Amanda & Merrill

Retro Recipe: Baking Sheet Macaroni and Cheese

July 13, 2011

- Amanda

I've always thought macaroni and cheese's 20% crunch to 80% soft ratio was all wrong. The ratio should be more like 50:50. The soft part, delicious though it may be, wears you out. You need lots of crisp bits to stay interested in the dish.

In an effort to realign macaroni and cheese, I brought together three concepts: a baked pasta technique from Cucina Simpatica, a potato gratin method from Jeffrey Steingarten, Vogue's food columnist, and a similar method used by Melissa Clark for kugel. In Cucina Simpatica, pasta is par-cooked, then combined with cream, cheese and other seasonings and baked at 500 degrees. The high temperature finishes the pasta quickly and toasts the tips on the top layer -- a memorable detail. Steingarten's gratin involves roasting thinly sliced potatoes and cream on a baking sheet so that the entire gratin is crisp and handsomely browned. And Melissa Clark spreads her kugel in a baking sheet achieving a predominantly crunchy texture.

Back in the macaroni and cheese lab, I combined these three ideas by par-cooking the pasta, folding it together with cream and a few cheeses, spreading it on a baking sheet, and finishing it in a 500-degree oven.

The result was total success -- the muffin top of mac 'n cheese! Major world issue solved, at last.

A few cooking notes: this is on the creamy side, so if you want it cheesier....add more cheese! And add whatever kind you like. I used fontina and asiago because I happened to drop by Buon Italia this week, but since those cheeses are not as easy to find, I might do cheddar next time. You can also add some diced ham, crushed tomatoes or any seasoning, really. I just kept this one simple to focus on the technique.

UPDATE: I've retested this with a new cream-less recipe and think you'll like the results. See the recipe at the end of the post.

ROUND ONE: Baking Sheet Macaroni and Cheese

Serves 6

  • Salt
  • 1 1/4 pounds pasta spirals (or small shells or fusilli)
  • 3 cups heavy cream
  • 1 cup grated fontina
  • 1 1/2 cups grated asiago
  • Freshly ground black pepper
  • 1/2 cup grated Parmesan cheese

1. Heat the oven to 500 degrees. Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil. Add the pasta and cook for 6 minutes. Drain.

2. Meanwhile, in a large mixing bowl, combine the cream, fontina and asiago. Season generously with pepper. Add the pasta and stir to combine. Spread the mixture in a 11x17 rimmed baking sheet, shaking the pan to fill it evenly. Sprinkle with the Parmesan cheese. Bake until browned on top and crisp, about 15 minutes.

ROUND TWO: Baking Sheet Macaroni and Cheese

Here I've used Julia Moskin's recipe for Crusty Macaroni and Cheese and applied my cooking method to it.

Serves 6

  • 3 tablespoons butter
  • 12 ounces extra-sharp cheddar cheese, coarsely grated
  • 12 ounces sharp cheddar cheese, coarsely grated
  • 1 pound pasta spirals (or other small shape)
  • 1/8 teaspoon cayenne
  • Salt
  • 2/3 cup whole milk

See (and print and save) the recipe here.


Order now

A New Way to Dinner, co-authored by Food52's founders Amanda Hesser and Merrill Stubbs, is an indispensable playbook for stress-free meal-planning (hint: cook foundational dishes on the weekend and mix and match ‘em through the week).

Order now

27 Comments

tessa022707 July 15, 2011
Love love love crispy mac and cheese...I like baking it in a well buttered muffin tin. Top, bottom and sides of crispy goodness with a gooey center and there is no fighting for the edge pieces. And I always, at the very end, squeeze a touch of lemon into the cheese sauce. Not enough to curdle it but just enough to freshen and zip it up.<br />
 
cateler July 13, 2011
mmmmm ... crunchy crusty bits. the more the better! Everyone in the house fights for the top of the M&C and the corners of the brownies. If it wasn't 100 degrees this would be dinner - but there is NO way the oven gets turned on today. Bookmarked for cooler days - brilliant really.
 
