Popular on Food52
10 Comments
Smaug
June 23, 2018
Astounded that I let the expression "meditation app" slip by without comment; I can only suppose that the constant petty outrages of modern living have at last worn me down.
Smaug
June 22, 2018
Waterstones make the best edge ultimately (if you go out all the way to a high quality finishing stone,and don't forget the Nagura stone), but good ones are expensive and they require considerable maintenance to maintain flatness. I think a better choice for most home cooks would be the factory made diamond stones, such as the ones sold by DMT. They're reasonably priced, use water for a lubricant and are completely stable. If you want more, go for a good finishing Waterstone, but be prepared to pay in the neighborhood of $100 for quality. Unless you've actually apprenticed in a temple builder's workshop, you will likely have trouble maintaining an even bevel with hand sharpening, and it DOES make a difference. Inexpensive devices such as the Chef's Choice sharpeners can be useful in preliminary sharpening stages for maintaining an even bevel. There are some proprietary systems made for knives, too- I know people who have some very expensive systems that work very well, but I have no recommendations.
Dean N.
June 22, 2018
I recommend Wicked Edge USA, have a sweet $400 system with 100/200, 400/600, and 800/1000 diamond plate holders, gets my kitchen, hunting, tactical, and pocket knives scary sharp. Before I got carpal tunnel I hand sharpened with DMT diamond plates, 100, 200, 400, and 600 grits then would finish with ceramic crock sticks to knock off the burr. After my carpal tunnel I had trouble maintaining angle without pain, so for years before I got my WE USA system I relied on a crappy carbide pull through with ceramic pull through on the opposite side, made by Smith, had no other choice. Getting my WE was the best thing I ever invested in.
Hana A.
June 25, 2018
Thank you for your thoughtful and helpful recs, Smaug and Dean! I love hearing everyone's preferences; knife maintenance is so personal.
Smaug
June 25, 2018
Well, maybe- people certainly vary quite a bit in what they will accept in an edge, but and ideal edge will have no irregularities at all, and a microscope will show quite objectively the relative merits of two edges. At any rate, mention should be made of hard Arkansas stones. They've fallen somewhat out of style except among the huntin'/ fishin' crowd- perhaps because they use oil as a lubricant, which can be a bit messy, but they've produced excellent edges for a long time, and require less maintenance than Waterstones.
Dean N.
June 25, 2018
Smaug, I learned on an Arkansas oilstone as a youth in the Boy Scouts in the early 80's and discovered DMT diamond plates in my early 20's about '91 or '92. However after having carpal tunnel winter of '00/'01, I can no longer maintain angle without pain. Discovering Wicked Edge USA in 2011 brought the zen of sharpening back, hearing zzzzzck, zzzzzck, zzzzzzck again is pure bliss.
Smaug
June 25, 2018
DN Yeah, I know what you mean, I have days when I'd swear my hands were full of broken glass and things like this are out of the question. Fortunately for me, it's not every day.
Dean N.
June 25, 2018
Smaug, with me it was nasty numbness and tingling and couldn't feel anything else, and the tingling hurt like crazy. Fortunately I didn't have to have the surgery, my Dr prescribed me B6 and it helped, but I still have to take it from time to time to keep it at bay.
See what other Food52 readers are saying.