The question about stuff floating in olive oil made me wonder: where do you buy your olive oil? What brands do you use and for what? (It seems to me that you would use different oils for baking, sautéing and finishing.) What readily available brands (i.e., you can buy them in the grocery store) are high quality and what should you stay away from? And @pierino, you mentioned that you thought it was a mistake to buy olive oil at Trader Joe's--and their selection is confusing--why do you think it's all inferior quality?
Recommended by Food52
17 Comments
When I used to live in NYC, I used to buy Trader Joe's and the 365 Whole Foods olive oils for everyday use, and I was pretty pleased with both products. Fairway also used to sell a very good everyday oil.
Now I live in Canada, and my everyday olive oil is usually bought at the supermarket. Colavita is decent as is the Safeway Select Extra Virgin Olive Oil (gasp!). But I also like buying a premium olive oil at a specialty foods store for drizzling and finishing dishes. The two I have on hand now are quite wonderful: An Affiorato oil from Italy and a Kastamonitsa oil from Crete, Greece, grown by a local chef's family.
Voted the Best Reply!
Why is pierino watching Rachel Ray?
I like to use Stonehouse Olive Oil. Some of the flavors are delicious. Just for an experience, my trip to Eataly to see all of the regional oils of Italy was lots of fun.
With some of the smaller lables the flavor can be wildly inconsistent from year to year.
Some years ago, a good Italian friend who lives in Assisi took me to a frantoio out in the hills of Umbria. A very small operation where locals took their olives to be pressed. The olive smell was overwhelming and wonderful. Big stone wheels pressing olives. Good olive oils are as complex as any wine. Could be grassy, bitter, peppery and umami all in one taste.
I've never been a big fan of Trader Joe's. If you care about price, it's a good place to go and occasionally there is something there I like. They now have the purchasing clout to buy large quantities from oversea's producers. I've just never tasted an olive oil from TJ that I've liked.
And a curse upon Rachael Ray for the coinage "EVOO, that means extra virgin olive oil"----she had to explain it every time she used it. Huh?