Kitchen B. July 13, 2011
This is a GENIUS recipe - I love making dauphinoise but it takes forever. Thank you......Love it
 
lillian.spiller July 13, 2011
I'm a recent convert to mac 'n cheese so i've got to try this (and I LOVE the crunch factor) but i am dreading cleaning the pan. do you think i could bake this on parchment paper?
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. July 13, 2011
Yes absolutely -- you may not get as much crispness on the bottom but the pan will make you happier!
 
Helen's A. July 13, 2011
You may want to try using non stick aluminum foil. Reynolds makes some, I love it for any kind of baking!
 
AntoniaJames July 13, 2011
Or you can just soak the pan overnight. The little hard bits should come up easily in the morning. I suspect that the small amount of extra effort would be richly rewarded with the crunchier texture. This recipe and the photo are making me so hungry, just looking at them!!! ;o)
 
mrslarkin July 13, 2011
Alas, it's a crusty mac-n-cheese kind of day. Amanda, is there a way to print and save Round One?
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. July 13, 2011
Sorry, I wiped it out after I made this one because I thought it was better than round one. Give this one a try!
 
MrsWheelbarrow December 21, 2009
I made it - round two - and at the last minute, I stirred a handful of dry bread crumbs into the reserved cheese. It made the topping chewy/cheesy crispy as well as sandy crispy, if you know what I mean. Very wonderful. By the way, made a half recipe, and baked it on a quarter sheet pan in the toaster oven.
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 24, 2009
Thank you so much for playing around with this -- the breadcrumbs are an excellent idea. I'm going to try it next time. (Btw, did you ever see the story in Saveur -- or maybe it was NYT -- by Kelly Alexander about cooking in her toaster oven? She made everything in there, and with success.)
 
lastnightsdinner December 13, 2009
People, don't fear the heavy cream! At 6 servings, that's 1/2 cup per, which is not going to kill you as an occasional indulgence! If it makes you feel better, do what I do and have a big salad or a pile of sauteed or steamed greens alongside it. Balance!
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 13, 2009
Ok, time out! I think I've freaked everyone out with the amount of cream. So I'm going to re-work this, doing a straight-up cheese version and I'll report back in a few days. Stay tuned!
 
Helen's A. July 13, 2011
Thank you! The DH just got cholesterol results back.... Would love to be able to make this for him!
 
Lucia F. December 13, 2009
Made it for dinner last night. It was good! Used milk instead of the heavy cream. There was a little water in the bottom of the pan perhaps from the milk? The recipe I usually make adds 3 eggs to the dish. I may try that next time. But it was a big hit and quick to make! Thanks for sharing the recipe. There is a photo of the dish on my blog. The pan I used is really old, so it is not a glamor shot. But certain pans just last forever -<br />http://sowhatareyoumakingfordinner.blogspot.com/<br />
 
amreen December 12, 2009
can anyone tell me why my cheese sauce was more like a blob of cheese surrounded by milk ... oh i am so sad right now :(
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 12, 2009
Did you use milk or cream?
 
amreen December 13, 2009
milk ... i have a feeling it might have been too hot when i put the cheese in ... but i swear i've done that before ... the cheese turned into an albino slimer (ghostbusters) :(
 
witloof December 12, 2009
what a brilliant idea... i usually eat the top and discard the rest.
 
Lucia F. December 12, 2009
I am making this today! Might use low fat milk instead of the heavy cream...
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 12, 2009
Let me know if that works -- I wonder if the sauce will come together. Could be great, because my version is definitely on the rich side. I'm going to make it again with more cheese and milk instead of cream to see what happens.
 
MrsWheelbarrow December 11, 2009
I must try this immediately, waistline be damned. What a krafty <get it?> idea.
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 12, 2009
Thanks -- let me know how it goes.
 
Chef G. December 11, 2009
You're so smart. I've always liked the top of mac and cheese better, too, but never thought about a way to make more top, less bottom. Come to think of it, I'd like to figure out that ratio for my body, too.
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 12, 2009
If you figure out the latter, please do tell. We'd all love to know.
 
lastnightsdinner December 11, 2009
What a fun twist (har) on mac & cheese!
 
Author Comment
Amanda H. December 12, 2009
har, indeed!