Boiled the water twice and dumped. Used a 4 sugar to 1 water ratio. Brought the sugar up to soft ball temp and left peels simmering for 45 min. Peels were tough, too bitter and had a funny plastic taste. Any suggestions?
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
HalfPint is a trusted home cook.
Were they organic oranges? A lot of supermarket fruit tends to be coated in wax to keep them from drying out.
If not, maybe you have to much pith still attached?
My first thought was the same as HalfPint's -- pith could easily explain the bitterness. So might the type of oranges (Seville for instance). I wouldn't worry about any wax or other contaminants though. If there was any, it would have come off in the first boiling.
When I candy citrus peel, I let it sit in the syrup overnight. That might help.
I'm curious about boiling the syrup to the softball stage. I've never done that and, frankly, don't understand the purpose. Might explain the toughness.
I scrape the bitter pith always so most is off. add 1/4 tsp. cream of tartar and in soaking water. To the sugar syrup Add 2tbs. of corn syrup. After rolled in sugar and dried a bit, sometime I dip in chocolate.
hardlikearmour is a trusted home cook.
I've used this recipe to make candied orange peels which doesn't call for removing the pith:
I definitely like the 3 time blanch the best (and have done 4 blanches when candying lemon peels). There is very little bitterness, and the texture is great. Even if there is wax on the oranges the blanching step should rid them of it.
From backyard BBQs to beach picnics.
Trader Joe's Summer Party Picks
My New Jersey Boardwalk
Go On, Spread Out
Extra Chewy Sugar Cookies
Your #1 Loves