness).
I do this all the time with my favorite asazuke ("shallow pickle") made with sliced cucumbers and salt. I usually stick with a classic Japanese style and also use a piece of kombu and some citrus peel.
A related preparation is ohitashi, an item that is briefly steeped in a broth (typically a dashi based one). The classic here is with blanched spinach leaves, but many other items can be prepared this way.
If one is serious about these types of dishes, it is highly recommended to read a cookbook on classical Japanese cuisine. The Tsuji cookbook refers to five basic vinegar sauces and eleven vinegar dressings.
The range of items that can be enjoyed with a quick pickle/brine/sauce/broth is enormous, ranging from lowly turnips and radishes to fancy ingredients like kanisu ("vinegared crab" -- cooked of course), yet another classic.
Of course the simplicity of this technique will reveal the shortcomings of inferior ingredients.
Jennifer S.
June 9, 2018
Totally agree about Japanese pickles, including the pressed oshinko. Delicious. I want to recommend also that the sweet component is optional in a quick pickle. I like most of mine without the sweet. Either way, quick pickles are great.
Join The Conversation