The next time you make it (and I'm sure you will), try beating it a little longer before adding the flour. In a recipe such as this, the creaming step replaces the baking powder. To get a nice rise, you need to add as much air as possible to the sugar/butter mixture by, ideally, whipping it until you can no longer feel the grains of sugar. You incorporate even more air into the emulsion when you add the eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition. Those air bubbles give a lift to cakes without leaveners; it's what gives pound cakes their characteristic lightness combined with a dense crumb
Skooj, you might want to ask this question on the recipe itself. Julie doesn't follow foodpickle, but she responds to all comments on her recipe fairly quickly.
5 Comments
Room temp butter and adding sugar in small increments during creaming helps with that stage of the process.