Thinking about making Rib Roast for Christmas using Ann Seranne's recipe from the NYT where you coat it with flour and S&P and place in a 500 degree oven for a time, then turn off the heat and leave in the oven for a couple hours. Anyone made this or have any great Rib Roast recipes? I certainly don't want to mess up an expensive roast.
Recommended by Food52
8 Comments
I prefer to cut the bone away and tie it back together myself. It makes me feel more like a professional, and it's often a few cents cheaper.
I've never done the "forgotten" rib roast recipe. I've heard from a couple of people who raved about it (including from the mother of a boyfriend in high school who coated her roast with wet rock salt, which was cracked off with a flourish before carving at the table). The only reason I've never tried it is because I can't afford to dedicate my oven to a single item for a holiday dinner--I'm constantly in and out of it with a pan of this and a sheet of that. Opening and closing the oven door even one time is strictly forbidden with a forgotten-type recipe.
If you decide to purchase a rib roast, the two most important tips I have are to make sure you spend the extra money and purchase a "choice" roast, not "select" grade (unless you like chewy, flavorless meat); and to make sure you don't shack up with a hillbilly from W.(by God) Va. who will only eat it if it's well done. Very well done, not even a little pink. So he gets an end slice, which I fry cut-end down, until it's "kilt," as in, "Is it dead yet?" That gene got passed along to one of the sons, dangnabbit.
I digress. Sorry for venting.
Here are some tips from a man who knows how beef should be cooked: Kenji J. Lopez-Alt worked (works?) at America's Test Kitchen. Once in a while, he makes the science of cooking a lot more fun with his reports from the www.seriouseats.com "lab". Go here to learn more:
http://www.seriouseats.com/2010/12/what-is-prime-rib-questions-how-to-cook-christmas-recipe-dry-aged-wet-aged.html
http://www.seriouseats.com/2009/12/the-food-lab-how-to-cook-roast-a-perfect-prime-rib.html
I dry-age mine for three days and use a rub of Diamond Crystal kosher salt, medium-grind black pepper, a couple pinches of dark brown sugar and very finely minced, almost paste-like, garlic.