What is a good substitute for condensed milk in a pumpkin pie for a lactose intolerant person?

Question

What is a good substitute for condensed milk in a pumpkin pie for a lactose intolerant  person?

Lynn T. · Answer

Just read this - how timely!  How much apple butter would you use for one pie - using 16oz of pumpkin?  Thank you!

lorigoldsby · Answer

Apple butter adds richness without the dairy. I also have that problem!

Cookie16 · Answer

Oops! I didn't finish my answer. That being said, I agree on about the coconut option for its richness. That will likely ensure you still have a rich tasting pie.

Cookie16 · Answer

I read around about best pumpkin pie recipes on Chow recently and most agreed that a REAL pumpkin pie, whatever that means, actually uses heavy cream.

merj · Answer

My husband is allergic to dairy and I use soymilk to substitute in my normal pumpkin pie recipe.  Cream of coconut (the sweetened stuff) is a good direct substitute for condensed milk and would probably be the best choice.

What is a good substitute for condensed milk in a pumpkin pie for a lactose intolerant person?

5 Comments

Popular on Food52

The Best Vanilla Extract Substitute Is Probably Hiding in Your Kitchen

11 Easy Dinner Recipes for When It's Been a Loooong Week

The 15 Best Pasta Salad Recipes to Make All Summer Long