what temperature to cook black licorice

I want to make the black licorice in this recipe: https://food52.com/recipes.... It says to cook to 240°, yet the recipe in Saveur (http://www.saveur.com/article...) from which this one was adapted, says to cook to 265°F. Any idea which might be right? Has any hotliner made this recipe yet?

  • 2208 views
  • 7 Comments

7 Comments

LevishRob September 2, 2014
You can continue cooking the black licorice until the temperature on the candy thermometer reaches 255º F
 
MrsWheelbarrow September 1, 2014
I chilled it in the 'fridge for 30 minutes then cut, formed (twirled ropes!) and chilled another 20 minutes. It looks adorable and tastes perfect. I'm not sure what type of food coloring was used, but I had "vibrant" food paste color and did not need anything like 1-1/2 teaspoons.
Answer image
 
Susan W. September 1, 2014
It looks sooo cute. I love the way you made different shapes. Licorice is my guilty pleasure.
 
MrsWheelbarrow September 1, 2014
I just made the recipe and took the mixture to 260°F. It's perfect.
 
Susan W. September 1, 2014
Has it completely cooled? Will you need to microwave it like instructed in the magazine version?
 
Susan W. September 1, 2014
Mrs. WB, I wondered that as well. I looked at the comments in the Saveur recipe. Lots of people questioned why they had the temp up to 265° when it's for a chewy candy. Maybe DFT noticed that and lowered the temp to 240°. I love chewy licorice, so I am going to go with 240°. First, I am going to look at other licorice recipes. :)
 
Tasha September 1, 2014
Ew! How about no temperature!
 
Recommended by Food52