cream pies

I made 2 coconut cream pies (first time), they cooled overnight(7 hours) and they're still runny. Can I fix it?

  • Posted by: Miranda
  • November 16, 2013


Donna M. November 16, 2013
Unfortunately you can't fix this now. Did your filling contain eggs? If so, I'm pretty sure that the reason they're still runny is that you didn't cook it long enough. Eggs contain an enzyme, alpha-amylase, that if not totally inactivated, will destroy the starch network of your custard. Even it looks nice and thick when you pour it into the shell, any enzyme not inactivated will catalyze and re-thin the filling. In order to inactivate all the enzymes, the entire mixture needs to come to above 180 degrees (and this is the important part) all the way through. By the way, this has happened to me also! In fact, I gave up on cream pies completely, convinced it would never get them right, until I saw an episode of Good Eats where Shirley Corriher explained this reaction.
Monita November 16, 2013
No don't think freezing will make a difference if the chilling didn't.
Monita November 16, 2013
Have you tried chilling them in the fridge?
Miranda November 16, 2013
Yes; would freezing them a short time help?
Recommended by Food52