I want to make this cake for my mother's wedding this summer, but I've done 3 test cakes and had the same problem each time: the cakes shrink away...
... from the edges and sink down once I remove them from the oven. While they're in the oven, they look like they're rising well and they'll form a slight dome above the top of the cake pans. But when they come out, even though a toothpick comes out clean, as they cool they shrink away from the sides and sink in at the top, so I'm left with essentially trapezoidal cakes that lack sufficient height for cutting into 2 layers each. People say they're very tasty, but pretty dense - more like pound cake. I've been using two Williams Sonoma Goldtouch 8" cake pans. I've done some troubleshooting of my own, to no avail: 1) absolutely no opening the oven during baking; 2) mixing flour & milk into creamed butter/sugar until just incorporated, not overmixing; 3) making sure to fold the egg whites very gently into the batter so as not to deflate; 4) using cake flour instead of AP flour; 5) getting an external oven thermometer to make sure my oven is really at 350 (turns out it does run cool, so I adjusted for that, but it didn't change the shrinkage problem); 6) making sure butter and eggs are completely at room temperature before beating. Is it possible that I'm not beating the egg whites enough? I struggle a little with deciding what are soft vs. medium vs. stiff peaks. Or that I need to adjust the heat of my oven lower or higher? Different cake pans? I'm at a total loss! Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
12 Comments
Good luck!
Something else I started doing a few years ago was doing the reverse creaming method for white cakes. Cook's Illustrated and Rose Levy Beranbaum have written about it. It's easier to do, leaves less to interpretation and works every time for me. You could easily adapt this recipe to that method (leaving out the cream of tartar). I ALSO never bake a white cake over 325F. But that's my preference.
And lastly, what others have mentioned, most cakes (especially leaner cakes), shrink away from the sides a bit. If you're afraid of under baking, you may be over baking...that will cause more shrinkage and collapsing because the proteins are constricting from over coagulation. So, bake until you have a little bit of crumb on the skewer or, if you have a probe thermometer, to 200F....that's the temperature at which most baked goods are done.
Good luck! I think you're on the right track. White cakes are perfect for wedding cakes because they're light but sturdy! Let us know!
My thoughts are more how to get a cake you and/or the guests of honor like for the wedding. So my ideas, like HLA's, are also work-arounds.
Do you have a reliable cake you've made before that you could substitute for the one that is giving you these shrinking sides and dropped middles? And then apply to that cake the raspberry & lemon filling/buttercreams.
Or, yes, turn to Rose Levy Beranbaum Cake Bible. I've made half or more of the cakes in that book and the recipes are reliable, delicious, beautiful. Many are like a little black dress, which you can serve simply or dressed to the nines.
Last, in the back of this cookbook there's a terrific section on wedding cakes, with professional tips and sources for ingredients and tools. No, I've not made a wedding cake from the book.
Good luck with the cake and congratulations to all!
You could try baking them with cake strips to help them stay level during baking. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aAtM2Gaf1Xg Whether this will prevent the sinking in the middle I can't say, but it would be worth a try.
If you can't get the cake recipe to work for you, then you could always use a different cake with the same filling and frosting. Maybe rather than making numerous attempts at this recipe you will be happier with a different, tried-and-true recipe. I've had great success with Rose Levy Beranbaum's cakes from the Cake Bible -- you could make her white butter cake and add lemon zest, or if you go with yellow butter or the golden almond cake. The other beauty w/ her book is the section dedicated to wedding cakes that helps you scale for the size pan you need. The book is definitely worth a gander if you are making a tiered cake.