Should I put my pumpkie pie back in the oven? I think it's too runny

I baked Meta Given's pumpkin pie for 35 minute but after 2 hours out it's still too runny. Would it ruin it to put it back in?

Posted by: inés
November 26, 2015

8222 views
5 Comments

5 Comments

Order Bynewest

newestoldestpopular

Threadsexpanded

expandedcollapsed

Ali S.November 26, 2015

Runny pie is a bummer. I'd put it in at a lower temperature for a gentler heat through—maybe 300°F.

inésNovember 26, 2015

Thanks, Ali. I will try that in a bit if it doesn't firm up (and cross my fingers it works!)

Sarah J.November 26, 2015

Also, custard pies often seem like they're too runny when you first take them out of the oven—a small circle in the center should actually still jiggle. It will set as it cools down (so you may be fine!).

Sarah J.November 26, 2015

How long has it been out of the oven?

inésNovember 26, 2015

It's been out for about 2 hours, so I was hoping it would have set more by now. I'll wait a little longer and then maybe put it back at a gentler heat if it's not better in an hour. Thank you!

Showing 5 out of 5 Comments

Recommended by Food52

Should I put my pumpkie pie back in the oven? I think it's too runny

5 Comments

Popular on Food52

The Best Vanilla Extract Substitute Is Probably Hiding in Your Kitchen

11 Easy Dinner Recipes for When It's Been a Loooong Week

The 15 Best Pasta Salad Recipes to Make All Summer Long