Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Amanda is a co-founder of Food52.
Well, technically, you should have eaten it by the 12th. If the cheese smells bad or is turning pink and/or moldy, it's no longer good. However, if it looks good and smells good, then it's up to you!
Sorry -- to clarify, I was thinking consume-by not sell-by -- if the sell-by date was 1/12/12, then you have at least a week, and then I'd look for signs of molding/rotting that I describe above.
I would say that if it still looks good or if it was unopened, you could have any where from about 10-15 day. After that I would toss it.
But it was delicious! Really!
Chrissy Teigen's Everything Bagel Casserole
How to Book the Best Airbnb
Get Set for the Best
Easy Lunch Ideas
Stock Up on Essentials