Every time I bake a pie with a double crust it always comes out super watery on the inside, almost like soup, but the crust is always done. How do I get the thick consistency I am looking for?
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Merrill is a co-founder of Food52.
Usually adding just a bit of cornstarch to the filling will do the trick -- what kind of pie are you making?
thank you! well i've made many but they are mostly fruit pies. the last one was apple cranberry. i live at high elevation; do you think that would have anything to do with it?
I like to use tapioca rather than cornstarch. Directions are on the box. Amounts depend on the type of fruit you are suing. Are you venting the pie?
Yes, much better idea to use tapioca!
I also like to use tapioca to thicken fruit pies -- usually about 2 tablespoons per pie does the trick, maybe a tablespoon more for watery fruits. Instant tapioca works best.
Also make sure you cut some good-sized vents in the top crust to let the steam escape!
one helpful thing with apple pies i've found is to season the apple slices and then let them sit for a few hours to let some of the liquid release before putting the fruit in the crust. i also like tapioca, but i use tapioca starch.
thanks for the help!
Happier iced coffee, cereal, and cookies, right this way.
Almond Milk Taste Test
Food52 Staffers' VIP Prep Tools
Spread the Word
You Can Review Our Shop Products!
Cold Fried Chicken from Mom