Can I make a pumpkin pie ahead of time? Like three days?

  • 88188 views
  • 6 Comments

6 Comments

Ryan C. November 20, 2018
For anyone interested in making pumpkin pie ahead of time, in general the day before should be perfectly fine. Personally I think 3 days is pushing it. Shuna's tips above are all great.
 
amysarah November 18, 2012
If you mean freezing the crust unbaked in the dish, I'd defrost it first (overnight in the fridge is easy.) Otherwise, I'd be concerned that when you bake it, the crust will still be underdone when the filling is set and ready to come out.
 
CarlaCooks November 18, 2012
Quick supplemental question: if you line your pie dish with the crust and freeze it, do you need to let it thaw before blind baking it, or can it go straight from the freezer to the oven? Would this be bad for the pie dish if it's made of glass or another non-metal material?
 
brandon November 16, 2012
these guys are totally right. I would roll out your dough, line the tin and throw it back in the freezer. make your custard base and leave that in the fridge also. then when youre ready prebake your crust, fill and finish.
 
ChefOno November 16, 2012

Also, the crust will soften and become distinctly less flakey with each passing hour. Bake the night before at earliest.

 

Voted the Best Reply!

Shuna L. November 16, 2012
You can make pumpkin pie ahead of time. Three days is ok, but a few things will happen to your pie which will change its eating experience. If time saving tricks are what you're after, I can suggest a few:
line, blind-bake and freeze crust until you're ready to make pie.
make the filling 6 days before you're going to bake pie.
bake pie the night before you are going to eat it and leave it at room temperature to cool down.
If you make your pie a few days in advance the filling/custard will dry out and pull away from the side of the crust. it will taste more dense every day it waits to be eaten.
I like to eat my pie at room temperature so I bake it the night before Thanksgiving. It's more delicate this way but I feel the flavors come through best if it's not super cold from the fridge.
Happy Holiday! I hope this helps!
 
Recommended by Food52